Asset Allocation Bi-Weekly – Where’s the Recession? Examining Employment (August 14, 2023)

by the Asset Allocation Committee | PDF

In August of last year, our yield-curve indicator signaled an inversion, which implies that a recession is set to occur within 16 months, on average.  And so, we are still within range of a recession occurring by year’s end.  However, the economic data continues to show improvement, raising hopes that the economy will avoid a full downturn.  In our May 22 report, we noted that new home sales were doing quite well, mostly because existing home sale listings were unusually low.  Essentially, the fact that most homeowners have a mortgage rate well below the current market is dampening home sales.  This improvement in housing has lowered the odds of recession.

In this report, we will discuss another aspect of why the recession has been avoided thus far—the labor markets continue to remain tight.  In Walter Scheidel’s book, The Great Leveler,[1] he postulated that inequality rises over time and that there are only four consistent factors that cause inequality to retreat:  mass industrial war, revolution, the breakdown of civil society, and pandemic.   Scheidel noted that after the Black Death, the loss of workers due to the plague led to a dramatic decline in workers, causing wages to rise.  Fortunately, the COVID-19 pandemic was not nearly as lethal as the Black Death, but it did have an impact on older workers’ participation in the labor force.

The chart on the left shows the over-55 labor force, while the chart on the right shows employment for the same cohort.  We have regressed a time trend through both series starting in 2000.  Note the onset of the pandemic led to a notable drop in both the labor force and employment for this age bracket.  How important is this development?  If the pre-pandemic trends had remained in place, the current unemployment rate would be 4.9% instead of 3.6%.

Using our Fed indicator, which subtracts CPI from the unemployment rate, if we use the pre-pandemic trends for employment in the labor force, then the indicator would be reading -1.94 instead of the current -0.63.  This reading would be consistent with at least steady policy and would likely be signaling the need to ease policy.

Overall, this study suggests that the labor market is tight because of older workers exiting due to the pandemic, an unusual circumstance.  Since the lethality of COVID-19 increased with age, it made sense that older workers left the workforce.  There has been speculation that they will eventually return, and they have, according to the data, but not to the pre-pandemic trend levels.  This analysis doesn’t mean the labor markets are not tight, but the tightness is partially due to the circumstances surrounding the pandemic.  Labor market tightness has tended to support wage growth which, in turn, has supported economic growth.  Although we still expect a recession in the coming months, there is a clear case that the lack of existing home supply and the exodus of older workers have reduced the economy’s sensitivity to rate hikes.  If inflation continues to decline (as we expect), then there is a chance that the U.S. can avoid a formal downturn.


[1] Scheidel, Walter. (2017). The Great Leveler: Violence and the History of Inequality from the Stone Age to the 21st Century. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press..

View PDF

Daily Comment (August 11, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Today’s Comment discusses the following key topics: why the Federal Reserve may be closer to reaching its 2% inflation target than investors realize, our concerns about the regional banking system, and how rising crime in South America complicates U.S. efforts to build closer ties in the region.

 It Gets Better: Thursday’s CPI report not only reinforced investors’ views that the Fed may be nearing the end of its hiking cycle, but also suggests that monetary policy may need to ease next year.

  • The Consumer Price Index (CPI) increased 3.2% in July from the previous year, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. The reading was above the previous month’s increase of 3.0% but below consensus estimates of 3.3%. Core inflation numbers were also impressive, declining from 4.8% to 4.7%. The reacceleration in the headline inflation number is likely due to base effect changes, which may not carry over to the next month. Meanwhile, the core CPI continues to be propped up by reporting lags in shelter data.
  • Despite both price gauges being well above the Fed’s inflation target of 2.0%, there is growing optimism that the Federal Reserve may not need to raise rates again this year. The monthly reading shows that headline inflation rose at an annual rate consistent with 2.3%, while core inflation rose at a pace consistent with 1.9%. The market took the CPI report positively as traders loaded up on bets that the central bank was going to pause in September. The CME FedWatch Tool shows that there is over a 90% chance that policymakers will leave rates unchanged at their next meeting.

  • Inflation is falling more quickly than most people realize. The July report shows that consumer prices have only risen 2.5% from the previous year after removing shelter, which accounts for over a third of the index weight, from core CPI. This discrepancy may continue going into next year, as it typically takes about 12-18 months for housing data to make its way into the CPI index. Additionally, if the San Francisco Fed is correct that shelter prices will fall into negative territory in 2024, it could mean that central bank policymakers may need to cut rates to avoid deflation.

