Daily Comment (May 31, 2022)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with an update on the Russia-Ukraine war, where Russian forces continue to make progress toward their scaled-down goal of seizing all of Ukraine’s eastern Donbas region.  In other major news regarding the war, the European Union has finally agreed on a partial ban on Russian oil imports, helping drive up global oil prices so far this morning.  We next review a range of international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today.  We wrap up with the latest news on the coronavirus pandemic.

Russia-Ukraine:  Russian forces continue to capitalize on their superiority in the quantity of equipment and manpower available to pour into the fight, especially now that they are concentrating their efforts on seizing territory in the Donbas region of eastern Ukraine.  The Russian superiority in equipment and personnel quantities has allowed them to seize more of the city of Severodonetsk, despite their continued losses of junior officers and rank-and-file soldiers.  The Russians are also regrouping near Izyum to renew offensives towards Slovyansk and Barvinkove.  It now appears more likely that Russia will eventually achieve its scaled-down goal of controlling all the Ukrainian provinces of Luhansk and Donetsk.  Meanwhile, we continue to see growing domestic dissent within Russian military circles, claiming that the Kremlin is not doing enough to win the war.

  • As evidence that Europe’s post-invasion defense spending hikes will likely have staying power, Germany’s government and center-right opposition parties on Sunday struck a deal to write its €100 billion defense budget hike into the country’s constitution.  The agreement provides for a special constitutional fund to support the Bundeswehr until as late as 2026, after which the government is committed to providing the finances necessary for German forces to meet NATO capability goals.
    • In a sign that German citizens are now more open to flexible budget financing, if necessary, to fund high-priority goals, the new fund will be financed entirely by new public borrowing.
    • According to Chancellor Scholz, the new fund ensures that German defense spending on average will meet or exceed the NATO standard of 2% of GDP.
    • The deal also calls for administrative reforms to accelerate weapons procurement and strengthen German military operations.
  • On the sanctions front, European Council President Michel said the EU has finally struck an agreement to ban imports of Russian oil, with a temporary exemption for oil delivered by pipeline.  The ban would apply to about two-thirds of all EU oil purchases from Russia.  Focusing on initially banning only seaborne oil imports will spare Hungary, Slovakia, and the Czech Republic, which are particularly dependent on Russian oil delivered by pipeline.  The EU ban is expected to be finalized on Wednesday, but in conjunction with relaxed Chinese pandemic restrictions, it is already helping boost global oil prices.
    • The partial ban risks distorting competition in the EU oil market, with refineries connected to pipelines from Russia enjoying a price advantage.
    • Hungarian oil group Mol (MOL.BD, 2,646.00) says it has enjoyed “skyrocketing” margins for its refineries since March because of the widening Brent-Ural spread.
  • In further disruptions to the global energy markets, major natural gas traders in the Netherlands and Denmark said they expect Russia to stop shipments to them as early as today, following their governments’ refusal to pay Russia in rubles in violation of EU sanctions.
    • The Netherlands and Denmark would join Finland, Poland, and Bulgaria in having their supplies of Russian gas turned off.
    • Those countries account for 16% of the volume Russia was contracted to deliver to Europe at the start of the year and now be sourced elsewhere.

Eurozone Inflation:  As shown in the data tables below, the Eurozone’s May Consumer Price Index (CPI) was up a record 8.1% from the same month one year earlier, far above both the expected inflation rate of 7.7% and the April rate of 7.4%.  Excluding the volatile food and energy components, the zone’s May Core CPI was up a worse-than-expected 3.8% compared with 3.4% in the year to April.

  • Although top ECB officials have recently said they plan to hike interest rates by just 25 basis points at upcoming meetings, the soaring inflation rate could force the policymakers to impose some 50-basis-point hikes.
  • If the ECB signals a faster rate hike pace, it will likely produce additional headwinds for Eurozone equities, although it could also boost the euro.

United Kingdom:  Almost ten more Conservative Party members of parliament have said they submitted letters of no confidence in Prime Minister Johnson, following last week’s report accusing him of breaking pandemic social distancing rules and the government’s tardy release of an inflation-relief program.

  • That brings the number of publicly known letters to 34, although some observers believe unacknowledged letters would bring the total close to 50.
  • A vote of no confidence that could topple Johnson would be required if the number of letters reached 54.

China-South Pacific:  A summit of South Pacific island nations yesterday deferred a decision on endorsing China’s proposed “China-Pacific Island Countries Common Development Vision,” at least temporarily setting back China’s effort to bring those countries under its influence.  While some South Pacific nations have been open to China’s overtures (including the Solomon Islands, which has just signed a new security agreement with Beijing), others remain wary of Chinese influence and are concerned that China is not working hard enough to limit global warming, which is a major threat to their low-lying territories.

  • Under Beijing’s proposed program, China would:
    • Help train police and diplomats from Pacific Island nations.
    • Set up Confucius Institutes, which in other countries have funded language studies but also have disseminated Beijing’s views on certain issues.
    • Provide aid, including new border-control technology and further infrastructure funding under China’s controversial Belt and Road Initiative.
    • Deepen cooperation in industries such as fisheries.
    • Promote rules for data security.
  • The U.S. and its key allies, including Australia, have belatedly been working to counter China’s move in the region, including measures through the Biden administration’s limited new Indo-Pacific Economic Framework.

Israel-United Arab Emirates:  The governments of Israel and the UAE signed a free-trade agreement today, boosting business ties less than two years after they established formal diplomatic relations in a U.S.-brokered deal.  The deal will cut tariffs and otherwise loosen restrictions on some 96% of trade between the two countries.

Colombia:  Leftist former guerilla Gustavo Petro won the first round of Colombia’s presidential election on Sunday with 40.3% of the vote, followed by populist right-wing real estate tycoon Rodolfo Hernández with 28.1%.  The two will now compete in a June 19 run-off election.

  • As in many countries around the world in recent years, the results are a rebuke to the country’s traditional centrist politicians, who are widely scorned for failing to end problems like poverty and drug violence.
  • While Petro and Hernández would probably both scare some investors away from Colombian assets, Petro may be the greatest risk, given his pledges to insert the state into Colombia’s market economy, heavily tax the rich, and move the country away from its dependence on oil and coal.

U.S. Monetary Policy:  The White House announced that President Biden will meet today with Federal Reserve Chair Powell to discuss the state of the U.S. and global economies.  The president has pledged not to try to influence Fed policy, but he has broadly supported the Fed’s plans to withdraw stimulus and fight inflation.

