Weekly Energy Update (August 27, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA | PDF

Here is an updated crude oil price chart.  The oil market has stabilized at higher levels after April’s historic collapse.

(Source: Barchart.com)

Crude oil inventories fell more than anticipated, declining 4.7 mb compared to forecasts of a 3.0 mb decline.  The SPR declined 1.8 mb; since peaking at 656.1 mb in July, the SPR has drawn 6.6 mb.  Given levels in April, we expect that another 14.5 mb will be withdrawn as this oil was placed in the SPR for temporary storage.  Taking the SPR into account, storage dropped 6.5 mb.

In the details, U.S. crude oil production rose 0.1 mbpd to 10.8 mbpd.  Exports jumped 1.2 mbpd, while imports rose 0.2 mbpd.  Refining activity rose 1.1%.

(Sources: DOE, CIM)

The above chart shows the annual seasonal pattern for crude oil inventories.  This week’s data showed another decline in crude oil stockpiles.  We are approaching the end of the seasonal withdrawal period.  Although the declines of the last few weeks are supportive, stockpiles remain well above seasonal norms and remain a bearish factor.

Next week’s data, and data for the next few weeks, will likely be affected by Hurricane Laura.  The storm will disrupt refinery operations and seaborne trade for the next few weeks.  In 2005, the combination of Hurricanes Katrina and Rita took refinery operations from 95% to just below 70%.  Although we don’t expect a repeat of that situation, we will see a drop in refinery operations.  Currently, the nation is well stocked with crude oil and distillates (diesel).  A bit worrisome is that gasoline stockpiles are less ample, although demand remains low enough that we don’t expect a sustained jump in prices due to the hurricane.

Based on our oil inventory/price model, fair value is $37.99; using the euro/price model, fair value is $64.09.  The combined model, a broader analysis of the oil price, generates a fair value of $51.16.  The wide divergence continues between the EUR and oil inventory models.  As the trend in the dollar rolls over, it is bullish for crude oil.  Any supportive news on reducing the inventory overhang could be very bullish for crude oil.

Gasoline consumption has started to edge higher.  Although we probably won’t see the usual seasonal decline in consumption (there wasn’t much of a vacation season), the improvement we are seeing is consistent with a better economy.

In oil news, Kuwait and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA), with the support of the U.S., are looking to link the power grid of these Gulf States to Iraq.  Baghdad has mostly fallen under the sway of Iran since most U.S. forces have left Iraq, but the dominance isn’t complete.  The hope is that if Iraq’s economy is tied more closely to the Arab states, Iranian influence can be weakened.

Massive public investment projects continue in the KSA despite weak oil prices.  It is clear that CP Salman is moving quickly to diversify the Saudi economy away from oil and believes these megaprojects are the path to foster this goal.  Although we do agree that we are probably now past the era of peak oil (the removal of Exxon (XOM, 40.03) from the Dow Jones is a symbol of this trend), we are not sure that these projects will give the KSA the ability to diversify from oil.  At the same time, the existence and high priority of these projects indicate Riyadh does see that its current economic structure won’t last indefinitely.

The UN Security Council has rejected a U.S. bid to “snapback” suspended sanctions on Iran for violating the terms of the Iran nuclear deal.  After pulling out of the arrangement and implementing unilateral sanctions on Iran, the U.S. wanted to reinstate the international ones that existed before the deal was made in 2015.  Although American sanctions are potent, they lack the international credibility of the UN imprimatur, and thus the odds are increased that other nations may violate American sanctions.

Economists have argued for some time that the most efficient way to reduce hydrocarbon consumption is with a carbon tax.  Creating a price for carbon gives signals to consumers and producers that support changes in behavior.  California is the only U.S. state with a modified version of a carbon tax (it uses a “cap and trade” model that is similar to a tax), where preserving forests, which pull carbon dioxide out of the atmosphere, can offset carbon production in other parts of the economy.  This gives trees an economic value other than for tourism and lumber.

