Daily Comment (January 18, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EST] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with an upward revision in the International Energy Agency’s forecast for global oil demand this year, which is giving a boost to oil prices so far this morning.  We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including an unexpected decision by the Bank of Japan that has given a boost to Japanese stocks but has driven down the JPY.

Global Oil Market:  In its monthly forecast, the IEA stated that the end of China’s strict pandemic shutdowns should lead to a further rise in oil demand this year, even though the COVID-19 infections sweeping through China right now are causing widespread economic disruptions at the moment.  With U.S. and European oil usage also looking firmer this year, the agency therefore predicted total global oil demand in 2023 will rise to a record-high average of 101.7 million barrels per day, up 1.9 mbpd from 2022.

  • The news is helping to give global oil prices a further boost so far this morning.
  • Brent crude oil futures are currently up approximately 1.6% to $87.30 per barrel.

China:  In another sign that China is easing up on its economic restrictions and trying to ease tensions with the West, the country’s censors have reportedly cleared two Marvel superhero movies from The Walt Disney Company (DIS, $99.91).  That marks the first Chinese clearances for Marvel movies since 2019, and the films will be allowed to be shown in China next month.

Japan:  The BOJ today kept its monetary policy unchanged, with a yield target of -0.1% for short-term obligations and a cap of 0.5% for 10-year notes.  The decision to hold steady came after a surprise tightening last month.  That disappointed many investors who had bet on a further hike in the 10-year yield and a potential end to the BOJ’s long experiment with yield- curve control.  In response, Japanese bond yields have declined sharply so far today, pushing down the JPY and boosting Japanese equity markets.

European Union:  In her address at Davos yesterday, European Commission President von der Leyen said that the EU will respond to the recent U.S. subsidies for green technologies by easing its restrictions on state aid to industry and pumping cash into strategic climate-friendly businesses.  However, her proposed program would still need a unanimous buy-in across all EU countries, and some national leaders believe a better way to keep investment in the EU is to boost the bloc’s productivity, increase research spending, and bring down energy prices.

  • EU leaders believe the $369 billion in green subsidies under the Inflation Reduction Act will likely draw massive amounts of investment out of Europe and toward the U.S., and they worry that EU countries don’t have the fiscal space to compete with the U.S.
  • However, the Biden administration continues to argue that the EU should adopt similar “complementary” subsidies that would strengthen the EU as a member of the evolving U.S. geopolitical bloc and reduce the EU’s dependence on China and the countries in its bloc.

United Kingdom:  The December Consumer Price Index (CPI) was up 10.5% year-over-year, marking a modest cooling in inflation after the index rose 10.7% for the year to November.  However, excluding the volatile food and energy components, the December Core CPI was still up 6.3%, unchanged from the inflation rate in November.

  • Overall British inflation has now slowed for two straight months, but only modestly, and the wave of strikes now sweeping across the country threaten to buoy wage costs and inflation for months to come.
  • The Bank of England is, therefore, still expected to keep hiking interest rates at its next policy meeting in February.

Russia:  Defense Minister Shoigu outlined a long-term expansion of the country’s military in which total personnel would rise to 1.50 million in 2026 from the current 1.15 million.  The plan would also include the creation of new military districts centered on Moscow and St. Petersburg and the establishment of an army corps in the exclave of Karelia.

  • The expansion of the country’s military will coincide with a likely pullback in economic activity because of factors such as Western sanctions and mass emigration.
  • As a result, Russia is likely edging closer to the day when its defense spending exceeds 10% of gross domestic product – a “defense burden” that has historically created headwinds for economic growth.

Turkey:  President Erdoğan announced that the country’s next presidential and parliamentary elections would be pulled forward by one month to May 14.  Erdoğan’s support in public opinion polls is currently at rock bottom because of soaring inflation, high unemployment, and a currency crisis.  However, he appears to be gambling that a recent spate of public spending programs and his aggressive foreign policy will help him eke out a win and stay in power.

U.S. Labor Market:  As early as today, Microsoft (MSFT, $240.35) is expected to announce another round of layoffs, making it one more in a string of high-profile information technology firms that are shedding workers.  Besides technology, it also appears that rising interest rates and the implosion of the housing market have prompted significant layoffs in the real estate and financial services industries.