  • Separately, Fed board member Waller yesterday said he would support raising interest rates in half-percentage-point increments for several more meetings, adding that he wouldn’t take such increases “off the table until I see inflation coming down closer to our 2% target.”  The statements put Waller on the hawkish side of Fed policymakers, given that their public comments recently have centered on 50-basis-point hikes only at the policy meetings in June and July.
  • In one sign that the Fed’s rate hikes are having their desired effect, the developing weakness in the housing market has pushed lumber prices dramatically lower.  Lumber futures for July delivery recently traded at $695.10 per thousand board feet, down 52% from their high in early March. On-the-spot wood prices have plunged, too. Cash prices fell about 12% last week to end at $794, down from $1,334 in March.
  • In another development, investors are increasingly worried that the Fed will soon start to sell its holdings of agency mortgage-backed securities.  That fear has pushed agency mortgage-backed bond yields higher, boosting their spread over Treasury yields to 1.20% from 0.70% at the beginning of the year and prompting some bargain-hunting.
  • Going forward, we still believe there is a heightened risk that the Fed’s policy tightening will reveal financial fragilities or spark a financial crisis and/or recession.  That chance may have declined somewhat because of reduced risk-taking following the financial blowups of the last two years, such as the Archegos hedge fund collapse or the plunge in the Terra USD cryptocurrency.  All the same, it’s important to remember that the negative impact of higher interest rates, a stronger dollar, and weakening demand in the real economy are all still working their way through the financial markets.  We continue to believe the current environment of high energy prices and rising interest rates require heightened caution on the part of investors.

U.S. Fiscal Policy:  Senate Majority Leader Schumer and Sen. Joe Manchin are reportedly nearing a deal to advance some elements of President Biden’s stalled economic program.  While the details remain closely held, some Democrats and outside analysts now expect a possible agreement could raise roughly $1 trillion in revenue and spend about $500 billion over a decade.

  • Roughly half the new revenue would be dedicated toward reducing the deficit.
  • The spending would focus on tax incentives for reducing carbon emissions and some support for fossil fuels, as well as an extension of subsidies for purchasing health insurance under the Affordable Care Act.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to  529,459,106 worldwide, with 6,289,228 deaths.  The countries currently reporting the highest rates of new infections include the U.S., Taiwan, Germany, and Australia.  (For an interactive chart that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population, click here.)  In the U.S., confirmed cases have risen to 84,012,408, with 1,004,760 deaths.  In data on the U.S. vaccination program, the number of people considered fully vaccinated now totals 221,190,484, equal to 66.6% of the total population.

Virology

  • In the U.S., the latest wave of infections already appears to be topping out, although hospitalizations and deaths are still accelerating with their usual lag.  The seven-day average of newly reported cases has now reached 109,105, up 14% from two weeks ago.  The seven-day average of people hospitalized with confirmed or suspected COVID-19 in the U.S. came in at 26,781 yesterday, up 20% from two weeks earlier.  New COVID-19 deaths are now averaging 368 per day, up 22% from two weeks earlier.
  • In China, plummeting infections in Shanghai suggest the city can lift most of its draconian restrictions on Wednesday as planned.  More than 22 million residents living in low-risk areas will be able to leave their compounds freely and fully resume using public transport. Private cars will also be allowed on the roads again.
  • On the other hand, Hong Kong has identified two new infection clusters centered on high-end nightclubs.  Health officials on Monday confirmed 275 new infections, including 48 imported ones, as well as two more related deaths.
    • The development came as officials prepared to roll out the third stage of their vaccine pass scheme on Tuesday.
    • Under that plan, most residents will need three jabs to enter premises unless they have already recovered from an infection less than six months ago.

Economic and Financial Market Impacts

  • The end of pandemic restrictions in Shanghai and elsewhere in China has raised hopes for reviving economic activity in that country, driving global oil prices up to a two-month high of approximately $117 for Brent crude.
    • Analysts estimate China’s latest pandemic lockdowns have cut its oil demand by approximately 1.2 million barrels per day.
    • Most or all of that demand is now likely to come back in the coming weeks and months.

View PDF

Asset Allocation Bi-Weekly – The Problem of Financial Conditions (May 31, 2022)

by the Asset Allocation Committee | PDF

Among the financial pundit class, there has been a growing call to weaken financial conditionsWhat are financial conditions?  They include credit spreads, the level of interest rates, the level of equities, the level of market volatility, the dollar’s exchange rate, etc.  Weaker financial conditions mean that borrowing costs rise, and the perceived risk of investment increases.  By increasing the costs of investment and borrowing, market participants (households, firms, etc.) will often exert greater caution, and this practice will tend to slow growth in the economy.  Essentially, the argument is that with inflation running “hot,” using weaker financial conditions to slow investment and consumption will eventually lead to less inflation.

However, managing financial conditions isn’t a straightforward process.  Once financial conditions begin to deteriorate, they can almost take on “lives of their own.”  In a sense, financial panics are evidence of rapidly deteriorating financial conditions.  A modest weakening in financial conditions might reduce “frothiness” in markets and lessen risk.  Nevertheless, containing a decline in financial conditions can be challenging.

Although there are several financial conditions indexes, we prefer the one generated by the Chicago Federal Reserve Bank.  This index has 105 variables, including various interest rate spreads, volatility measures, and the levels of several indexes and interest rates.  The index is updated weekly.  A rising index suggests increased financial stress (deteriorating financial conditions).  From 1973, when the index began, to mid-1998, there was a tight correlation between the level of fed funds and financial conditions.  For the most part, policymakers could use financial conditions as a “force multiplier” to enhance policy.  When the policy rate rose, financial conditions worsened in lockstep.  When the policy eased, they rapidly relaxed.

But, after mid-1998, the two data series became almost uncorrelated.  What happened?  A couple of factors likely affected this relationship.  The first was the passage of the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, which eliminated the difference between commercial and investment banking.  This bill changed the financial system, leading to more financial activities occurring outside the traditional banking system.  In other words, the non-bank banking system was fostered by this bill.  Why is that important?  To illustrate, instead of borrowing from a bank, firms could issue debt or do collateralized borrowing in a much less regulated environment.  Raising the policy rate didn’t necessarily lead to reduced borrowing because the financial markets have more ways to provide liquidity due to the changes in regulation.

The second factor was greater transparency in monetary policy.  Even in the late 1980s, the FOMC acted in secret.  “Fed watchers” tried to divine if a policy change had occurred by monitoring money supply data or bank reserve changes.  But by the mid-1990s, the FOMC started announcing when the policy rate changed, and over the years, it has been increasingly transparent about its policy expectations.  In general, society tends to treat transparency as a good unto itself.  But by making its policy direction clear, markets could adjust and thus had little to fear from “surprises.”  In the non-bank banking system, participants could use derivatives to insulate their positions from policy changes, rendering them less effective.

So, due to changes in the financial markets and increased openness, the FOMC has lost its ability to use financial conditions as an effective policy tool.  For example, on the above chart, the FOMC steadily lifted rates from 2004 to 2006.  During this time, financial conditions didn’t move.  Then, in 2007-08, when financial conditions deteriorated rapidly, aggressive rate cuts had little ability to improve them.  It took years of “zero-rate policy” and rounds of Quantitative Easing (QE) to finally improve financial conditions to a level in line with the pre-Great Financial Crisis period.

Recent history shows that when financial conditions weaken, it takes aggressive and swift action by the FOMC to reduce it.  In March 2020, financial conditions deteriorated rather quickly, and not only did the FOMC cut rates rapidly, but it implemented a broad intervention into the financial markets to support their function.  In addition, the balance sheet was expanded at a pace not seen outside of wartime.  Clearly, the pandemic was part of the policy response, but widening credit spreads and other signs of financial stress were also part of the Fed’s actions.