Regional Bank Troubles: Nearly five months after the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank (SIVBQ, $0.15), small and midsized banks are still struggling to stand on their own.

  • Regional banks will continue to struggle as long as the Federal Reserve keeps interest rates in restrictive territory. This is because higher interest rates force banks to increase the amount they pay for deposits, which lowers their net interest margins. As a result, banks are not able to lend at the same levels, which could lead to slower economic growth. However, if the Fed commits to offering banks liquidity, it is unlikely that there will be a financial crisis any time soon. That said, regional banks’ inability to offer attractive savings rates to maintain deposits will leave them vulnerable to disintermediation.

Southern Uncertainty: Rising crime in South America is making it more difficult for the United States to build alliances with countries in the region that share its belief in democracy.

  • Rising violence within South America complicates the Biden administration’s efforts to expand its regional influence. President Biden has made “democracy versus autocracy” the organizing principle of his foreign policy, and his administration has made it clear that it will not support countries that backslide from democratic norms. This is likely why Biden refused to invite Cuba, Nicaragua, and Venezuela to the recent Summit of the Americas. As a result, the Biden administration is at risk of losing influence in the region to China, which has been more willing to overlook human rights abuses in order to expand its economic and political reach.

View PDF

Daily Comment (August 10, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning! Today’s Comment will focus on three key topics: the growing rift between the U.S. and China over semiconductors, possible threats to the European energy markets, and the White House’s latest attempt to mediate ties between Saudi Arabia and Israel.

 Another Salvo in the Chip War: The U.S.-China rivalry in artificial intelligence (AI) took a new turn after the U.S. government announced investment restrictions on Chinese tech companies.

  • Despite recent moves by the Biden administration to “de-risk” the relationship between the United States and China, the process is likely to be slow and arduous. China accounts for the largest share of the revenue for companies in the S&P 500 outside of North America, and Beijing’s shift toward deleveraging means that it is becoming more reliant on foreign investment for capital. As a result, there are strong incentives for both countries to keep the relationship going, even as tensions rise. Thus, these actions by the Biden administration are steps toward the long-term trajectory of the relationship, but it is unlikely to have a substantial impact on companies in the short- to medium-term.

 Eurozone Energy Concerns: After narrowly avoiding a recession in the last quarter, high energy prices are likely to put the eurozone economy back in focus for investors.

  • Earth’s hottest month on known record was July 2023, with global temperatures averaging 62.51 F, six-tenths of a degree higher than the previous record set in July 2019. This was largely due to El Niño conditions, which cause warmer ocean temperatures and more extreme weather events. The effects of El Niño on Europe are less consistent than in other regions, but northern countries could experience colder temperatures during the winter months, while southern countries in the region may experience wetter conditions. Potentially hazardous weather conditions could lead to a rise in energy demands.
  • The war in Ukraine and possible labor protests in Australia have added to the energy uncertainty. Russia and Ukraine have launched attacks near each other’s energy infrastructure. On Wednesday, a Russian drone strike hit an oil depot in Ukraine, while Ukrainian drone strikes in the Black Sea have raised concerns about potential supply disruptions, as they could damage shipping vessels carrying oil and gas. Simultaneously, natural gas prices in the region surged almost 40% following reports that workers at important LNG plants in Australia are planning a strike for higher pay and better job security. The issues in Ukraine and Australia raise the likelihood of supply shortages.

  • Although the euro area has made significant progress in building up its energy storage for the winter, there are still risks that could lead to energy spikes. A prominent German utility company has cautioned lawmakers against becoming overconfident in the region’s energy security. He warned that there is still much uncertainty concerning the upcoming winters, which could potentially lead to an energy crisis. A possible shortage of natural gas will weigh heavily on the struggling European economy and may push it into recession.

 Middle East Pivot: The White House has made a breakthrough with Saudi Arabia and is now hopeful of reaching a similar agreement with Israel.