  • Nevertheless, with the economy facing an overall shortage of workers, many of those being laid off appear to be finding other jobs quickly. That’s evident in the weekly data on initial jobless claims, which haven’t increased appreciably despite the technology and real estate layoffs.
  • Indeed, one benefit to the layoffs is that the released workers become available to other industries that are growing but have had trouble finding workers, such as defense.

U.S. Bank Regulation:  Acting Comptroller of the Currency Michael Hsu warned that a bank is probably too big to manage effectively and should be broken up if it repeatedly fails to resolve longstanding deficiencies despite reprimands from its regulators and onerous restrictions such as caps on its growth.  The statement highlights the increased regulatory and antitrust risk facing many industries under the Biden administration.

U.S. Investment Strategy:  An interesting article in the Wall Street Journal describes how financial firms are currently in intense disagreement over the future of the “60/40” portfolio, in which 60% of assets are allocated to stocks and 40% to bonds.  Although the 60/40 portfolio largely failed to protect its investors from big negative returns in 2022, its adherents maintain that it was a rare, one-off occurrence.  Others believe a fundamental change may be in order, a viewpoint which we share, given the likelihood of a secular bear market in bonds and unusually good prospects for gold and other commodities.  For example, a decent standard asset allocation going forward may allocate almost half the previous bond allocation of 40% to gold and commodities.

View PDF

Asset Allocation Bi-Weekly – The Master of Surprise (January 17, 2023)

by the Asset Allocation Committee | PDF

[Note: The podcast that accompanies this report will be delayed until Friday, January 20.]

They don’t call Haruhiko Kuroda the “Master of Surprise” for nothing. The Bank of Japan (BOJ) Governor lifted the yield cap on 10-year Japanese government bonds (JGB) by 25 bps last month. The bank will now allow the 10-year yield to fluctuate between -0.50% and +0.50% before intervening in the market. The move jolted markets as it paved the way for possible future monetary tightening. Because Japan is the world’s largest creditor, an increase in Japanese yields could attract capital from abroad back to the mainland. As a result, the policy change could lead to an overall increase in borrowing costs for other countries, including the U.S., and could also affect exchange rates.

The JPY surged as much as 5% against the dollar on the day following the BOJ’s surprising decision. This was the JPY’s largest gain since the New York Fed and BOJ joined forces to prop up the currency in 1998. The rise in the currency reflects investor sentiment that the BOJ is getting ready to tighten its monetary policy. The central bank has intervened in bond markets to keep its bond-yield rates around 0%. Attempts by speculators to push the BOJ to adjust its policy prematurely have typically ended in tears as the bank defended its caps aggressively and burnished the short JGB trade as “the widow-maker in the process.

Although the BOJ maintains that the move was not designed to alter future monetary policy, it is difficult to discern another motive. The latest meeting summary showed that BOJ officials raised their cap to address issues within their bond market. Days before the decision, a BOJ survey revealed that investors’ perceptions of bond market functionality fell to a record low. Additionally, the 10-year JGB failed to trade for four straight days at one point between the October and December meetings, signaling a decline in liquidity. However, the lack of telegraphing, especially given the bank’s sizable bond holding, suggests that the decision may have been more nuanced.

BOJ Governor Kuroda’s term ends on April 8. The two front-runners to succeed him are former BOJ Deputy Governor Hiroshi Nakaso and current Deputy Governor Masayoshi Amamiya. The latter is seen as more of a dove, but both are expected to tighten policy. By raising the yield cap, Kuroda gave his successor more wiggle room to navigate a way forward without rattling markets. The policy adjustment allows the future head of the BOJ to chart their own path forward without the cloud of their predecessor.

The biggest obstacle preventing further tightening is the country’s substantial debt burden. Japan has the largest government debt-to-GDP ratio among advanced economies at 206%. It has been able to manage this burden through its yield-curve control. Japan’s effective interest was 0.6% in 2021, much lower than many of its peers. In contrast, the effective interest rate on Italian debt was 2.3% in 2021, while the U.S. paid 1.6% during that period. Given the size of the debt, a small increase in interest rates could still lead to a sizable jump in debt payments. Although manageable in the long term, a 100-bps rise in interest rates would add 3% to the government debt-to-GDP ratio by 2025, according to Fitch Ratings Agency.

Higher interest rates in Japan could also lift borrowing costs for other countries. An increase in the yield on Japanese sovereigns incentivizes Japanese investors to bring capital home, leading to higher interest rates for the rest of the world. The U.S. is particularly vulnerable. Higher yields on JGB will attract interest from Japanese investors, who are the largest holders of U.S. Treasuries outside of America itself. As a result, the increase in Japanese interest rates could also lead to an increase in U.S. rates.