Although the call for purposely undermining financial conditions is understandable, the above chart shows it could trigger unforeseen outcomes.  We are no longer in a world where financial conditions deteriorate in lockstep with changes to the policy rate.  Instead, over the past 24 years, these conditions have shown a tendency to ignore policy tightening, only to deteriorate rapidly with little warning.  A modest weakening of financial conditions might be welcome, increasing the potency of tighter policy.  However, a sudden spike, as seen in 2008 and 2020, could be destabilizing, forcing the FOMC to rapidly reverse its current policy path.  Sadly, such events are almost impossible to predict in advance, although we can say that they seem to occur after tightening cycles.

It is possible that 2008 and 2020 may reflect the immaturity of the non-bank financial system, and markets may have evolved to a point where such market events have become less likely.  The backstops offered by the Fed during March 2020 might serve as a blueprint for containing financial crises.  Therefore, allowing financial conditions to deteriorate is less risky.  However, it appears to us the burden of proof lies with proving that tightening won’t “break something.”  And so, we remain vigilant, watching for funding issues that could trigger a run on liquidity and force the FOMC to ease.

View PDF

Daily Comment (May 27, 2022)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning! U.S. equities continue to rally as investors no longer fear that the Fed will become more hawkish. Additionally, a drop in mortgage rates and a strong performance from retailers have boosted investor sentiment. Today’s report begins with the rising popularity of windfall taxes. Next, we discuss the latest updates on the Russia-Ukraine war and other related stories. We comment on the latest U.S. economic and policy news, focusing on the rivalry between Washington and Beijing and waning inflation expectations. We conclude with our COVID-19 coverage.

Tax on Energy: On Thursday, the U.K. government announced that it would introduce a 25% tax on the profits of energy producers. The government will use the tax to provide subsidies of £650 in two installments to low incomes households and £300 to some pensioners. The U.K. is not the first country to push corporations to use their profits to help the country. On Wednesday, the Hungarian government made a similar request for companies to use their “excess profits” to help the government fund utility subsidies. Italy also taxed profits on energy companies to fund aid packages earlier this month.

We suspect that taxing excess profits of firms, particularly those in the energy sector, could be detrimental to resolving the oil shortage. By taxing firms for being extremely profitable, the government gives them less incentive to expand production capacity. Moreover, by using the funds for consumer subsidies, the government is disrupting the communication mechanism for the consumer to purchase less. As a result, the tax on excess profits may hinder attempts to lower prices because it does not reduce demand or encourage firms to expand capacity.

Russia-Ukraine: Russian soldiers are having more success in eastern Ukraine as the troops learn from their previous mistakes. Russian forces are advancing in Severodonetsk and are close to encircling the region. These forces also appear to be closing in on the west and south of Popasna. Despite these gains, Ukrainian officials have maintained a solid defense.

Other Russia-Ukraine news

  • The White House stated it expects a Russian default to have a minimal effect global economy. The remarks came after the Treasury decided not to extend the waiver to allow Russia to repay bondholders in dollars. Last month, World Bank economist Carmen Reinhart warned that a Russian default could stress a financial system already burdened with rising inflation and slowing growth. Russia is expected to pay about $100 million of interest on its foreign debt on Friday.
  • In a phone call with Italian Prime Minister Mario Draghi, Russian President Vladimir Putin stated his country would be willing to help ease the food crisis in exchange for lifting sanctions. U.K. and U.S. officials have described the offer as blackmail. The Kremlin’s decision to block the export of grains is another sign that Russia is trying to raise the cost of the West’s loyalty to Ukraine. The blockade has benefited Russia as it has raised the price it can charge for its grains; meanwhile, it hurts the West by contributing to rising inflation. As food prices increase, we suspect that the Western coalition will start to fray. If we are correct, it would mean that Ukraine is running out of time to retake regions lost to Russia. The rising inflation due to conflict may lead the West to pressure Ukraine to agree to a cease-fire with Russia.

U.S. economic and policy news

  • The U.S. pivot: Despite the ongoing conflict in Russia, Washington still views China as its primary geopolitical rival. In a speech, SoS Antony Blinken stated that the U.S. would attempt to influence China’s behavior by shaping the “strategic environment around Beijing.” The remark came on the eve of economic talks between the U.S. and Taiwan. The Biden administration is developing the Indo-Pacific Economic Framework, designed to create greater economic integration with the U.S. and countries within the region. Meanwhile, China has been trying to expand its military influence throughout the region by acquiring security pacts. Despite the U.S. and China’s supposed advantages, it isn’t clear who has the upper hand. The U.S. is unwilling to provide the market access that China is willing to offer. Meanwhile, China does not have the defensive capabilities to provide the same level of protection as the U.S. military. As the two countries compete for influence, countries within the Indo-Pacific will likely benefit, and thus, these areas could be attractive places for investment.
  • Fiji announced it would join the Indo-Pacific Economic Framework on Friday.
  • Inflation expectations: Although inflation remains elevated, there are growing signs that it may have peaked. Research from the New York fed suggests that consumers’ inflation expectations are starting to wane. The finding shows that consumers expect inflation to fall to 3% in about five years. Consequently, the study suggests inflation expectations are more anchored than most people realize. In another sign that inflationary pressures are fading, staffing companies report firms are becoming more reluctant to raise wages due to concerns that consumers are starting to push back. Although inflation will likely remain above the Fed’s two percent target for the foreseeable future, we suspect the Fed will be less inclined to be more assertive in raising rates.

International news

  • Chinese lockdowns have led to a worker revolt in a factory in Shanghai. To minimize the impact of lockdowns on the global economy, China has forced laborers to work in a bubble. The unrest adds pressure on Beijing to abandon its controversial Zero-COVID Strategy. The lockdown is affecting the economy. In April, industrial profits fell 8.5% from the prior year.
  • The E.U. is preparing for Russia to halt natural gas shipments to the bloc. Europe is already building its inventory stock and is willing to ration gas supplies to industries.

 Interesting fact

  • Following the decline of several of its competitors, Bitcoin has reclaimed its dominance as the most widely held cryptocurrency.

COVID-19: The number of reported cases is 527,941,243, with 6,284,762 fatalities. In the U.S., there are 83,837,175 confirmed cases with 1,004,122 deaths. For illustration purposes, the FT has created an interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics. The CDC reports that 744,812,955 doses of the vaccine have been distributed, with 586,008,740 doses injected. The number receiving at least one dose is 258,394,333, and the number of second doses is 221,128,528. The number receiving the first booster is 103,110,612, and the number receiving the second booster is 13,235,706. The FT has a page on global vaccine distribution.

  • The White House has stepped up its efforts to make it easier for patients to access the COVID-19 oral pill treatment, The Federal government plans to reimburse a clinic in Rhode Island that immediately prescribes the pill to patients who test positive for the virus. The new approach suggests that the Biden administration is looking for alternative methods outside of vaccinations to contain the spread of the virus.

View PDF

Business Cycle Report (May 26, 2022)

by Thomas Wash | PDF

The business cycle has a major impact on financial markets; recessions usually accompany bear markets in equities.  The intention of this report is to keep our readers apprised of the potential for recession, updated on a monthly basis.  Although it isn’t the final word on our views about recession, it is part of our process in signaling the potential for a downturn.