View PDF

Daily Comment (August 26, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

It’s a pretty quiet news day today, which is probably fitting for the dog days of summer.  Unfortunately, the lack of news also means there’s still no discernible progress on the next coronavirus relief bill in Congress.  Another negative is that Hurricane Laura is bearing down on the Gulf Coast.  We are also getting reminders that the U.S.-China relationship remains tense enough to be a potential threat to the markets.  We outline all the key news below.

United States-China:  According to new reporting by the Wall Street Journal, the July demand by the U.S. that China close its consulate in Houston also included a demand that China remove all of its active-duty military officers conducting research in the U.S. under academic guise.  The administration has become increasingly concerned that those military members, with the help of diplomats in China’s consulates, are a key method by which the People’s Liberation Army is trying to soak up sensitive U.S. technologies.  Separately, a prominent Chinese economist and government advisor said China should refuse to export medicines and drug precursors to the U.S. in retaliation for U.S. restrictions on semiconductor sales to Chinese companies.  Finally, the American Chamber of Commerce in Shanghai warned of significant harm to U.S. firms operating in China if President Trump’s recent executive order on WeChat is applied too broadly.  According to a survey of its members, the Chamber said that a broad ban on U.S. citizens and companies transacting with the Chinese chat messaging and commercial platform would mean that almost 90% of U.S. firms in China would find it harder to communicate with staff and local authorities.

China:  Experts are warning that President Xi’s latest “anti-corruption” purge may be intended to help Xi be named Communist Party Chairman—a title that hasn’t been used in decades.  Taking on the same title held by Chairman Mao would in turn help Xi hold on to power beyond his second term.

Hong Kong:  As the government continues to crack down on political protests following the introduction of Hong Kong’s new security law in June, two pro-democracy lawmakers have been arrested for allegedly participating in anti-China demonstrations last year.  The two legislators, Ted Hui and Lam Cheuk-ting of the opposition Democratic Party, were detained early today.

Sweden:  Alarmed by Russia’s aggressive territorial moves and military exercises, the Swedish government has adopted a heightened state of military readiness and is beefing up its defenses.  The country’s military readiness is now reportedly at its highest since the early 1990s.

India:  Reserve Bank of India Governor Shaktikanta Das has warned that India’s state-dominated banking system will need to push ahead with an infusion of funds to withstand the country’s deepening coronavirus crisis.

Lebanon:  Saad Hariri, a three-time former prime minister, made clear on Tuesday that he is not interested in taking the job again and forming a new government amidst the political turmoil touched off by the country’s recent port explosion disaster and economic crisis.  “Certain political forces are still in a state of severe denial of the reality of Lebanon,” he said in a statement, a nod both to his lack of support and the political establishment’s resistance to meaningful reform.

Hurricane news:  Tropical Storm Laura was upgraded to a hurricane, with a projected landfall around the Texas-Louisiana border late Wednesday or early Thursday.  As we mentioned in yesterday’s report, the storm could push many people into emergency shelters for a significant period.  If so, it could constitute as a “super-spreader event” and spark a rise in national coronavirus cases in the coming weeks.  Separately, oil and gasoline futures have strengthened in response to the storm, based on concerns that it could force temporary production shutdowns.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 23,930,649 worldwide, with 820,246 deaths and 15,606,094 recoveries.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 5,779,707, with 178,535 deaths and 2,053,699 recoveries.  Here is the interactive chart from the Financial Times that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population.

Virology

Economic Impact

  • Highlighting the continued dearth of business travel it expects even after the pandemic ends, American Airlines (AAL, 13.14) said yesterday it would shed 19,000 workers on October 1, as soon as layoff restrictions tied to its federal crisis funding end.