  • Saudi Arabia agreed to terms that would allow it to recognize Israel in exchange for progress on the Palestinian issue and security guarantees. The details of the arrangement are still being negotiated, but U.S. officials are optimistic that a deal can be reached within the next year or so. Additionally, Washington is also urging Riyadh to impose limits on its relationship with China. In response to the agreement, Israel has also requested a defense pact with the U.S. to join the deal with Saudi Arabia, as it seeks protection from a growingly assertive Iran.
  • The U.S.’s efforts to resolve tensions between Saudi Arabia and Israel are a sign that it still wants to be a major player in the Middle East, even as it pivots toward the Indo-Pacific. This agreement will likely help counter the inroads China has made in the region. Over the last year or so, Beijing has engaged in talks with Riyadh over creating a petroyuan and has played a crucial role in restoring ties between Saudi Arabia and Iran. Resolving tensions between the two sides will likely build on the progress made with the Abraham Accords by paving the way for more peaceful relations in the Middle East.

  • As the U.S. moves away from its role as an importer of last resort, it will likely continue to provide defense assistance to other countries to maintain its influence. This could take the form of intelligence sharing, joint military exercises, or weapon exports. We have already seen some of this play out in Ukraine and Taiwan, and it is possible that the U.S. would be willing to do the same in the Middle East. American defense and aerospace industries are well-positioned to capitalize on the global rearmament trend, as they have a long history of providing arms to allies and partners around the world.

View PDF

Weekly Energy Update (August 10, 2023)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA | PDF

Oil prices are challenging the upper end of the trading range but so far have failed to breakout above that level.

(Source: Barchart.com)

Commercial crude oil inventories rose 6.8 mb, well above the 3.0 mb build forecast.  The SPR rose 1.0 mb.

In the details, U.S. crude oil production jumped 0.4 mbpd to 12.6 mbpd.  The adjustment factor, which is a plug number to make the supply balance sheet “balance,” has been high in recent weeks.  We suspect the DOE had been undercounting barrels and thus has adjusted production higher.  Exports dropped 2.9 mbpd, while imports were unchanged.  Refining activity rose 1.1% to 93.8% of capacity.

(Sources: DOE, CIM)

The above chart shows the seasonal pattern for crude oil inventories.  Last week’s rise partly offset the large draw from the previous week.  However, inventories remain a bit below their seasonal average.

Fair value, using commercial inventories and the EUR for independent variables, yields a price of $64.21.  Commercial inventory levels are a bearish factor for oil prices, but with the unprecedented withdrawal of SPR oil, we think that the total-stocks number is more relevant.

Since the SPR is being used, to some extent, as a buffer stock, we have constructed oil inventory charts incorporating both the SPR and commercial inventories.

Total stockpiles peaked in 2017 and are now at levels last seen in late 1985.  Using total stocks since 2015, fair value is $93.30.

Market News:

 Geopolitical News:

 Alternative Energy/Policy News:

  • Fusion power is back in the headlines. One of the keys to the scientific method is repeatability.  If an experimental outcome isn’t repeatable, it probably isn’t real.  U.S. government scientists are claiming they have achieved a net gain in a fusion reaction for the second time.  Although we doubt fusion will be commercially feasible for decades, we do note that researchers are starting on the process.
  • China continues to make inroads into global auto markets. In July, the bestselling EV in Sweden was a Chinese nameplate.
    • The Inflation Reduction Act created incentives to build EVs and key components in the U.S. One way this was structured was to deny consumers the tax credit if the car or batteries came from outside the U.S. or from nations without a free trade agreement with the U.S.  Such restrictions create incentives for evasion.  China is apparently investing heavily in South Korea’s EV battery industry, likely to create an avenue to gain access to the U.S. auto market.  South Korea has a free trade agreement with the U.S.
    • Chery Automotive, a Chinese SOE and the country’s ninth largest automaker, is teaming up with Huawei (002502, CNY, 2.38) to provide the operating system for some of its vehicles. The U.S. considers Huawei to be a potential conduit of information to the Chinese government, so it will be worth watching to see how Washington responds to nations importing these cars.
    • A price war for EVs in China has emerged, meaning it’s cheaper to purchase electric than gasoline vehicles.
    • As we have noted before, Western policymakers need to balance the goal of reducing carbon emissions with the foreign policy goal of isolating China. As this report points out, it’s a difficult tradeoff.
  • It’s likely that the early adoption phase of EVs is coming to a close. If so, it means new buyers will be more discriminating in terms of price and when making comparisons to gasoline cars.  That may mean that adoption will slow, and hybrids might become more prominent.
  • New technology could spur expanded use of geothermal power by expanding the use of horizontal drilling to create more “hot spots” to generate power.
  • As we have documented on numerous occasions, the move away from fossil fuels will entail a wholesale shift into metals. Copper, lithium, nickel, cobalt, and other metals will be needed for many of the alternatives, from windmills to solar panels to EVs.  As we have also noted, China dominates many of these metals, both in their mining and processing.  The West is trying to source these key inputs from areas free of China’s control.  However, the task is proving difficult.
  • Another recent theme we have discussed is that the joint goals of reindustrializing America (and the industrial working class) and meeting climate targets may be in conflict. Emphasizing the former will lead to higher costs, while focusing on the latter may lead to more imports which would not help the U.S. industrial sector.  Balancing these policy goals is difficult, but if the leadership sides with meeting climate goals over the goals of labor, the political costs could be large.
  • In the U.S., solar power additions to utility capacity are expected to grow sharply by year’s end. Meanwhile, China is investing in pumped storage in conjunction with wind and solar power.  Pumped storage allows power to be provided when the sun doesn’t shine and the wind doesn’t blow.
  • U.S. utilities are warning that the Biden administration’s plans to restrict carbon emissions are unworkable.