The Confluence Diffusion Index hit a post-recession high; however, several indicators have deteriorated. In April, elevated inflation and hawkish Fed policy weighed on financial market indicators, leading to a flatter yield curve and a deceleration in the annual change in the stock market index. In the labor market, indicators show firms are reluctant to lay off workers because of concerns of a worker shortage. Lastly, manufacturing and construction indicators suggest that supply chains are still a problem for firms. Consequently, the latest report showed that all 11 benchmarks are in expansion territory. The diffusion index rose from +0.8789 to +0.9394, remaining well above the recession signal of +0.2500.

The chart above shows the Confluence Diffusion Index. It uses a three-month moving average of 11 leading indicators to track the state of the business cycle. The red line signals when the business cycle is headed toward a contraction, while the blue line signals when the business cycle is in recovery. The diffusion index currently provides about six months of lead time for a contraction and five months of lead time for recovery. Continue reading for an in-depth understanding of how the indicators are performing. At the end of the report, the Glossary of Charts describes each chart and its measures. In addition, a chart title listed in red indicates that the index is signaling recession.

Read the full report

Daily Comment (May 26, 2022)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning! Today’s report begins with a summary of the Fed meeting minutes and other central bank news. Next, we discuss the latest developments in the Russia-Ukraine war. Afterward, we go over the pushback regarding China’s zero-COVID strategy and the possibility of global famine due to the Russian blockade of the Black Sea. We end with international news and our COVID-19 coverage.

Fed Meeting Minutes: The Fed meeting minutes revealed a consensus among voting members for the central bank to hike rates 50 bps over the next couple of meetings. The minutes reaffirmed market sentiment that the central bank might push rates into restrictive territory to tame inflation. As a result, the S&P rose slightly, and Treasuries were relatively unaffected. The Fed’s decision to maintain 50 bp hikes appears to be related to its confidence that the economy is strong and capable of withstanding additional tightening. Fed members and staff shrugged off the unexpected decline in Q1 GDP as being temporary. Additionally, the group downplayed the possibility that decreases in inventory spending, government spending, as well as net exports, would persist throughout the year. Although the Fed was generally upbeat about the economy, it mentioned the Russia-Ukraine war and lockdowns in China as threats to the expansion.

Central Bank News

  • Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City President Esther George has announced that she will be stepping down in January. The decision to leave her post was not surprising. Fed officials are required to step down due to mandatory retirement rules of Fed Presidents. Chicago Fed President Charles Evans is also expected to step down for a similar reason. As a result, there will likely be two vacancies in 2023 among the 12 regional banks.
  • There are growing fears that the ECB is behind the curve in containing inflation. Veteran British economist Charles Goodhart warned wage pressures would contribute to inflation as workers demand higher pay to cope with increasing food and energy prices. There seems to be a broad consensus among ECB members to end negative rates next quarter, with Dutch central bank chief Klaas Knot stating that he would support a 50 bp rate hike in July. By one of our central bank policy measures, seen in the chart below, the ECB may be behind the curve but still in a better position than the U.S. This suggests that the ECB may not have to raise rates as aggressively.

  • The chart above shows the annual change in CPI minus the unemployment rate. When CPI exceeds that unemployment rate, it signals that the economy may be overheating.

Russia-Ukraine: As the war enters its fourth month, the Kremlin faces growing criticism on social media regarding the way it is handling the Ukraine war. Bloggers on Telegram have complained that the government has not adequately supplied Russian soldiers with military equipment needed to hold off Ukraine troops. Although it is unclear how impactful these messages are on the general public, the backlash suggests the government may be losing control over the narrative. Meanwhile, the West is preparing for the possibility of a long war. NATO general Jens Stoltenberg urged countries need to be prepared to provide Ukraine with additional support. We believe that as the conflict rages on, the West will struggle to maintain its coalition. The inability of the EU to secure an agreement on the Russian oil ban reinforces the concern that this coalition may fracture in the future. If we are correct, it could mean the West could push Ukraine into accepting a ceasefire with Russia. At this time, leaders in both Russia and Ukraine have been postponing peace talks, hoping to secure more leverage. We believe such negotiations will happen sooner rather than later.

On the ground, Russian forces have entered Lyman and are closing in on Popasna. Russian troops are making gains in Ukraine but very modestly. The military is struggling to find reserves to carry out the mission.  It has raised the maximum age for army recruits and forced border guards to cancel their vacations.

The Global Food Crisis: The Russian blockade of Ukrainian ports continues to stir fears of global famine and instability. Russia and Ukraine supply about 30% of the world’s wheat, a crucial food source for developing countries. In response to criticism, Russia has agreed to relieve some of the pressure by opening the Black Sea port for foreign ships. The move should put downward pressure on grain prices.

  • Brazil agreed to supply China with corn. The move comes as Beijing looks to build up its stocks to hedge against a potential food crisis. The agreement led to a decline in corn prices due to concerns that the deal could reduce demand for U.S. corn.

Zero-COVID Policy:  In a rarity, Chinese Premier Li Keqiang openly acknowledged that the zero-COVID strategy is harming the economy. In a meeting with multinationals operating in China, Li offered reassurances that the country would do its best to expand vaccinations. In addition, conceding the need for increased vaccinations, Li warned that the Chinese economy could struggle to avoid a contraction in the second quarter. His remarks highlight the growing unease among members of Chinese leadership about Xi’s decision to reimpose COVID-19 restrictions.

International News

Interesting facts:

COVID-19:  The number of reported cases is 527,228,581, with 6,282,713 fatalities. In the U.S., there are 83,702,508 confirmed cases with 1,003,738 deaths. For illustration purposes, the FT has created an interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics. The CDC reports that 739,095,455 doses of the vaccine have been distributed, with 583,221,364 doses injected. The number receiving at least one dose is 258,312,266, the number of second doses is 221,050,854, the number receiving the first booster is 102,997,276, and the number receiving the second booster is 12,988,274. The FT has a page on global vaccine distribution.

View PDF

Weekly Energy Update (May 26, 2022)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA | PDF

Crude oil prices have been mostly holding steady this week.

(Source: Barchart.com)

Crude oil inventories fell 1.0 mb compared to a 2.1 mb draw forecast.  The SPR declined 6.0 mb, meaning the net draw was 7.0 mb.

In the details, U.S. crude oil production was unchanged at 11.9 mbpd.  Exports rose 0.8 mbpd, while imports fell 0.1 mbpd.  Refining activity rose 1.4% to 93.2% of capacity.

(Sources: DOE, CIM)

The above chart shows the seasonal pattern for crude oil inventories.  This week’s report is consistent, showing a partial reversal of last week’s rise, with rising crude oil exports and increased refinery activity offsetting the continued draw from the SPR.  Seasonally, the draw begins in earnest in June.

Since the SPR is being used, to some extent, as a buffer stock, we have constructed oil inventory charts incorporating both the SPR and commercial inventories.

Total stockpiles peaked in 2017 and are now at levels seen in late 2008.  Using total stocks since 2015, fair value is $90.65.