Foreign Policy Response

  • The German government announced that wage subsidies for workers furloughed by the pandemic will be extended by 12 months to the end of 2021, in contrast with most other European countries, whose programs are set to expire in the coming months.  The government will also extend a program providing grants to companies to help them cover their fixed costs and a provision allowing firms to avoid filing for bankruptcy if they can’t service their debt.
  • In new proposals to help British homeowners having trouble paying their mortgages during the crisis, the U.K. Financial Conduct Authority said lenders must continue to provide repayment relief support measures even after the October 31 expiration of a program giving borrowers the right to claim a three-month payment holiday.  After October 31, lenders must consider the appropriateness of different “long- and short-term” measures, which could include extending the repayment term of a mortgage to reduce the monthly repayments or restructuring loans.
  • While the popular perception is that left-of-center political leaders are more apt to support stricter lockdown measures to contain the virus, South Korea shows that’s not necessarily the case everywhere.
    • With COVID-19 cases rising for nearly two weeks straight, the majority of South Koreans want the nation’s maximum social-distancing measures imposed, and so do the country’s opposition conservative lawmakers and some medical associations.
    • The holdouts are South Korea’s left-leaning President Moon Jae-in and the public health architects of one of the world’s successful virus responses, backed up by small businesses and government economic advisers.

View PDF

Daily Comment (August 25, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

The newest Confluence of Ideas podcast episode, “The Dollar and the Eurobond,” is available today!  This episode looks at the decision by the EU to create a mutualized bond, a debt instrument backed by the full faith and credit of all the member states of the EU, and how this could affect the dollar’s reserve currency role and create a competing instrument for the U.S. Treasury.  Although the dollar remains the global reserve currency, there is widespread dissatisfaction with the role.  On the domestic front, the dollar’s role has been positive for financial services and retailers, but it has been a persistent negative factor for import-competing industries and their workers.  Foreign nations are increasingly uncomfortable with the U.S. weaponization of the dollar through financial sanctions.  If debt mutualization continues to expand, the euro will become an attractive reserve currency to foreign reserve managers.

The strength in U.S. risk assets so far today stems in large part from signs that the U.S.-China trade deal signed in January is still on track, despite all the other friction points in the bilateral relationship.  Oil and gas prices are up as Tropical Storm Laura heads toward the Gulf Coast.  For once, there is little new info on the coronavirus pandemic.  We review all the key news below.

United States-China: After a videoconference between U.S. Trade Representative Lighthizer, Treasury Secretary Mnuchin, and Chinese Vice Premier Liu He to review the U.S.-China trade deal signed in January, the Trade Representative’s office released a short statement saying, “Both sides see progress and are committed to taking the steps necessary to ensure the success of the agreement.”  China’s official Xinhua News Agency published a statement saying, “Both sides agreed to create conditions and atmosphere to continue to promote the implementation” of the trade pact.  The statements provide reassurance that the agreement remains in place regardless of China’s apparent shortfall to date in meeting its commitment to import more U.S. products.  The statements therefore suggest trade tensions between the countries could remain calm in the near term.  That’s clearly a positive for risk assets for now.  However, it’s important to remember that there are plenty of other friction points between the U.S. and China, such as China’s geopolitical aggressiveness, technology theft, and spying, to name a few.  All the U.S.-China friction points could heat up again if they become a point of contention in the runup to the U.S. elections in November.

United States: The Republican Party launched its mostly online convention yesterday, with President Trump being nominated unanimously as its candidate for president.  The convention programming included a noticeably higher share of live speeches than the Democratic one last week, though there isn’t yet much of a sense which party was more successful in engaging the national audience.  We also noted that in discussing his administration’s response to the coronavirus pandemic, President Trump reverted to calling it the “China virus.”  That signals China bashing could indeed be a significant part of Trump’s campaign leading up to November.

Speaking of elections, National Security Agency Director and head of U.S. Cyber Command Paul Nakasone, along with senior Cyber Command adviser Michael Sulmeyer, have published an article in Foreign Affairs stating that the U.S. “disrupted a concerted effort to undermine the midterm elections” in 2018 and is using those lessons to protect November’s elections.  The article claims experts at the NSA and Cyber Command have “formed the Russia Small Group (RSG), a task force created to ensure that democratic processes were executed unfettered by Russian activity.”