  View PDF

Daily Comment (August 9, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with the latest news on China’s deteriorating relations with the West and the problems in its domestic economy.  We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including reports of rising inflation expectations in the eurozone and negative signs regarding the current labor contract talks in the U.S. auto sector.

China-Taiwan-Japan:  During a rare visit to Taiwan by a high-ranking Japanese official, former Prime Minister and current Vice President of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party Tarō Asō said the current period of peace in the region is now “tilting toward a time of emergency.”  Without specifically naming China and its intention to retake control of Taiwan, he warned that Japan, the U.S., and their allies would only be able to maintain peace in the Taiwan Strait if they bulk up their armed forces enough to deter any military action from a third country.  The warning is consistent with the analysis in our latest Bi-Weekly Geopolitical Report, published on Monday.

China-United States:  In the U.S.’s latest effort to keep the Chinese military from acquiring cutting-edge technology, President Biden will sign an executive order today requiring U.S. investors to report any private-equity or venture-capital stakes that they take in Chinese firms involved with semiconductors, quantum computing, or artificial intelligence.  Under the order, U.S. investors would also be banned outright from making direct investments in specific areas of those sectors.

  • The new rules will reportedly be less stringent than China hawks in Congress and the military advocated, probably because of lobbying by business elites and some in the administration who want to limit tensions with China.
  • Nevertheless, coming less than a year after the administration’s tough restrictions on sending advanced semiconductor technologies to China, the new rules will surely be seen by Beijing as a further attempt to hamstring China’s economic development. U.S. investment in China has fallen sharply in recent years, but the new rules could push it down even further.
  • In any case, the new rules will worsen U.S.-China tensions further, which we continue to believe will dramatically affect the global economy and create risks for U.S. investors in the coming years.

China:  In the latest bad omen for China’s domestic economy, the July consumer price index was down 0.2% from the same month one year earlier, marking the first bout of deflation since 2020.  Unlike the U.S. and many other developed countries, China experienced little inflation amid the supply disruptions at the end of the coronavirus pandemic, at least in part because the government never provided much financial aid to help households get through the crisis.  Now that the pandemic has passed, however, many consumers are focused on rebuilding their savings rather than buying.

  • Weak consumption demand and government interference in the economy are also discouraging investment, as is weak demand for Chinese exports. The situation is making it increasingly difficult for Chinese firms to hike prices.
  • For the global economy, Chinese deflation translates into lower export prices which may help hold down inflation around the world. On a less positive note, however, low-priced Chinese goods dumped on the global market could weigh on foreign corporate margins.

Eurozone:  Despite the deflation in China, a popular gauge of future inflation expectations in the eurozone suggests investors are becoming more pessimistic about price hikes there.  The region’s “five-year, five-year forward inflation swap — a measure of the markets’ expectation of price growth over the second half of the next decade — hit 2.66% this week,” compared with the eurozone’s average inflation rate of about 1.3% in the decade before the coronavirus pandemic.

Italy:  Prime Minister Meloni’s right-wing populist government was forced to partially backtrack on its surprise windfall profits tax on lending institutions, which we described in our Comment yesterday.  It appears the government was unsettled by the big drop in Italian bank stocks yesterday, so it has instead said the tax will be capped at 0.1% of the banks’ risk-weighted capital.  That’s about one-fifth of the originally estimated hit.