With so many crosscurrents in the oil markets, we see some degree of normalization.  The inventory/EUR model suggests oil prices should be around $60 per barrel, so we are seeing about $40 of risk premium in the market.

To scale the impact of high gasoline prices, we calculate the number of gallons a non-supervisory worker can purchase with one hour of work at the average national retail price of gasoline.

As the chart shows, we are approaching six gallons, which isn’t the all-time low but getting close to that level.  In general, low readings tend to track consumer confidence and presidential approval ratings.

Market news:

This chart shows the long-term history of the Brent-WTI spread.  Until the shale revolution, WTI regularly was priced higher than Brent.  Restrictions on exports and the explosion of shale production led the spread to flip violently around 2011.  As the U.S. increased oil exports, the spread narrowed, but Brent tended to hold its premium over WTI. The recent narrowing is likely signaling rising export demand from the U.S.

  • Despite high oil prices, U.S. production growth has been slow. Although there are many reasons for this lack of output (e.g., high input costs, labor shortages, unfriendly regulatory environment), one particular reason is that oil executives are being paid based upon profitability and less on production.
  • Meanwhile, U.S. natural gas prices are elevated in a period where prices are usually weaker. Seasonal demand usually weakens in the spring and falls as temperatures moderate.  This year, prices are elevated, in part, due to LNG exports.  The LNG isn’t quite as global as oil, but it continues to expand.
  • The North American Electric Reliability Corporation released its Summer Reliability Assessment. The risks of outages this summer are elevated.
  • Another factor limiting energy supplies is the skyrocketing cost of transportation.

 Geopolitical news:

  • The U.S. is facilitating talks between Egypt, the KSA, and Israel over the sovereignty of two small islands near the Gulf of Aqaba. The islands are controlled by Egypt but would be returned to their original owner, Saudi Arabia.  But, for this action to occur, Israel would have to approve.  The thinking is that if Israel signs off, it will create a framework for normalizing relations between Israel and the KSA.  Such an event would further expand the Abraham Accords.
    • This may be part of an attempt by the administration to heal relations with the KSA.
  • UAE President Sheikh Khalifa bin Zayed Al Nahyan died earlier this month. The leader is credited with the UAE’s economic development but has been mostly a figurehead since his stroke in 2014.  Crown Prince Mohammed bin Zayed Al Nahyan will take over as president.  Like the KSA, the founder of the UAE intended to pass leadership through his sons.  However, as this first generation ages, there is increasing speculation that MBZ, as he is known, will pass power to his son, one of the grandsons of the founder.  Like in KSA, this generational transition is fraught with risk, because the pool of potential leaders is large, and thus, there are many who will be disappointed.  This worry isn’t imminent; MBZ is only 40 and could easily rule for three decades.
  • Despite high oil prices and fears of insufficient supply, the KSA signaled it would not increase production beyond the current plan. The KSA also reiterated support for Russia, highlighting the growing rift between the U.S. and the KSA.
  • Finland’s decision to apply for NATO membership has prompted Russia to halt natural gas flows to the Nordic nation.
  • China is said to be increasing its purchases of Russian crude to build its strategic reserve by “quietly” buying Russian crude oil at deep discounts. These purchases would seem to violate sanctions, but the S. is giving Beijing a pass, perhaps wanting to avoid a confrontation with China.
  • We consider the negotiations to revive the Iran nuclear deal as dead, much like the Monty Python skit, yet talks, mostly fostered by the EU, continue. Even the Europeans acknowledge the talks are nearing their end. The Iranians deny they have made any concessions, increasing the odds the deal isn’t going to happen.
  • Hassan Sayad Khodayari, an officer of the Iranian Revolutionary Guard Corps, was assassinated at his home in Tehran over the weekend. Although no one has claimed responsibility, the general suspicion is that this is the work of the Israelis.  Israeli media is reporting that Khodayari was involved in planning attacks against Israelis, including kidnappings.
  • Yet another CEO of Petrobras (PBR, USD, 14.51) has been sacked, the third in recent months. Jose Mauro Ferreira Coelho has been replaced by Caio Mario Paes de Andrade.  Why is President Bolsonaro so angry with the company?  Because fuel prices keep rising and he wants the company to fix prices and lose money.
  • Even though the U.S. has been in talks with the Venezuelan regime, Caracas continues to work with Iran. In fact, the Iranians are working to repair Venezuela’s largest refinery.  The Paraguana refinery complex, which has a capacity of 955 kbpd) is only producing at 17% of capacity; it is unclear if Tehran has the expertise or the funds to fully restore production.
  • The EU is struggling to build a consensus on embargoing Russian oil, with Hungary being the major stumbling block. However, there are reports that the state oil firm MOL (MOL, USD, 4.14) is taking at least initial steps to process non-Russian oil.
  • The U.S. is making it clear that one of its policy goals is to “cripple” Russia’s oil industry. As part of this goal, the U.S. is considering secondary sanctions on buyers of Russian oil.  The Russian economy continues to struggle.

 Alternative energy/policy news:

  View PDF

Daily Comment (May 25, 2022)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with an update on the Russia-Ukraine war, where Russian forces are now making better gains toward their newly reduced goals.  We next review a range of international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets.  We wrap up with the latest news on the coronavirus pandemic.

Russia-Ukraine:  Russian forces continue to implement their latest strategy shift, which involves abandoning their effort to make a major encirclement of Ukrainian forces in the eastern Donbas region.  They are instead completing a series of smaller encirclements.  The strategy shift has allowed them to seize more territory than they did earlier in May, but their progress is still relatively minor, and the tough, costly urban combat would likely slow them if they try to take the city of Severodonetsk.  Meanwhile, we continue to see increased complaints about the war within Russia, even by nationalist politicians who generally support President Putin.

United Kingdom: Prime Minister Johnson has come under new political pressure today as an official investigation found he must “bear responsibility” for a culture in Downing Street during the pandemic that allowed the repeated breaking of COVID-19 rules.  However, the long-anticipated report was not as critical of him as some had expected, increasing the chance that he could survive what has been one of his most dangerous political scandals.

Saudi Arabia:  Finance Minister Al-Jadaan said the kingdom will use its huge windfall from today’s high oil prices to top up its reserves, fund more domestic development projects, and invest more into its massive sovereign wealth fund.

  • The kingdom posted a $15.3 billion budget surplus in the first quarter, putting it on track to meet its goal of a $24.0 billion surplus for the entire year.
  • If Saudi Arabia succeeds in posting a surplus this year, it would be the kingdom’s first since 2013.

Pakistan:  Foreign Minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari said he wants to negotiate a deal with the IMF to resume lending under a $6 billion loan program agreed upon in 2019 but in limbo since a dispute with the previous government over energy subsidies.  The renewed lending would be used to help replenish the country’s foreign reserves and deal with the surge in food and energy prices touched off by the war in Ukraine.

United States:  As the Federal Reserve continues to tighten monetary policy, driving interest rates higher, top U.S. mortgage lenders are reporting a sudden plunge in refinancing demand.  Firms ranging from Wells Fargo (WFC, $43.29) to Rocket (RKT, $8.75) are laying off staff, selling servicing rights, and otherwise trying to survive.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to  526,808,553 worldwide, with 6,280,679 deaths.  The countries currently reporting the highest rates of new infections include the U.S., Germany, Taiwan, and Australia.  (For an interactive chart that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population, click here.)  In the U.S., confirmed cases rose to 83,505,455, with 1,002,743 deaths.  In data on the U.S. vaccination program, the number of people considered fully vaccinated now totals 221,001,614, equal to 66.6% of the total population.