China-India: In response to the China-India border dispute in the Himalaya Mountains, the Indian government has quietly started to phase out equipment from Huawei (002502.SZ, 3.04) and other Chinese companies from its telecom networks.  New Delhi has issued no formal written ban on Chinese equipment, nor has Prime Minister Modi’s government made any such public pronouncements.  However, industry executives and government officials say key ministries have clearly indicated that local telecom service providers should avoid using Chinese equipment in future investments, including in 5G networks.  The move suggests the U.S. is gradually bringing more countries to its side in its effort to roll back Chinese economic, technological, and spying activities around the globe.

Russia: German doctors treating Russian opposition activist Alexei Navalny said tests confirmed he was poisoned with a toxic nerve agent.  It therefore looks like Navalny has joined a long list of Russian opposition figures who have mysteriously been poisoned and/or murdered.  In response to the announcement, German Chancellor Merkel and her foreign minister, Heiko Maas, called on Russia to conduct an open and transparent investigation into the poisoning and to prosecute the culprit.  However, the Russian government said it sees no need for a probe and accused the German doctors of rushing to judgment.

Belarus: At least two members of an opposition-led council formed to help the transfer of power to a new government following Belarus’s presidential vote were detained, raising fears that longtime authoritarian leader Alexander Lukashenko has no intention of ceding power.

Hurricane news: The National Hurricane Center has issued a hurricane watch stretching from an area in Texas near Houston to western Louisiana as the two states prepared for Tropical Storm Laura to strengthen to a hurricane before making landfall later this week.  The storm is expected to arrive Wednesday or Thursday, on the heels of Tropical Storm Marco, which brought high winds and rainfall to eastern Louisiana beginning late Monday.  Oil and gasoline futures have jumped in response, based on concerns that the storms could force temporary production shutdowns.

Indexes: S&P Dow Jones Indices announced it will launch its latest major restructuring of the Dow Jones Industrial Average starting next Monday.  The restructuring will involve eliminating ExxonMobil (XOM, 42.22), Pfizer (PFE, 38.84), and Raytheon (RTX, 61.88) from the DJIA, and replacing them with Salesforce.com (CRM, 208.46), Amgen (AMGN, 235.57), and Honeywell International (HON, 159.37).  Even though the changes won’t take place until next week, the prospect of increased buying by index-tracking funds is likely to boost the new additions today and possibly through the end of the week.

COVID-19: Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 23,679,320 worldwide, with 813,820 deaths and 15,359,999 recoveries.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 5,741,189, with 177,284 deaths and 2,020,774 recoveries.  Here is the interactive chart from the Financial Times that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population.

Virology

  • Newly confirmed U.S. infections rose slightly to 38,045 yesterday, but the figure continues to trend downward fairly steeply.  Looking forward, new cases could be held down artificially in the coming days because of testing disruptions associated with Tropical Storm Marco and Hurricane Laura along the Gulf Coast.  If those storms push many people into emergency shelters for any significant time, they could constitute as “super-spreader events” that might push up infection rates in the coming weeks.
  • Japan will relax a controversial coronavirus rule allowing Japanese citizens to enter the country subject to a COVID-19 test and quarantine but bans foreign residents who left the country after April 2.  The government fears the discriminatory stance against foreigners will undermine business competitiveness and damage Tokyo’s reputation as a financial center.
  • For the first time, researchers have documented a case of COVID-19 reinfection.  This offers evidence that patients who have recovered from the disease could be infected a second time months after the initial episode.  If confirmed, the finding would bolster the theory that immunity from being infected with the virus or being vaccinated could last only a few months, similar to coronaviruses that cause the common cold.  That would imply that when a viable vaccine is available, regular shots might be needed to maintain immunity.

Economic Impact

View PDF

Weekly Geopolitical Report – Biden’s Foreign Policy (August 24, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady | PDF

Traditionally, Labor Day is considered the point when an increasing number of Americans start paying attention to the November elections.  As part of our analysis of the candidates, we create dossiers of the candidates and the leading figures with whom they surround themselves.  In this report, we will comment on those we see as potentially taking positions in the foreign policy team of a Biden presidency.  First-term presidents tend to lean heavily on foreign policy experts, so the people selected to fill these roles would have a hand in shaping policy.

