Weekly Geopolitical Report – On Optimization (March 23, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady

In our discussions of COVID-19, we have noted that part of the reason the virus has been so disruptive is because the world has adopted a stance that optimization is an unalloyed positive.  When I was in graduate school, I participated in a seminar with several professional private sector economists.  A question was posed about what the goal of economics should be, and the resounding response was “efficiency.”  On its face, that position makes sense; after all, who wants to be inefficient?  But the key is how efficiency is defined and measured.

There are two underlying issues that frame optimization.  The first is the broad number of variables that may be considered in optimization.  The second is that many actions designed to optimize suffer from the error of composition.  In other words, what is rational at the micro level may be irrational at the macro level.  Both of these factors are affected by globalization, thus making them appropriate for a geopolitical report.

One of the reasons COVID-19 has had such a drastic impact on the global economy is because companies and governments have optimized to a narrow set of factors and the lack of redundancies in the system has caused breakdowns in supply chains.  As we have watched this crisis unfold, we have been struck by the fact that much of the impact was tied to the drive for optimization.

In this report, we will examine the issue of optimization.  We will start by discussing the expanse of variables considered and why market participants tend to assume that slow moving variables are constant and thus they are vulnerable when they change.  An analysis of the error of composition problem will also be included.  We will conclude with market ramifications.

View the full report

Daily Comment (March 23, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EST]

It’s Monday.  Global markets remain in risk-off mode after the Senate’s first swing at the third phase of the rescue package failsBREAKING: FED GIVEN BROADER POWERS TO INTERVENE IN FINANCIAL MARKETS—MORE BELOW—S&P FUTURES RECOVER.  We update the COVID-19 virus news. Here are the details:

COVID-19:  The world now has 349,211 reported cases of COVID-19, with 15,308 fatalities and 100,165 recoveries.  Here is another link to a new site we have found on tracking the virus, along with a chart of infections from the FT:

The U.S. pace of infections is rising rapidly; this is probably more about increased testing. Sadly, there is no evidence of the bend we usually see when a country is getting on top of the spread.

The virus news:

The policy news:

The economic news:

Odds and ends:  The Marines are retooling their planning, preparing for war in the Asia-Pacific and reducing training for the Middle East.  Saudi Arabia intends to maintain the oil share war through borrowing.

View the complete PDF

Asset Allocation Weekly (March 20, 2020)

by Asset Allocation Committee

During the recent market tumult, gold has performed rather well, until lately.

(Source: Barchart.com)

This chart shows the nearest gold futures contract over the past year.  From mid-January, when reports of COVID-19 began to circulate, gold prices marched steadily higher, making an intraday high of $1,704.30.  Since then, this has declined by over $250 per ounce.  This drop is occurring despite a series of measures designed that would normally support gold prices, e.g., the return of zero fed funds, new quantitative easing, plans for massive fiscal spending, etc.

This is a chart of our gold model.  Fair value has increased to $1,529 per ounce and prices have dropped below that level.  We suspect the recent weakness is related to a rapid tightening of financial conditions.

This chart shows the Bloomberg Financial Conditions Index. A negative reading suggests higher levels of financial stress.  When financial stress rises to high levels, investors often are scrambling for cash, selling what they can and not necessarily what they should.  In other words, the investors may be selling gold to raise funds because it is a liquid asset.

Returning to the gold model chart, we highlighted the area in yellow that represents the 2008 Great Financial Crisis.  In the worst of that situation, gold also underperformed fair value.  However, once the liquidating stopped, gold began a multi-year bull market.  Although we are not necessarily expecting a similar move in prices, we do expect the aggressive expansion of liquidity via fiscal and monetary policy to create favorable conditions for gold in the coming years.

View the PDF

Daily Comment (March 20, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EST]

Good morning and happy Friday!  “There are decades where nothing happens, and there are weeks where decades happen.”  This quote, misappropriated to Lenin, seems to capture much of how things feel right now.  It’s a “green screen day” with equity futures rebounding around the world and the dollar finally taking a pause from its recent strength.  We update COVID-19 news, including comments about global stimulus activities.  Here are the details:

COVID-19:  The world now has 246,275 reported cases of COVID-19, with 10,038 fatalities and 86,035 recoveries.  Here is a chart of infections from the FT:

The U.S. pace of infections is rising rapidly; this is probably more about increased testing.  Sadly, there is no evidence of the bend we usually see when a country is getting on top of the spread.