U.S. Labor Market:  In a worrisome sign for the ongoing contract negotiations between the United Autoworkers Union and Stellantis (STLA, $19.34), UAW chief Shawn Fain has complained that concessions demanded by the automaker are a “slap in the face” to union workers.  Coupled with militant statements by other UAW officials recently, Fain’s statement underscores that the union is likely to drive a very tough bargain, as workers and their representatives know they have increased leverage amid today’s tight labor market.  We suspect the major U.S. automakers will need to agree to significant pay increases and improved benefits to avoid a strike this fall.

U.S. Commercial Real Estate Market:  New figures from Jones Lang LaSalle (JLL, $175.05) show real estate developers demolished 14.7 million square feet of office space in the first half of 2023, while breaking ground on only 4.8 million square feet.  That marks the first time in recent memory in which developers tore down more office space than they built.  The data provides further evidence of today’s pessimism regarding the prospects for commercial office space.

U.S. Orange Juice Market:  Nearby futures for frozen concentrated orange juice have hit a record high above $3.00 per pound, reflecting a dramatic decline in Florida’s citrus crop due to a string of hurricanes and tree blight in recent years.  Production in the state has fallen from about 240 million boxes per year two decades ago to just 18 million boxes this year.

View PDF

Daily Comment (August 8, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with new evidence of military aggressiveness from the China/Russia bloc, which we continue to believe will produce risks for investors exposed to China or to companies dependent on China.  We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including a surprise windfall profits tax on Italian banks and a credit-rating cut on several regional banks in the U.S.

China-Russia-United States:  It was reported yesterday that almost a dozen Chinese and Russian navy vessels sailed close to the Aleutian Islands off Alaska last week, in what is believed to be the largest such joint operation ever.  In response, the U.S. Navy dispatched four destroyers and a surveillance plane to shadow the flotilla.

  • Even though the Chinese and Russian ships did not enter U.S. territorial waters and have since left the area, officials are considering it unusually brazen and provocative.
  • The incident also highlights our concern about the potential for increased Chinese and Russian naval cooperation.
    • Even though China now has the world’s largest navy in terms of the number of its combat ships, it still consists mostly of smaller vessels geared toward defending the waters along China’s coast. Over time, China intends to build a “blue water” navy that can project power globally, but that remains a work in process.
    • In contrast, the Russian navy, which ranks as the world’s third-largest (just behind the U.S. Navy) has long been able to project power globally, especially via its advanced submarines. Many of its ocean-going surface ships have also been modernized with highly capable cruise missiles, as shown in the war in Ukraine.
    • If the Chinese and Russian navies set their minds to cooperating more fully and building synergies, and if they build up enough bases or port rights in friendly countries, they could potentially help the China/Russia bloc become a much more formidable military force around the world.

China:  July exports were down a whopping 14.5% from the same month one year earlier, after June exports were down 12.4% year-over-year.  Along with similarly bad export declines for other Asian economies, such as South Korea, the figures show how regional economies are being hurt as Western consumers shift from pandemic-driven goods consumption to post-pandemic services.  For China, the export challenges also exacerbate domestic issues, such as the state’s increasing interference in the economy and worsening demographics.

Russia-Ukraine War:  As Ukraine’s forces continue their slow, plodding counteroffensive against the Russians in the eastern parts of the country, new reports suggest that the U.S.’s recent provision of “cluster munitions” has helped improve their progress.  The new munitions are reportedly helping the Ukrainians hit concentrations of Russian infantry, groups of vehicles, and other targets, allowing Kyiv’s forces to make better progress than before.

Pakistan:  Prime Minister Sharif said he plans to dissolve parliament on Wednesday and transfer power to a caretaker administration, a step that would normally lead to new elections within 90 days.  However, a Sharif-led committee on Saturday also said it would redraw the country’s electoral districts in response to Pakistan’s latest census, potentially pushing the next elections into next year.

  • If the elections are postponed until early 2024, it would produce a prolonged period in which the country is led by a government not backed by parliament.
  • Coupled with the recent jailing of opposition leader and former Prime Minister Khan, the moves suggest Pakistan’s democracy is being steadily undermined. In turn, that could produce further political and social instability.