  • As yet another wave of infections seems to be hitting the U.S., newly reported cases are on the rise, again.  The seven-day average of newly reported cases has now reached 108,082, up 40% from two weeks ago.  However, hospitalization and death rates are still rising much more slowly.  The seven-day average of people hospitalized with confirmed or suspected COVID-19 in the U.S. came in at 25,383 yesterday, up 30% from two weeks earlier.  New COVID-19 deaths average just 331 per day, down 10% from two weeks earlier.
  • The chief executive of Pfizer (PFE, $53.41) has warned that the stage is set for “constant” waves of infections because of growing complacency about the virus, politicization of the government response, and waning immunity from infections and vaccinations.
  • In China, the government is cracking down even harder on students at elite universities who have been protesting strict pandemic restrictions.  The action raises the risk of wider political protests and instability in the country.
  • To help cushion the economy from President Xi’s super-strict “zero- COVID” strategy, the government has released a 33-point stimulus package.  The measures are centered on greater financial relief for more industries via tax refunds, tax cuts, and fee reductions.
    • The government will also support banks by allowing borrowers of various types of loans to postpone principal and interest repayments until the end of this year.  Bank lending quotas for small and micro-sized businesses will be doubled.
    • The additional measures will bring the government’s total planned tax refunds and reductions to 2.64 trillion yuan (US$396 billion) for 2022.

View PDF

Daily Comment (May 24, 2022)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning.  After a strong rally off the lows on Friday and impressive follow-through yesterday, risk assets are lower this morning.  However, one pattern emerging in the past couple of weeks is that the correlation between stocks and bonds has again become inverse.  Since about May 6, we have seen the inverse pattern that has mainly been in place since the mid-1990s and is the backbone of the 60/40 portfolio.  We remain cautious about the long-term path of this relationship.  If inflation becomes persistent, higher bond yields are probably unavoidable. The fact the pattern has returned suggests that (a) the market thinks the current yield on longer duration Treasuries is “about right,” and (b) the debt markets believe the Fed will defend bond values against inflation.

In today’s Comment, we open with China news, focusing on the aftermath of President Biden’s statements on Taiwan.  From there, we take a look at economic news.  The Ukraine update follows.  International news comes next, and we close with the pandemic update.

China news:  Was it a gaffe, or not?  As we reported yesterday, President Biden seemed to end the U.S. policy of strategic ambiguity regarding Taiwan.  Within 24 hours, the White House tried to walk the comments back, suggesting “nothing has changed.”  To be fair to the president, strategic ambiguity has been fraying for some time.  We note that SoS Blinken once referred to Taiwan as a “country,”  and it isn’t the first time the president has suggested the U.S. would defend the island militarily.

So, has anything changed?  In some ways, yes, but in others, no.  What has changed?  Japan seems much more committed to the defense of Taiwan.  As we have noted before, Taiwan in the hands of Beijing is an existential threat to Tokyo.  What remains the same?  We seriously doubt anyone in China’s leadership believes the U.S. would not come to the aid of Taipei if China tried to invade Taiwan.  That isn’t anything new.  The rhetoric surrounding the president’s remarks in Beijing will escalate; if the PLA hasn’t been pondering how to thwart American defense efforts in its invasion plans, they should be relieved of duty.  We note that within the international relations community, the end of strategic ambiguity is being widely cheered.  The primary benefit of ending strategic ambiguity is that China won’t be as likely to miscalculate, assuming the U.S. won’t act; that was, in part, why the Korean War occurred.  However, as noted above, the odds of such a miscalculation were small anyway.  The most serious risk of ending the policy is that it reduces American optionality and might lead to less cautious behavior on the part of Taiwan.  We still view Taiwan as a chief point of geopolitical risk; the president’s “gaffe” doesn’t change that.

Economics and policy:  It’s day two of Davos.  Some softening in monetary policy may be coming.

Larry Summers has been a problem for the administration.  He criticized the fiscal stimulus in 2021, saying it would likely lead to higher inflation.  Although fiscal spending wasn’t the only reason for inflation, it certainly contributed.  He is now attacking the idea that industry concentration leads to higher prices.  The basic issue is that industry concentration can improve efficiencies but also gives market power to firms.  Firms can decide how to allocate the gains to efficiency because they have market power.  Since the mid-1980s, when the Bork Standard for antitrust emerged, firms have mostly allocated these efficiencies to profits and consumers by keeping price hikes contained.  Labor has generally been excluded from benefiting from any efficiencies.

This chart shows the share of output going to labor.  The trend was mainly declining but clearly accelerated this century.  So, back to Summers’s argument.  He contends that antitrust action might actually lead to higher inflation if it undermines the efficiencies from concentration.  But, that is true only if two conditions are met.  First, increased competition should make it more difficult to pass along high costs.  Second, it appears that Summers believes current profit margins will be maintained.  With S&P 500 earnings nearly 8% of GDP, an all-time record, it seems reasonable that a return to trend could allow for antitrust to at least not contribute to higher inflation.  At the same time, we think the administration is overstating the case for antitrust to bring down inflation.  It’s easier to blame industry concentration for inflation than to cool the economy by cutting spending and raising taxes.

The Ukraine War:  The conflict appears to be evolving into a trench war, with both sides building fortifications to thwart offensive actions.  Here is the latest map:

International roundup:  A big deal is in the works and more from the president’s trip.

COVID-19:  The number of reported cases is 526,196,860 with 6,278,868 fatalities.  In the U.S., there are 83,393,876 confirmed cases with 1,002,385 deaths.  For illustration purposes, the FT has created an interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.  The FT has also issued an economic tracker that looks across countries with high-frequency data on various factors.  The CDC reports that 741,676,155 doses of the vaccine have been distributed, with 584,449,398 doses injected.  The number receiving at least one dose is 258,174,992, while the number fully vaccinated, which would grant the highest level of immunity, is 220,933,970.  For the population older than 18, 76.5% of the population has been fully vaccinated, with 61.1% of the entire population fully vaccinated.  For those over 65, 90.9% have been fully vaccinated.  The FT has a page on global vaccine distribution.

  • Pfizer (PFE, USD, 52.88) says studies show its vaccine triggers a strong immune response in young children.

View PDF

Daily Comment (May 23, 2022)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning and happy Monday!  On Friday, the S&P 500 flirted with official bear market territory (a decline of 20% from the high), but using the words of a locally once famous market strategist, it made a “Hollywood finish” and closed nearly unchanged.  We are seeing follow through buying this morning with bond yields up a bit after stabilizing recently.  The dollar is sharply lower this morning, with the EUR rallying on reports the ECB is poised to end its negative policy rate soon.  The World Economic Forum is being held in Davos this week, and continuing the tradition of stating the obvious, the tone of the meeting is the end of globalization.