The virus news:

The policy news:

  • We have seen nations attempt to control the news flow about the virus. China is notable in this area.  The U.S. is engaging in some of this as well.  The White House is asking states to stop issuing early information on initial jobless claims.  We are watching this news with great interest.  As we have been working through the data, we are seeing other economists suggesting historic declines in Q2 GDP of over 10% and perhaps a 2.0 million jump in jobless claims.  If the government decides to stop the release of the data, we will all be “flying blind.”  In addition, it won’t work; organization theory suggests that if you stop the flow of real information, people simply make up their own.  Not only will it probably not be accurate, it will likely be worse.
  • The Senate leadership is putting together a fiscal package of at least $1.0 trillion. Already, there is speculation this level will fall short.  And, the chance of getting something done quickly is starting to fade.  As one would expect, there is already squabbling over the details.  The White House has suggested that companies that take aid must give the government equity.  There is strong opposition to that idea, suggesting conditions haven’t gotten bad enough yet.
  • One of the tensions in the Senate bill is where the benefits fall. The establishment (both left and right) tend to favor support for businesses first, on the idea that if businesses fail, the job losses will be even worse.  Populists counter that businesses have squandered support after 2008 and recent tax cuts by merely repurchasing stock to aid the capital-owning establishment.  As we noted yesterday, we would use the same tactic we employ when confronting a dessert table—try everything!  However, we do note a set of reports that will give the establishment a black eye: a couple of senators, briefed on COVID-19 in February, dumped their equity holdings.  These reports will tend to undermine the establishment’s case; look for aid to be tied to equity.
  • Meanwhile, Germany and the U.K. have set up fiscal expansions.
  • The central banks continue to expand their activities. The BOE has cut rates to record lows and is increasing QE.  The Fed is moving aggressively as well, buying $250 billion of the $500 billion of new QE this week.  This almost certainly looks like more will be coming.  The ECB has also indicated it will consider boosting its balance sheet
  • Oil prices rallied on a few reports. First, President Trump suggested he may intervene in the conflict between Russia and the KSA.  There is some precedent for this action.  VP Bush reportedly did the same during the 1986 oil price collapse.  However, we note his intervention came after oil prices neared $10 per barrel and the parties were already in talks to end the overproduction war.  Second, as already announced, the U.S. will increase buying for the Strategic Petroleum Reserve.  Third, Texas is apparently considering dusting off its old production allocation mechanism used from the 1930s into 1970 which regulated the amount of oil that the state would produce.  Meanwhile, U.S. production remains at record levels.  As we noted in this week’s Weekly Energy Update, due to hedging, production will likely remain near record levels for the rest of the year without intervention.  What is unclear—if the Texas Railroad Commission restricts output, how will that affect debt servicing by oil companies?
  • The PBOC surprised us by not cutting rates overnight. China’s stimulus thus far has been modest.

The economic news:

Expect continued market swings.  Policymakers are moving in the right direction but the economic impact of battling the virus has been significant.  Enjoy the weekend.  We will talk to you on Monday.

View the complete PDF

Daily Comment (March 19, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EST]

Today is the spring equinox; it’s hard to say if this is a good or bad omen.  We update COVID-19 news.  Although there is much to say about the financial markets, to some extent, it can be summed up succinctly—there is a dash for cashEquities are falling again this morning.  Congress is working on a $1.0 trillion stimulus bill.  Don’t be surprised in a few weeks when we will marvel at how timid this action was.  We are paying close attention to today’s initial claims data as it is expected to show a massive increase in layoffs.  The weekly energy report is updated on our website.  Here are the details:

COVID-19: The world now has 222,643 reported cases of COVID-19 with 9,115 fatalities and 84,506 recoveries.  Here is a chart of infections from the FT:

The U.S. pace of infections is rising rapidly; this is probably more about increased testing.

The virus news:

And now, financial market news related to COVID-19:

Odds and ends: The journalism spat between the U.S. and China continues, with Beijing expelling some U.S. reporters.  The trade war continues as the U.S. increases tariffs on European aircraft.

View the complete PDF

Weekly Energy Update (March 19, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

Crude oil inventories rose 2.0 mb compared to the forecast rise of 3.5 mb.

In the details, U.S. crude oil production rose 0.1 mbpd to 13.1 mbpd.  Exports rose 1.0 mbpd, while imports rose 0.1 mbpd.  The inventory build was less than forecast due to the rise in exports.

(Sources: DOE, CIM)

The above chart shows the annual seasonal pattern for crude oil inventories.  This week’s report put inventory accumulation modestly above seasonal norms.  Inventories will be expected to rise steady into late May.  We will be watching this chart closely in the coming weeks for signs that inventories are rising abnormally due to the market share war described below.

Based on our oil inventory/price model, fair value is $55.77; using the euro/price model, fair value is $53.14.  The combined model, a broader analysis of the oil price, generates a fair value of $53.26.  As we noted last week, the model output is less relevant unless Russia and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) come to an agreement on supply.