Although the markets anticipate that the BOJ will tighten policy more in 2023, they are not completely certain. We suspect that Japan’s decision to raise its yield cap by 25 bps had more to do with giving Kuroda’s successor more flexibility to conduct policy. That said, it appears that either candidate expected to take over, Hiroshi Nakaso or Masayoshi Amamiya, is likely to tighten. If correct, this should help boost financial sector equities internationally as it makes it easier for banks to profit from lending.

View PDF

Daily Comment (January 17, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EST] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with a slew of reports related to China and its recent shift toward supporting domestic economic growth and easing tensions with the West.  We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including similarly important shifts in the economic policies of Japan and Europe.

Chinese Real Estate Industry:  In the latest sign that Beijing has reversed its previous clamp down on the residential real estate industry, the government has reportedly drafted a 21-point action plan to aid embattled developers with 450 billion CPY ($67 billion) in financing.  The plan would also include “reasonable debt extensions” for “high-quality developers.”  The government hasn’t indicated which firms are eligible, but it appears the support will focus on large, nationally active, systemically important firms.

  • The new support programs for real estate developers suggest that China’s traditional growth-oriented, pro-Western policymakers have firmly taken control of the government apparatus. Other recent signs pointing in that direction include the dramatic relaxation of COVID-19 restrictions and conciliatory moves toward the West.
  • The reversal from the formerly hardline, ideological policies will likely lead to a temporary easing of U.S.-China tensions, a surge in optimism regarding China, and possibly a rebound in Chinese equity markets. The policy easing could also help rekindle Chinese economic growth, which came in at a very weak 3.0% in 2022, according to official statistics released today.  We still believe U.S.-China relations will worsen over time, but the current reversal in Beijing’s policies could produce a short-term, investible pop in the value of Chinese risk assets.

Chinese Information Technology Industry:  Despite the step-back from tough restrictions on the real estate industry and acerbic diplomacy against the West, other reporting indicates that the government has expanded its longstanding practice of taking 1% equity positions in key private firms as a way to exercise ongoing influence over them.  These “special management shares” or “golden shares” typically come with a seat on the private firm’s board of directors and the right to control certain company decisions.  This allows the government to wield power over it outside the regulatory regime.

  • A unit of the Cyberspace Administration of China has reportedly taken golden shares in a digital media unit of Alibaba (BABA, $117.01), along with a seat on its board, and it is reportedly preparing to take similar golden shares in Tencent (TCEHY, $47.79). Other Chinese tech firms that already have such golden shares include Weibo (WB, $20.69) and TikTok owner Bytedance (unlisted).
  • China’s shift from heavy-handed regulations and fines against its technology industry may look positive at first glance, but the increasing use of golden shares suggests that the step back from regulation is only a tactical adjustment. What we are probably seeing is that Beijing wants to take a kinder, gentler approach to its key real estate and technology industries, but without really losing control over them.  Except for those who feel comfortable investing alongside the Chinese Communist Party, investors are likely to see that as a negative for these companies in the long run.

Chinese Population Growth:  Today, the National Statistics Bureau said that the country’s population fell by 850,000 in 2022, marking its first decline in decades.  That left China’s official population last year at 1.412 billion people.

  • Like many countries around the world, China’s extremely low birth rate is expected to lead to further headcount declines and worsening population aging in the future. Among the key implications, that means China’s workforce and available military manpower will also continue to decline.
  • Some countries are in relatively better shape, including India. In fact, India is expected to overtake China as the world’s most populous country later this year.

U.S.-China Geopolitical Competition:  Swedish state-owned mining company LKAB announced that it has discovered a deposit of more than 1 million tons of rare earth oxides in the country’s far north.  If confirmed, it would be the largest such deposit in Europe.

  • Rare earth minerals are essential to advanced technology products, and China and its evolving geopolitical bloc currently account for the big majority of the world’s proved reserves, production, and refining capacity.
  • When the Swedish deposit is eventually mined in a decade or so, it could help reduce the evolving U.S. bloc’s current dependence on China.

Global Automobile Market:  Data providers LMC Automotive and EV-Volumes.com reported that global sales of fully electric vehicles surged to 7.8 million units last year, giving them at least a 10% market share for the first time.  Fully electric vehicles made up 19% of all car sales in China, 11% in Europe, and less than 6% in the U.S.  The rapid growth in the market underlies the rising demand for lithium, cobalt, and other exotic minerals that are especially important in the batteries of electric vehicles.