Italy:  The right-wing populist government of Prime Minister Meloni unexpectedly announced a windfall tax on bank profits generated by higher interest rates.  According to the government, the tax proceeds will be used to provide relief to families hurt by higher interest costs.  The move follows Meloni’s recent criticism that banks have been too slow to boost interest payments to depositors.  As might be expected, the announcement is weighing heavily on Italian banking stocks so far this morning.

U.S. Energy Prices:  With global crude oil prices trending up again in response to OPEC+ supply cuts and stronger-than-expected demand, retail gasoline prices last week rose to an average of $3.87 per gallon, reaching their highest level since last November.  If gasoline prices continue to rise, they could start to put ever more upward pressure on the consumer price index, potentially reversing some of the recent moderation in overall price inflation.

U.S. Banking Industry:  Moody’s (MCO, $342.41) said it has cut the credit ratings of 10 key regional banks and is reviewing the ratings of six other institutions, based on concerns that the Fed’s continued interest-rate hikes will undermine their funding and impinge on their capital.  Each cut was only one notch, and all the banks kept their investment-grade rating.  Nevertheless, the move has rekindled concerns about mid-sized lenders like those that failed in March.  That’s helping push down the value of risk assets so far this morning.

U.S. Commercial Real Estate Industry:  Leading mortgage real estate investment trusts Blackstone Mortgage Trust (BXMT, $22.79) and KKR Real Estate Finance Trust (KREF, $12.51) said they extended no new commercial mortgage loans in the first half of 2023.  Before this year’s problems in the sector, the firms would have likely provided billions of dollars of new loans each quarter.

  • The REITs’ pullback in lending offers further evidence of just how much investors have soured on the prospects for commercial real estate, especially office buildings.
  • Eventually, the sentiment on commercial real estate will hit rock bottom and potentially produce great bargains in the REIT sector. However, we believe it’s still too early for that to happen.

View PDF

Bi-Weekly Geopolitical Report – The Economics of National Defense in Great Power Competition (August 7, 2023)

Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA | PDF

Tensions between the United States and China continue to worsen, with the two nations hurtling toward each other in a geopolitical game of chicken that, in a worst case scenario, could potentially end up in war.  In the distance, a few possible off-ramps still hold promise, but the two powers are charging at each other so fast that it will be tough to make the turn onto any of them.  If war comes, it will most likely start with a Chinese grab for Taiwan.  However, the war wouldn’t really be a fight for control of a subtropical island slightly bigger than Maryland, some 100 miles off the southeast coast of China.  Taiwan would only serve as the immediate excuse for war.  The war would really be a contest for the world’s future.  The war would pit the vision and fundamental interests of the U.S. and its geopolitical and economic bloc against the vision and interests of the China/Russia[1] bloc.

If war comes, the spoils of victory would be what we call the three Ts: Territory, Technology, and Trade.  To the victor would go the territory of Taiwan, or for the U.S., the assurance of Taiwan’s territorial integrity.  Keeping Taiwan unshackled would preserve the global space for democracy and freedom and ensure that Taiwan remains a bulwark against the authoritarian rule of the Chinese Communist Party.  To the victor would also go Taiwan’s unique factories and workers producing the world’s most advanced semiconductor technologies.  Finally, the victor would secure the ability to restrict or keep open the vital sea lanes and trade routes feeding key U.S. allies like Japan and South Korea.

Since both the U.S. bloc and the China/Russia bloc could deploy masses of highly destructive weapons and concentrate them on a limited objective, a war over Taiwan could be relatively short—days or weeks, rather than months or years.  All the same, properly preparing for such a war would require a long-term effort.  The military buildup that has given China the world’s largest navy and put it in position to possibly win such a conflict has continued for far more than a decade.  As the West has learned in its struggle to arm Ukraine against Russia’s invasion, “Great Power” military preparedness requires full-scale exploitation of a country’s national resources and a large, advanced defense industry.  In this report, we discuss the economics of defense in today’s Great Power competition and what it means for investors.

Read the full report


[1] Given the increased geopolitical and economic cooperation between China and Russia, we now refer to their bloc jointly.  However, we still believe China is the main driver of this bloc.

Don’t miss our accompanying podcasts, available on our website and most podcast platforms: Apple | Spotify | Google
The podcast episode for this particular edition will be available later this week and posted under the Confluence of Ideas series.

Daily Comment (August 7, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with several items related to China and its relations with the rest of the world.  We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including news of continuing moderate declines in U.K. home prices and more evidence that U.S. scientists on making progress on using fusion as a future energy source.