Needless to say, our forecast for oil prices was reasonably accurate in terms of level but far too conservative in terms of time.  WTI has declined under $21 per barrel since our last report.  The combination of increased KSA supply and rising Russian output, combined with falling demand, is putting significant negative pressure on prices.  U.S. oil producers in the shale patch are already signaling layoffs.  The U.S. industry is more competitive and better hedged than in 2015; although bankruptcies are unavoidable, production will likely remain elevated for some time regardless of how low prices fall.

This chart shows WTI oil prices with U.S. crude oil production.[1]  We have highlighted the area from the peak in oil prices in 2014 to the peak in production in 2015.  The lag between these two periods was 10 months.  Thus, we would not expect any significant declines in U.S. output until late Q4 at the earliest.  If Russia and the KSA continue to fight for market share, oil prices will remain under further pressure for the foreseeable future.

View the PDF


[1] The official DOE data has a two- to three-month lag.  The production data reported in the weekly data is an estimate from the DOE.

Daily Comment (March 18, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EST]

Well, it’s Wednesday, and we face another day right out of a post-apocalyptic zombie movie.  While there is still no sign of zombie armies marching on Washington, there is a more worrying sign that global financial markets are seizing up in a desperate scramble for liquidity.  Policymakers around the world are pledging in unison to do “whatever it takes” to rescue the global economy, which is a good thing, but markets will remain volatile until real results are visible.  Below we review all the key news from the crisis and beyond.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 203,529 worldwide, with 8,205 deaths and 82,107 recoveries.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 6,496, with 114 deaths and 17 recoveries.  Most disconcerting, the slowdown in the real economy is exposing or exacerbating financial weaknesses.  There are increasing worries about businesses and individuals not only having trouble paying their everyday bills, but also covering the high levels of debt they took on during the boom of the last decade.

United States:  In yesterday’s Democratic Party primary elections, former Vice President Biden won all three key races.  With his wins in Florida, Illinois and Arizona, it appears he would only have to win 42.8% of the remaining delegates to the party’s summer convention in order to win outright in the first ballot.  The wins heap even more pressure on Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders to drop out of the race.

Argentina:  President Alberto Fernández has proposed a further hike in the country’s soybean export tax to 33%, just months after he increased the tax to 30% from the previous 25%.  However, the powerful farmers’ lobby is now starting to push back by launching protests.  Along with the global coronavirus panic, the tension is negative for Argentine stocks and bonds.

View the complete PDF

Daily Comment (March 17, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EST]

Happy St. Patrick’s Day!  To celebrate the holiday, we think it would be great if the markets could end the day “in the green.”  However, much will depend on news flow related to the COVID-19 “black swan.”  With so many fast-moving developments, equities could easily turn back into the red.  On that colorful note, we review the latest news on the epidemic and a few odds and ends related to the oil market, Russia and Israel.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 185,067 worldwide, with 7,330 deaths and 80,236 recoveries.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 4,661, with 85 deaths and 17 recoveries.

Oil market:  The International Energy Agency has warned that the Saudi-Russian price war and the COVID-19 epidemic will cut the revenues of “vulnerable” producing countries like Iraq and Nigeria by up to 85%.  The warning highlights how the combined crises could spark significant fiscal stress for many less developed countries.

Russia:  The highest Russian court approved President Putin’s constitutional changes, which were passed by parliament last week.  The court’s approval removes one of the final barriers to Putin potentially staying in power until 2036.

Israel:  President Rivlin has given former military chief Gantz the first crack at forming a government after this month’s inconclusive election.  However, Prime Minister Netanyahu is appealing to legislators in Gantz’s coalition to join with him to form a broad coalition in which Gantz and Netanyahu share power.

View the complete PDF

Weekly Geopolitical Report – Renewed Fighting in Idlib (March 16, 2020)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

When financial markets get caught up in a crisis like the ongoing coronavirus panic, one underappreciated risk for investors is that they can get too distracted to notice other, longer-term problems that might be brewing.  That’s why we take such a disciplined approach to monitoring geopolitical, economic, social and market events all around the world.  While we continue working hard to understand the coronavirus epidemic and anticipate its trajectory, we’re also paying close attention to the latest flare up in the Syrian civil war.

In this week’s report, we discuss the Syrian government’s effort to finish off the last remaining rebels in the northwest part of the country, and we show why Turkey recently launched a counteroffensive against that effort.  We explain what the various players in the drama are hoping to achieve and how their actions could draw in outside forces like Russia and the U.S.  Importantly, we also discuss how the situation could produce another destabilizing migrant crisis for the Europeans.  As always, we conclude with investment implications.

View the full report