Japan:  The Bank of Japan has begun its latest policy meeting, prompting concern that it could decide on a further loosening of its yield-curve control policy, as it did in December when it decided to let the yield on 10-year Japanese government bonds rise to 0.50%.  So far this morning, 10-year JGB yields have moved slightly above that limit, pushing the JPY higher.

European Union:  In another sign that the EU is taking up the mantle of industrial policy and the subsidization of its key industries, Competition Chief Vestager has sent a letter to EU finance ministers asking them to consider a new “temporary crisis and transition framework,” which would simplify state aid rules for green projects and renewable energy technologies.  The new framework would be designed to compete with the $369 billion in new U.S. subsidies for green energy technology included in the Biden administration’s recent Inflation Reduction Act.  European Council President Charles Michel has echoed the call for new EU industry support.

United Kingdom:  The British train conductors’ union has voted to hold two more days of strikes early next month, prolonging the long wave of work stoppages among transportation and public services workers.  Besides being disruptive to the economy, the wave of strikes continues to weaken the political position of Prime Minister Sunak and his Conservative Party.

World Economic Forum in Davos:  The WEF is kicking off its winter conference today in Davos, Switzerland.  After two years in which the in-person forum was canceled because of COVID-19, the event will be attended by hundreds of top political and business leaders from around the world.  The forum typically produces a lot of interesting political, economic, and business news and commentary.

Russia-Ukraine War:  Late last week, the Russian government stated that President Putin has named Gen. Valery Gerasimov as commander of the Russian forces in Ukraine, demoting the previous commander, Gen. Sergei Surovikin to the position of deputy commander.  Since Gerasimov was probably heavily involved in overseeing the invasion, the decision is likely to have little appreciable effect on the war.  In large part, naming Gerasimov as commander is likely meant to signal that the Kremlin has the war well in hand, despite financier Yevgeny Prigozhin’s effort to claim credit for the recent capture of Soledar, via his Wagner Group mercenaries.  Prigozhin continues to disparage the Ministry of Defense and, by implication, Putin himself, likely in an effort to build political support for a potential future challenge to Putin.

  • Separately, the British government late last week confirmed that it will provide Challenger 2 battle tanks to Ukraine, marking one of the first commitments to send heavy armor to the Ukrainians.
  • The announcement is important because it is likely to encourage other NATO allies to provide main battle tanks to the Ukrainians, potentially providing a significant boost to the country’s ability to push out the invading Russians.

Peru:  Protests against President Dina Boluarte and the ouster of former President Castillo continue to spread around the country.  Indeed, the protests are intensifying and becoming more violent, prompting the government to declare a state of emergency in the capital Lima and several other regions.

U.S. Fiscal Policy:  On Sunday, newly elected Speaker of the House McCarthy said he would negotiate with President Biden over raising the federal debt ceiling of roughly $31 trillion, which the government is expected to hit this week, but he insisted that the talks include spending cuts.  With Democrats insisting that federal programs continue to be funded at least at current levels, the statement illustrates the risk of an impasse, potentially leading to a partial government shutdown or even a debt default, as the government runs out of work-around measures later this year.

U.S. Winter Storms:  California was hit by yet another big round of rain and snow storms on Monday, and a smaller set of storms in the middle of this week is now expected to mark the end of a period of intense precipitation.  Although the storms have caused widespread death and destruction, they have also helped alleviate the state’s recent intense drought.  That could potentially be a boon for California’s important agriculture sector, help bring down produce prices, and modestly reduce inflation pressures.

View PDF

Daily Comment (January 13, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EST] | PDF

Good morning! Today’s Comment begins with a discussion on whether the Fed is close to ending its rate-hiking cycle. Next, we explain why changes to Japan’s controversial yield-curve-control policy pose a risk to the international financial system. The report ends with our thoughts on the state of the global economy.

 Is the Fed Finished? Investors and policymakers are growing confident that inflation is on the right path; however, the two groups disagree about when tightening will end.