There is an old saying in politics that “personnel equals policy.”  Although not completely the case, it does matter who is in the important cabinet and advisory posts.  Because this is a geopolitical report, we will focus on foreign policy positions—Secretary of State, Secretary of Defense, Secretary of Treasury, Director of the CIA, and National Security Advisor.  We have no insider information about who will get these roles; our predictions are based on open sources and our own analysis.  But, based off these conjectures, we will attempt to determine what Biden’s foreign policy would look like.

We will begin with an overview of what we would expect in terms of foreign policy from a Biden presidency.  We will follow that discussion with a short biography of who we think are the leading candidates for the aforementioned positions and name other potential candidates for the positions.  Using this information, we will attempt to indicate what the sum of these positions would mean for the direction of Biden’s foreign policy.  As always, we will conclude with market ramifications.

Next week, we will do the same for President Trump.  Second terms are different than first terms.  First-term presidents are learning their job and tend to be dependent on the experts they appoint.  In the second term, presidents have more experience and the people they appoint to key positions are there mostly to execute the president’s policy preferences, not to offer advice.  In addition, by the second term, the party’s leading functionaries have served (and moved on) and the team that replaces them is usually second tier.  All that will be covered next week.

Read the full report

Daily Comment (August 24, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

It’s Monday and the last full week of August (that month went by fast, didn’t it?)!  There is a lot going on this morning.  We have twin tropical storms, one already in the Gulf of Mexico and the other on its way.  California is suffering through wildfires.  The GOP convention kicks off this week.  Global equities are moving higher with hopes for COVID-19 treatments.  Overseas news leads our coverage this morning; Belarus protests continue, and we are watching the fate of Aleksei Navalny.  Economics and markets are next.  The pandemic report follows.  We also update the China news.  Let’s get to it:

Foreign news:

Economics and Markets:

  • Inequality has been a growing problem for some time; the pandemic has worsened the divide. Knowledge workers have tended to manage the pandemic because they have been able to shift to working from home; customer-facing jobs and those that cannot be accomplished without access to fixed capital have suffered.  Data suggests that employment is back to pre-pandemic levels for the highest earning quartile, whereas it remains 15% below mid-January for the bottom quartile.
    • Beyond the obvious political problems this situation causes, it also affects how the economy functions. For example, we are seeing a surge in buying used goods—cars, clothing, furniture, etc.—where shoppers are willing to own something less than new to save money.  One interesting twist is that in the GDP calculation, used items don’t add to growth.
  • Money market funds are an important conduit for the non-bank financial system, the so-called “shadow banking system.” This system gets its liquidity via repo instead of deposits.  Low interest rates are a serious impediment for money market fund operators; at very low rates, they struggle to earn a profit.  Funds are temporarily waiving fees to prevent the generation of a negative yield; in other words, from breaking the buck.  The net asset value (NAV) of money market funds is traditionally set at $1.00 per share. While there is nothing to prevent it from reducing the NAV below a dollar, it would undermine the belief that money market funds are as good as cash.  Complicating matters, as we note in this week’s AAW, is that money market levels are elevated, further hampering the operators of these funds (if one is losing money on current assets, it’s hard to make up the difference with higher volume).  As rates continue to fall, there will be even greater incentive to move funds into higher-yielding assets even at higher risk.
  • Existing home sales are on a tear. Single-family sales now exceed pre-pandemic levels.  Generational adjustments (millennials are reaching their family-building age) and pandemic-driven preference for a home of one’s own are behind the lift.  The biggest constraint remains the lack of available homes.  Another factor helping home buying is that the mortgage guarantee firms have been granting forbearance during the crisis, which is preserving credit ratings.

COVID-19:  The number of reported cases is 23,456,597 with 809,349 deaths and 15,155,418 recoveries.  In the U.S., there are 5,704,597 confirmed cases with 176,809 deaths and 1,997,761 recoveries.  For illustration purposes, the FT has created an interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.  The FT has also issued an economic tracker that looks across countries with high frequency data on various factors.