China-Australia:  The Chinese Ministry of Commerce said it will finally remove the 80.5% tariff on Australian barley that was imposed in May 2020 to retaliate against then-Prime Minister Morrison’s call to investigate Beijing’s role in the global coronavirus pandemic.

  • Faced with slowing economic growth, worsening relations with the West, and a realization that the tariffs hadn’t had much impact on Australia, the Chinese government in recent months has been signaling that it will ease off its punitive measures.
  • Once the barley tariffs are lifted, Canberra is hoping Beijing will also lift its punitive tariffs on Australian wine.

China-Ukraine-Russia:  The multilateral peace forum on the war in Ukraine held in Saudi Arabia over the weekend failed to produce any concrete results, but diplomats are praising China’s “constructive” participation and its commitment to also attend the next meeting.  China’s participation in the forum, which focused on Kyiv’s 10-point plan to end the war, is being taken as a sign that it is putting a bit of distance between itself and Russia, despite President Xi and President Putin declaring a “no limits” partnership in the past.

China-Philippines:  Despite China’s improved behavior in some aspects of its international relations, the Chinese continue to harass some members of the U.S.-led geopolitical bloc.  On Saturday, a Chinese coast guard vessel blocked and water-cannoned a ship trying to resupply Philippine troops on a contested shoal in the South China Sea.  The shoal is well within the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone, but China claims it as its own territory.

  • China’s aggressive action was apparently planned well in advance. The move likely aimed to punish the Philippines for its recent assertiveness in defending its exclusive economic zone, strengthening its U.S. alliance and other security partnerships, and publicizing China’s gray-zone aggression in the South China Sea.
  • The Chinese action is particularly concerning because any armed attack on Philippine public vessels, aircraft, or armed forces in the South China Sea would invoke U.S. mutual defense commitments under the U.S.-Philippine security treaty.

China-United States:  Late last week, U.S. authorities arrested two ethnic-Chinese sailors in the U.S. Navy for selling military secrets to a Chinese intelligence officer in California.  The arrests illustrate how China’s Ministry of State Security focuses on recruiting Chinese Americans and ethnic Chinese people living in the U.S. to gain access to sensitive military secrets, technology, and other information.

United Kingdom:  Data from housing firm Halifax showed U.K. home prices declined in July to an average of £285,044, for a fourth straight monthly decline.  Nevertheless, even as the air comes out of the British housing market in response to slow economic growth and a long string of interest-rate hikes by the Bank of England, the home-price declines remain relatively modest.  The average home price reported by Halifax was down just 0.3% from June, and it was down just 2.4% from the same month one year earlier.

Niger:  The junta that seized control of the government last week closed the country’s airspace, forcing several international airline flights to be re-routed.  The airspace closure was apparently to help thwart a threatened military intervention by the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS).  The ECOWAS militaries had threatened to intervene if the coup plotters didn’t step down by Sunday, but the deadline has passed with no action so far.

U.S. Private Property Rights:  A nonprofit led by Edward Blum, the activist who pushed for this summer’s Supreme Court decision outlawing affirmative action in college admissions, has sued to block the Black-owned venture capital organization known as the Fearless Fund from running its program offering grants to small businesses owned by Black women.  Alleging the program practices unlawful racial discrimination, the suit suggests that today’s culture wars could potentially trip up private investment funds or investors who want to seed projects by historically undercapitalized groups.

U.S. Bond Market:  Even as the yield on shorter-term fixed income remains relatively stable, the yield on benchmark 10-year Treasury obligations settled at 4.060% on Friday, within striking distance of the 14-year high of 4.321% reached last October.  The “bear steepening” is widely considered a reflection of growing optimism about the economy.  We still think a mild recession is likely soon, but more investors and analysts seem to be looking for a “soft landing” that would encourage the monetary policymakers to keep interest rates high for an extended period.

U.S. Real Estate Market:  New research from the University of Toronto shows that diverse city downtowns with a mix of offices, residences, and attractions have nearly returned to, or even exceeded, their pre-pandemic foot traffic rates.  In contrast, downtowns that feature mainly office buildings remain far below their pre-pandemic foot-traffic levels.  That realization is sparking downtown redevelopment projects in a number of cities, many of which involve municipal governments providing incentives for office-to-residential conversions.