  • The latest CPI data showed that inflation is continuing to decelerate. Consumer prices rose 6.5% from the prior year, the slowest increase since October 2021. The easing of price pressures has added to the speculation that the Fed will reduce the size of its rate hike to 25 bps at its next meeting in February, with some investors pricing in a pause for March. That said, Fed officials insist that the central bank is not finished. St. Louis Fed President James Bullard insists that the Fed quickly raise rates above 5%, while Richmond Fed President Thomas Barkin urged the central bank to be deliberate in its next rate increases.
  • The market responses to the data were relatively mixed. U.S. Equities whipsawed but ultimately closed higher. Meanwhile, the U.S. dollar index dipped, and the ten- and 2-year bond-yield spread narrowed. The overall mood of investors appeared to be bullish for stocks as traders now believe that the Fed is nearing the end of its tightening cycle. After the report, swaps signaled less than 50 bps of tightening over the next two FOMC meetings, a sign that investors believe the next hike could be the last one.
  • It is unlikely that the Federal Reserve will pause rate hikes before lifting its policy rate above 5%. If 2022 serves as a guide, the Fed will lift rates whether markets like it or not. Recent comments from Fed Chair Jerome Powell reinforce this belief. On Tuesday, he warned that the central bank is prepared to raise rates despite political pressures to stop. We suspect that the Fed views the tight labor market as evidence that it can raise rates even during a recession. Thus, market bets of an imminent pause may be short-sighted while inflation remains well above the Fed’s 2% target.

JGB Headaches: The Bank of Japan continues to deal with the fallout after it widened the target range for yields on 10-year bonds.

  • The announcement that the BOJ will review the side effects of its ultra-loose monetary policy has led to speculation that it could end yield-curve control (YCC). On Friday, the central bank vowed to intervene in markets after traders pushed the yield on the 10-year JGB above the 0.50% target. The jolt in yields was related to a Citigroup report which predicted that the bank could abandon YCC as soon as next week. The added pressure for the BOJ to pivot away from its ultra-loose accommodative policy has boosted the JPY. The currency has now surged more than 3% against the dollar since January 11.
  • Although the BOJ has consistently maintained that its decision to widen the target range on 10-year bonds was to improve market functionality, traders have interpreted the move as a sign that it was preparing to tighten policy to address rising inflation. As a result, the bank may be forced to delay ending YCC until markets are calmer.
  • The market rout in Japan poses a risk to the global financial system. The country’s low-interest rates and cheap currency have made it attractive for investors to generate arbitrage profits, known as the yen carry trade. In this situation, investors borrow in one currency and invest the money into high-yielding assets in another currency. As a result of the JPY’s relative weakness against the dollar, it was used as the go-to funding source for cross-border lending, and, therefore, a sharp appreciation in the currency will make it more expensive for borrowers to make debt payments.

  • The fight against inflation has made the market very sensitive to changes in monetary policy. Hence, central banks and governments must be mindful of major policy changes as they could create a financial crisis. The international financial system narrowly avoided a blowup last year following the release of former U.K. Prime Minister Liz Truss’s disastrous mini-budget.
    • As previous reports mentioned, we suspect a U.S. recession is imminent but will likely be of the garden variety. However, a financial crisis, housing market crash, or major geopolitical event could cause a severe downturn.

Recession Receding: There is growing optimism that the global economy is positioned to bounce back from its slowdown.

  • The IMF believes that the global economy may have averted a recession but has warned that the situation is still fragile. Warmer-than-expected weather helped cushion Europe from the worst of the effects from the war in Ukraine. The better temperatures have meant that EU countries have not needed to use much of their energy inventory through the winter thus far. As a result, Europe has been able to avoid a possible energy crisis. The U.K. also appears to be on better footing. The latest GDP figure showed that the economy grew in November, suggesting that the U.K. avoided a recession toward the end of 2022.
  • China still poses a risk to the global economy. The latest trade figures from the country showed that exports fell 9.9% in dollar terms from the previous year, while imports fell 7.5% in the same period. The sharp drop in foreign and domestic sales reflects the devastating impact that Zero-COVID has had on demand and production within the country. Although there is much optimism that the country’s reopening will help lift world GDP growth, the chaotic transition away from these restrictions threatens to undermine the confidence of the Chinese consumer, which could crimp future spending.
    • Chinese Lunar New Year should provide insight into the psychological impact that the transition has had on consumers. A jump in spending will be a positive sign for the global economy.
  • Despite the upbeat outlook on the global economy, it is important to remember that many countries will likely face economic contractions this year. The length and severity of the downturns depend on the cause of the contraction. A major unknown is whether central banks will tighten during this period. Policymakers from the European Central Bank, Federal Reserve, and the Bank of England have held steadfast to the idea that increasing rates in a downturn is not out of the question. However, markets have doubts as to whether these officials are serious. As a result, investors should still be vigilant of sudden market changes.