Virology: 

China news:

View PDF

Daily Comment (August 21, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Happy Friday!  Equity futures are mostly marking time this morning.  We lead off with foreign news; Iran, North Korea, and Russia are the focus.  We also update news on China, followed by policy news and the latest on the pandemic.  We wrap up with market details.  Being Friday, a new Asset Allocation Weekly is available; you can find it at the end of this report, and through this link.  The companion podcast and chart book are available as well.  This week’s topic returns to an old favorite, the level of retail money market funds.  Here is what we are watching this morning:

Foreign news:

  • The U.S. officially filed a complaint with the U.N. Security Council to trigger the “snapback” provisions of the Iran nuclear deal. The primary goal of the U.S. is to extend an arms embargo that is set to expire in October.  Given that the U.S. suspended its participation, the proposal did not get a warm welcome from the other members.  Although it is certain the proposal won’t pass (both China and Russia have a permanent veto and want to sell arms to Iran), the U.S. complaint puts Europe in an uncomfortable position.  The European members of the council are siding with Russia and China against the U.S.  That isn’t their normal position.  In addition, Europe was a supporter of the deal; not supporting the snapback increases the odds it will officially fail.  What makes this situation especially difficult is that Iran is clearly violating the agreement.  Tehran would argue that the U.S. actions forced it to, but that doesn’t matter all that much.  We would look for the European members to do everything they can to delay the vote.
  • Germany is prepared to fly Alexei Navalny out of Russia after his apparent poisoning. So far, the Kremlin is blocking his departurePoisoning remains a favorite tool of the Kremlin for dealing with opponents.
  • It is always difficult to know what is going on in North Korea. It’s a closed society with a limited number of contacts with the outside world. In a rare admission of failure, Kim Jong-Un, at a party meeting, admitted that his first five-year plan, launched in 2016, has not met its goals.  He attributed the failure to COVID-19, flooding, and sanctions.  Although the government still claims there are no cases of COVID-19 in North Korea, the virus did close the border with China, choking off trade.
    • A development we continue to watch is the steady rise of Kim’s sister, Kim Yo-Jong, who is now said to be the “second in command.” This ascension appears tied to other efforts by Kim to delegate greater responsibility to other officials.  This decision may be an admission that his government was too centralized or a way to assign failure to other officials.
  • The U.S. is deploying $300 million of frozen Venezuelan assets to undermine the Maduro regime.

China news:

  • The flooding crisis shows no signs of abating. The city of Chongqing, with a population of 30 million, is making flood preparations for its biggest flood event in four decades.   As water backs up behind the Three Gorges Dam, officials are opening the floodgates.  Inflows into the electric turbines are at 75 million liters per second and the floodgates are seeing flows of 42.9 million liters per second, the most since the dam was constructed.  The maximum level of the reservoir is 175 meters; the waters are forecast to reach 165.5 meters tomorrow.  If the dam is breached, it would not only be a major embarrassment to the Xi government, but it would add to downstream flows and exacerbate flooding.  The Leshan Giant Buddha carving, a massive monument carved into the side of a river valley, is “getting his feet wet” for the first time since 1949.
  • Although the U.S. has essentially implemented a “death sentence” to Huawei (002502, CNY 2.96), Beijing has not, so far, retaliated against U.S. firms operating in China. We suspect there are two reasons.  First, China still needs U.S. knowhow and investment, and second, there is probably hope that a Biden government will relax some of the Trump administration’s policies.  We suspect the second hope is on shaky ground; Trump could be reelected, and Beijing may be underestimating the degree to which the U.S. policy establishment has turned on China.  Once China realizes the trend against it is secular, we would expect retaliation to begin in earnest.
  • The U.S. isn’t done with actions against China—this coming from an unlikely source, the Home Furnishings Association.
  • There appears to be a policy shift coming in China. We are hearing more about a “dual circulation” economic policy, which looks to turn China’s economic focus inward.  This news would confirm a couple of longstanding factors.  First, throughout China’s history, it has cycled from focusing outward to inward.  It does the former when it wants to spur growth.  The coastal areas become export hubs, leading to much better growth but widening regional income gaps.  As these gaps lead to political and social divisions, leaders turn the economic focus inward, which leads to slower growth, but greater political unity and stability.  Mao took China inward, while Deng moved outward.  Xi has been focusing on political and social unity, and thus shifting the economy to a more domestic focus, which would be consistent with this policy.  Second, China’s economic development since 1978 has been investment and export-driven.  The distortions from this policy have created a situation where the policy is no longer able to generate growth without excessive debt creation.  A shift to consumption has been a longstanding recommendation; this “dual circulation” policy might facilitate that move.  If China follows through, it would have significant effects on the global economy.