U.S. Fusion Energy:  Scientists at the Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory in California said they have successfully repeated an experiment in which they sparked a fusion reaction that produced more energy than it used.  The successful replication has led to increased optimism that scientists are now on track to eventually be able to produce copious amounts of clean energy, which could dramatically reshape the economy and produce new investment opportunities in the coming decades.

View PDF

Daily Comment (August 4, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning! Today’s Comment will discuss three topics: recent optimism about the global economy, the Bank of Japan’s recent intervention in bond markets, and the increase in global defense spending due to the rift between the U.S. and China.

 Turning Tide: While a possible recession was a hot topic at the start of the year, there is now growing optimism that the economy may be more resilient than previously thought.

  • Persistently strong economic data has shifted the conversation from an imminent downturn to sustained growth. Earlier this week, Bank of America (BA, $31.41) concluded that a recession is unlikely to occur in 2023. Meanwhile, Richmond Fed President Thomas Barkin expressed confidence that the Federal Reserve may be able to achieve a soft landing if inflation continues to ease. This increased confidence is supported by a wave of positive economic data, which suggests that the labor market remains tight, and spending remains robust despite rising borrowing costs. However, this does not mean there is no risk of a downturn.
  • Despite some encouraging signals, the state of the business cycle remains uncertain, as there are still several risks. The government’s inability to agree on a budget agreement will likely impact bond yields, which could lead to higher borrowing costs over the next few weeks. At the same time, there appears to be a notable deceleration in the rate of consumption and hiring. The latest GDP report showed a significant slowdown in consumption from an annual pace of 4.16% in the first quarter of 2023 to 1.64% in Q2. At the same time, the jobs report showed that job creation disappointed for the second consecutive month.

  • During the pandemic, households and firms took advantage of transfer payments and lower interest rates to pay down debt and extend loan duration. As a result, consumers were prepared and able to absorb higher prices in the months following, while firms were less pressed for financing. This dynamic explains why monetary tightening has not yet led to a sharp increase in defaults. However, it is unclear how long the economy can keep this up, as the farther away we move from the pandemic, the more vulnerable households and firms will be to rising borrowing costs. This may mean that the economy will slow down this year, even if it is able to avoid a recession.

 Not So Fast! A week after its historic shift in monetary policy, the Bank of Japan (BOJ) is signaling that it is not ready to be completely hands-off.

  • On Thursday, the Bank of Japan (BOJ) made an unscheduled intervention in the bond market for the second time this week, by offering to buy $2.09 billion of bonds with five to 10 years left until maturity in an effort to control the rise in yields. The announcement came in response to a sudden rise in 10-year Japanese government bonds, which saw yields rise to a nine-year high of 0.65%. The purchases highlight the central bank’s unwillingness to tolerate a massive spike in interest rates following its decision to loosen its grip on 10-year debt yields.
  • Investors were confused by the BOJ’s actions, as it was unclear how much the bank was willing to tolerate in terms of the pace of the increase in yields. Although the central bank’s intervention led to a modest decline in yields, the bond market was not significantly impacted as rates quickly returned to their previous level. A similar situation occurred in the currency market, as the yen (JPY) bounced back after initially depreciating against the dollar. However, equities were negatively affected, with the TOPIX index ending the day down 1.45%.

  • As the world’s largest creditor, Japan’s monetary policy significantly impacts the global economy. Data from the Japanese Ministry of Finance shows that foreign investors have been increasing their holdings of Japanese long-term debt since the BOJ first tweaked its policy in December 2022. Simultaneously, Japanese investors have been offloading their holdings in the weeks leading up to the central bank’s latest rate decision. As short-term rates in Japan begin to rise, we expect higher yields will encourage residents to bring capital back home. However, this shift is likely to take time to materialize, as rates in the United States and Europe remain attractive.

Military Rising: The United States and its allies are continuing to increase their military spending in an effort to create a stronger deterrent to China in the Pacific.

(Source: Wikimedia Commons)

  • The growing rivalry between the United States and China is driving a global arms race. Countries are ramping up spending on defense as they look to choose sides and protect their own interests. Rising military demand will likely benefit the defense and aerospace industries, as they will likely be the recipients of much of this new spending. However, the major obstacle to this increase in investment is the need to generate the necessary revenue to pay for new weapons. As a result, we believe that the world’s shift towards building up military capacity will likely be gradual.

View PDF