Our coverage this morning begins with China news, focusing on comments from President Biden on Taiwan.  From there, we take a look at the Australian elections, where a transfer of power has occurred.  An update on the Ukraine war follows.  We have a long read on the change in German thinking and the problems it presents for the Social Democrats.  A quick update on some economic and international news comes next and we finish with the latest on the pandemic.

China news:  While at a press conference in Tokyo, President Biden stated that the U.S. would militarily intervene if China were to invade Taiwan.  This is monumental.  America’s policy toward Taiwan has traditionally been strategic ambiguity.  We never committed to the defense of the island for a couple of reasons.  Knowing it was defended could change Taiwan’s behavior.  It could either (a) become reckless, threatening Chinese actions in the region (imagine shooting down Chinese warplanes that regularly penetrate its airspace), or (b) knowing the U.S. would act, no longer take steps to defend itself.  There have been voices calling for such a declaration. These were not universal.  The White House claimed this wasn’t a change in policy, but that is contradicted by similar comments made last year that set off a scramble by the State Department to walk back the president’s remarks.  Although the U.S. never said it wouldn’t defend Taiwan, the end of strategic ambiguity is a new complication for the region and U.S.-Chinese relations.  As one would expect, China isn’t happy with the comments.  In other news relating to China:

  • The first time we noticed Chinese capital flight was in 2012, which was just about the time Xi Jinping began his first term. Despite capital controls, Chinese money flowing into various markets became noticeable.  For example, the FHFA House Price Index for the Pacific region (where the impact was noticeable) was markedly different from that in New England.

In 2013, the first year after Xi’s elevation to power, Pacific home prices rose nearly 19% compared to New England, where prices rose a modest 4.5% (for the U.S. as a whole, including the Pacific region, the rise was only 7.7%).  Fears of Xi’s crackdown on corruption likely led many wealthy Chinese to try to preserve their wealth from seizure by sending it abroad, with some of it finding its way to West Coast real estate.  Although outflows wax and wane over time, recently, there are reports of increased outflows.

(Source:  IIF)

This chart from the Institute for International Finance shows a rise in outflows from China.  Fears of a larger crackdown in front of Xi’s third term are likely leading wealthy Chinese to move money out of the country.  The CPC is now saying party elites should divest from their foreign holdings, ostensibly to protect themselves from Western sanctions.  Even though experience of Russian oligarchs suggests this is a prudent policy, we suspect policy instability in China is a more pertinent concern.

  • President Biden is in Asia making the case for the administration’s Indo-Pacific Economic Framework. Outside of America’s clear allies in Asia—Australia, Japan, South Korea, and Taiwan—the rest of Asia is indifferent to U.S. overtures.  Although these nations appreciate America’s security support, they really want access to U.S. consumers.  Unfortunately, that desire isn’t likely to be offered by the president.  Instead, he is promising to start talking, which is far short of what these nations want.  The problem is that these nations like the presence of the U.S. military in the region to protect them from the “tender mercies” of the Chinese.  Nevertheless, they don’t want to be forced to choose to lose the economic relationship with China because the U.S. isn’t open to increasing trade with the region.  The political support for trade is lacking in Congress as populists on both the left and right have soured on trade.
  • Needless to say, Beijing isn’t pleased with the president’s visit to the region. In fact, the PLA Navy is conducting exercises in the South China Sea to coincide with this tour.  American policy is designed to isolate China; the code words are “cold war strategy.”  In the meantime, China is trying to expand its security outposts into the region beyond the recent one with the Solomon Islands.
  • Although China has indicated it is a close ally of Russia, that relationship didn’t stop Beijing from trying to steal Russian defense data through hacking. Albeit the news is ironic to some extent, friendly nations usually conduct intelligence gathering on each other.  The U.S. hacking of the German Chancellor’s cell phone is a case in point.
  • China is Russia’s ally, but we note that Chinese firms have been instructed to stop working on an LNG project in Russia. It appears Chinese leaders would prefer not to run afoul of EU sanctions.

A change down under:  In Saturday’s election in Australia, Labor has won the most seats and will form a government.  It is the first Labor government in almost a decade.  The latest data show that the Labor, led by Anthony Albanese, has won 73 seats, three short of a majority.  However, there are three races that are likely to go to Labor, meaning it should be able to form a government without a coalition.  The Liberal/National coalition, the conservatives led by Scott Morrison, took a drubbing, losing 21 seats to secure 54, although it might secure four more seats as the vote counting finishes.  Most notable, seven seats went to non-party affiliated independents, suggesting the Australian electorate is fracturing to some extent.  Calling themselves the “teal independents,” a play on the colors of the major parties, these independents support climate change legislation but are also centrists, meaning they reject the right-wing populism of the Liberal/National coalition.  How did Labor win?  It ran on a climate platform, promising to address carbon emissions.  Such promises are attractive until the costs of these policies emerge, and with inflation becoming a problem, it may be impossible to both reduce carbon emissions and control prices.  Increasing discomfort with the previous government also helped Albanese.  This election may have been more about not supporting the incumbent.  Unfortunately for Albanese, he is taking office as the Australian economy is hitting serious headwinds.  We note the OECD’s leading indicator is signaling a recession.

The Ukraine War:  The conflict appears to be evolving into a trench war, with both sides building fortifications to thwart offensive actions.  Here is the latest map:

(Source:  Institute for the Study of War)

Most of the fighting is shown by the green circles on the map.  The circle highlighted with an arrow shows the fighting around Sievierodonetsk, where Russian forces are trying to push Ukrainian forces out of the area.  There are reports the Russian military has relieved some commanders of their posts, is splitting units into smaller groups, and is using more artillery and less infantry in its fighting.

  • Although the U.S. approved a $40 billion aid package for Ukraine, we are starting to hear rumblings about the path of the war and U.S. policy. For Russia, Ukraine is critical; without control of Ukraine, Russia’s hopes for restoring the empire are lost.  For Ukraine, ceding any territory is impossible.  President Zelensky has staked his administration on pushing Russian troops out of his country.  These conditions suggest that the conflict will go on for a long time.  But a long conflict isn’t necessarily in the U.S.’s best interest.  The longer the war goes on, the harder it will be to keep NATO intact and the greater the negative effects of the war on the global economy.  Given concerns about a recession in the U.S., second thoughts about supporting a long war are starting to emerge.  As readers know, we don’t consider the New York Times as just a news organization but also a reflection of elite opinion formation.  We note the paper’s editorial board has pointed out that support for Ukraine in Congress is far from universal.  The editorial signals that the U.S. may not support Zelensky’s goal of removing Russia from Ukraine.  There is also talk of a ceasefire.  Although we don’t expect the conflict to end soon, we may see a growing movement to force a ceasefire that may allow Russia to hold the territory it seized in 2014.
  • President Zelensky has proposed using Russia’s foreign reserves to rebuild his country.
  • Prince Abdulaziz bin Salman, the Saudi energy minister and half-brother of Crown Prince Salman, signaled that the kingdom would stand by Russia as a member of OPEC+. This news suggests the oil cartel will maintain its program of gradual production increases.  For Western consumers, this means oil prices will remain high until demand reductions bring prices down.
  • Russian debtors have paid coupons in advance of a Treasury directive that will almost certainly push Russia into default.
  • Russia has banned 963 Americans from entering its country, including Senators Harry Reid, John McCain, and Orrin Hatch, all who have left here earthly pale.
  • As fears of Russia grow, bonds in the Baltic states and Finland are showing signs of weakness.
  • Vitaly Savelyev, the Russian Transportation Minister, admitted Saturday that Western sanctions have “practically broken” logistics in Russia. The war and sanctions have caused a major rerouting of the flow of commodities, raising costs and causing spot shortages of key materials.