Policy news:

COVID-19:  The number of reported cases is 22,709, 116 with 794,256 deaths and 14,562,070 recoveries.  In the U.S., there are 5,576,089 confirmed cases with 174,290 deaths and 1,947,035 recoveries.  For illustration purposes, the FT has created an interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.  The FT has also issued an economic tracker that looks across countries with high frequency data on various factors.  The Rt data shows that just over 60% of the states are reporting a reading under one, suggesting a slowing infection rate.  Alabama has the lowest reading, while Hawaii has the highest.

Economics and Markets

  • This recession is hitting New York real estate harder than 9/11 and the Great Financial Crisis.
  • Although markets are powerful structures, they don’t always supply everything a society wants. When this occurs, the formal economic term for it is “market failure.”  Some market failures are simply tolerated because the costs of the failure are not enough for government to intervene.  Others are large enough to where government does overrule the market.  One classic case of this was universal phone service.  Stringing wires into rural America was a money-losing proposition, but government leaders feared that if large swaths of low population areas were denied service, it would adversely affect those regions.  Thus, a deal was struck with Ma Bell—provide universal service and the company would be allowed to be a virtual monopoly.  The company paid for the money-losing service with high charges on long-distance, which was mostly funded by businesses.  Note that no such deal was made with broadband, and this service has not been universally provided to rural and low population areas.

View PDF

Asset Allocation Weekly (August 21, 2020)

by Asset Allocation Committee | PDF

One of the relationships we monitor is retail money market levels (RMMKs).  In theory, any available liquidity could conceivably end up purchasing equities.  But, RMMKs are used by investors in their brokerage accounts and thus are probably “closer” to equities compared to other forms of “near money,” such as checking accounts, savings accounts and certificates of deposit.  The chart below shows the most current reading.

This chart shows retail money market levels on a weekly basis along with the Friday closes of the S&P 500.  The gray bars show recessions, whereas the orange bars show periods when retail money market levels fall below $920 billion.  In general, when RMMKs fall to $920 billion or below, the uptrend in equities tends to stall.  It would seem there is a certain level of desired cash, and when that level falls below $920 billion, households try to rebuild cash by either slowing their purchases of equities or selling stocks to build liquidity.

During the runup to the Financial Crisis, we saw a rise in RMMKs.  The peak in liquidity was reasonably close to the trough in the S&P 500.  In early 2018, we saw a notable rise in RMMKs that persisted despite the rally in equities.  As the pandemic hit and the Federal Reserve aggressively eased monetary policy, RMMKs soared.  The rise in RMMKs initially coincided with the sharp decline in stocks, although the pace slowed as equities recovered.  It peaked in the second half of May and has been trending lower.  When RMMKs fall, that liquidity must go to some other asset, real or financial.

Although scaling RMMK is difficult, we do note that the ratio of M2 excluding RMMK does tend to track the fed funds target with a lag.  This makes sense.  Holding “cash” outside of a period of crisis is usually driven by interest rates.  As rates fall, and hopefully the crisis eases, the current elevated level of RMMK will start to look for higher returns.

The chart suggests that RMMKs should begin to decline in earnest by December; where that liquidity finds a home is uncertain, but we would expect a good portion of it to go into equities if inflation fears remain muted.

View PDF