A German scandal:  Narratives are important to human thinking.  We tend to tell stories as a way to make sense of the world.  We don’t consider them “stories” or “myths,” instead, we call them “narratives” to frame our views of the world.  Robert Schiller wrote a book about economic narratives that is a worthy read.

One narrative that has emerged in various forms over the past couple of centuries is the idea that trade makes the world less risky.  In other words, if we trade with each other, we are less likely to go to war.  Norman Angell wrote a book called “The Great Illusion” where he suggested that a major war in Europe wasn’t likely because of how deeply intertwined the economies of the continent were… in 1910.  Despite how disastrously wrong this idea was with reference to WWI, the notion has persisted.  Tom Friedman made famous a common saying that two nations with McDonald’s (MCD, USD, 230.51) have never gone to war.  Well, they have now; both Ukraine and Russia had the restaurant chain.

A variation of this idea became popular in Germany among the Social Democrats (SDP), which was that trade with the Soviets would improve relations and tame the worst instincts of Moscow.  The concept, called Osthandel, argued that this trade helped end the Cold War.  Needless to say, the U.S. narrative on the end of the Cold War didn’t acknowledge this German narrative. The American version would argue the U.S. prevailed despite German actions.  But, stories stick, and the Germans held on to it after the Soviet Union dissolved.  Thus, Germany saw the growing dependence on Russian energy not as a bug but as a feature, a formula for peace and prosperity.  The Germans went so far as to build direct pipelines to Germany through the Baltic Sea, the Nord Stream I and Nord Stream II pipelines, bypassing those pesky Poles and Ukrainians.

The Russian invasion of Ukraine has shredded Osthandel, and the political ramifications are just starting.  Former German Chancellor Schroder has finally resigned from the board of Rosneft (NK Rosneft’ PAO, RUB, 384.25).  But, he is the Chairman of Nord Stream 2 and was recently nominated to the board of Gazprom (Gazprom PAO, RUB, 263.00).  In a recent profile in the New York Times, Schroder was unapologetic for his ties to Russian energy and his personal friendship with Vladimir Putin.  In fact, Putin offered him a board seat on Nord Stream 2 a mere 17 days after Schroder left the office of the Chancellor of Germany, the project was approved on his watch.  This week, the SDP and its coalition partners stripped Schroder of his parliamentary privileges.  He loses his office and staff, although he will keep his pension and security detail.  The CSU leader, Markus Soder, described Schroder as a “willful, bizarre, old man who cares more about his own bank account than Germany’s reputation in the world.” “That’s embarrassing, a disgrace for our country.”

Adding to the scandal is that Matthias Warnig, a former Stasi agent, was also a colleague of Schroder on the board of Rosneft.  Warnig worked with Putin during the latter’s time in East Germany when he was a KGB agent.  After the fall of the GDR, Warnig, who used the cover of a trade official for East Germany when he was with the East German spy agency, was hired by Dresdner Bank (now a unit of Commerzbank, (XETRA, EUR, 7.24)) shortly after German reunification.  He was instrumental in founding the Dresdner Bank Moscow branch; this branch was in St. Petersburg and was negotiated with none other than Vladimir Putin.

So why is this important?  The German ruling coalition is perhaps the most complicated in postwar German history.  The three parties that form it have divergent interests, and thus, unlike former governments, this coalition might not hold together.  Or, the leadership might change; if the Chancellor came from the Greens, the policy toward Russia would likely harden.  The same is true for the Free Democrats, the other member of the coalition.  Schroder has damaged the SDP in a manner that may force Chancellor Scholz out of office.  The comments above by Soder of the opposition CSU suggest the political atmosphere for Scholz is deteriorating.  There is a growing likelihood that Green Party leader and current foreign minister Annalena Baerbock could take that role.  In any case, the only way for Scholz to survive will likely require him to take a much more hardline position against Russia.  Burying Osthandel would harden relations with Russia, regardless of who is in power in Russia.  And, of course, this hardening of relations has led to Germany planning to boost its defense spending.

Economics and policy:  China tariffs and other news.

  • The Biden administration is wrestling with how to manage tariffs on China. From an economic perspective, easing tariffs could reduce U.S. inflation, which has been a serious drag on the president’s approval ratings.  However, making conditions more favorable for China is a difficult sell.
  • Although she doesn’t have a  direct influence on the policy, Treasury Secretary Yellen has expressed opposition to raising the Fed’s 2% inflation target. Some economists (Adam Posen at the Peterson Institute has been vocal about this idea) have called for raising the target, arguing that the fact that the fed funds target fell to zero is clear evidence the inflation target is too low.  There isn’t much evidence to suggest that much thought went into picking a 2% target, but it has become the global standard.  There are two problems with changing it.  First, a target that can be changed often isn’t much of a target.  After all, the goal of the target is to create clarity for borrowers and lenders on the path of policy.  Second, it’s quite possible that a 4% target may lead to instability, as households and businesses might view a higher target as obvious debasement.
  • Small business surveys suggest confidence is falling, adding to evidence of a weakening economy. Economists are starting to downgrade their forecasts for economic growth.
  • When I used to teach, I would often use babysitting pay to illustrate opportunity cost. I tried to show that there may be a wage so high that it doesn’t make sense to stay in school, for instance.  It was mostly, at the time, a thought experiment.  However, parents are now seeing a shortage of sitters, and pay is skyrocketing, along with other perks.  Rates are being quoted at up to $30 per hour.

International roundup:  More from the president’s trip and an update on Israel

  • While in South Korea, President Biden and the newly elected President Yoon of South Korea agreed to increase the deterrence of North Korea.
  • It looked like the narrow coalition holding the Israeli government together was about to fray until a member of a Palestinian Party agreed to return to the coalition after threatening to leave. Her leaving would have led to a no-confidence vote and new elections.
  • A senior member of the Iran Revolutionary Guard Corps was assassinated outside his home yesterday. No one claimed responsibility for the attack.

COVID-19:  The number of reported cases is 525,686,037 with 6,277,389 fatalities.  In the U.S., there are 83,281,403 confirmed cases with 1,002,173 deaths.  For illustration purposes, the FT has created an interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.  The FT has also issued an economic tracker that looks across countries with high-frequency data on various factors.  The CDC reports that 741,676,155 doses of the vaccine have been distributed, with 584,279,990 doses injected.  The number receiving at least one dose is 258,149,591, while the number fully vaccinated, which would grant the highest level of immunity, is 220,914,142.  For the population older than 18, 76.5% of the population has been fully vaccinated, with 61.1% of the entire population fully vaccinated.  For those over 65, 90.5% have been fully vaccinated.  The FT has a page on global vaccine distribution.

View PDF