View PDF

Daily Comment (January 12, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EST] | PDF

Good morning! Today’s Comment begins with our thoughts on the latest Consumer Price Index report and its implications for Fed policy. Next, we discuss the impact that China’s reopening is having on markets. The report concludes with our thoughts on Germany’s response to the U.S. climate-change subsidy initiative.

Inflation Nation: The CPI report will bolster expectations that the Fed will moderate monetary policy this year.

  • The December inflation report has bolstered expectations that the Fed will reduce the size of its rate hike at its next meeting. Last month, headline CPI rose 6.5% from the prior year. The increase was in line with expectations and below the previous month’s report of 7.1%. The cooling of inflation will give the Fed some flexibility if it decides to slow the pace of interest rate hikes. On Wednesday, Boston Fed President Susan Collins, a voting member, mentioned that she favored a 25 bps hike in February. Meanwhile, Fed Chair Jerome Powell’s lack of clarity on rate policy reinforced investor sentiment that he may favor a downshift in rate rises.
  • Although the Fed is considering moderation in its policy, other central banks are hesitant to follow suit. European central bank official Olli Rehn insisted that the ECB needs to raise rates significantly in its next meeting to contain inflation. His French counterpart Francois Villeroy also mentioned the importance of raising rates into restrictive territory. In Japan, a review of the central bank’s ultra-easy monetary policy has led to speculation that the Bank of Japan could make another adjustment to its yield-curve-control ban. The reluctance to moderate policy in Europe is related to inflation being well above U.S. levels; meanwhile, rising inflation in Japan may force the bank to tighten.
    • The combination of BOJ tightening speculation and Fed moderation has led to a strong uptick in the JPY.
  • A moderation in the Fed’s monetary tightening will allow other central banks in the developed world to close the interest gap with the U.S. The rise in rates in Europe and possibly Japan will put downward pressure on the greenback. If true, international equities could provide attractive opportunities. Additionally, a consistent deceleration in inflation suggests that the Fed may be able to pull off the elusive soft landing.

China’s Back: There is much anticipation regarding the reopening of the Chinese economy, but the lack of COVID data may be a problem for markets.

  • Commodity prices are surging due to expectations that the end of China’s Zero-COVID restrictions will boost global demand for materials. On Wednesday, copper prices soared to $9000 a ton, its highest level since June 2022. The rampant rise in the metal is due to hopes that the increase in economic activity in China will boost global growth. Oil prices had a similar bounce as the price of crude jumped 3% on Wednesday, despite a strong build-up in U.S. inventories. It is now expected that Brent could hit $110 a barrel by the third quarter when China and other Asian economies fully reopen.
    • The optimism has boosted Chinese equities. Year-over-year performance of the MSCI China Price Index has now surpassed the S&P 500.

  • Despite the improvement in market sentiment, the lack of infection data from China is troubling. Beijing has not updated its daily COVID reports for three days. Although the reduction of tests rendered the data mostly meaningless, the lack of transparency is feeding concerns that the spread of the virus may be worse than the government originally anticipated. One hospital in China reported that half of its 2000 workers were infected with the virus. Meanwhile, local officials in Henan, the country’s third most populous province, revealed that over 90% of the region had been infected. The mystery behind the scale of the spread has led neighboring countries to push for more testing for tourists leaving China.
  • A severe outbreak is potentially detrimental to the global economy. A major unknown is how the recent rise in infections could impact consumer psychology. Although it is tempting to believe that things will return to normal after the recent wave, there is also the possibility that people will be much more cautious, particularly when it comes to services. Hence, the recovery may not be as robust as the current market pricing suggests. Spending during the Lunar New Year will likely provide insight as it is one of the year’s biggest shopping periods for China. A sharp increase in sales should boost optimism about China’s recovery.

Berlin Shrugs: Germany may be more open to allowing the U.S. to implement its climate-change subsidies than its comments suggest.

  • The European Union is moving to compete against the U.S. in the green energy race. German Chancellor Olaf Scholz is pushing for the EU to create financial instruments to make it easier for countries to provide incentives for green investment. Although Scholz did not explicitly call for EU bonds, he did advocate for joint financing instruments to help budget-strapped countries. The call was in response to the U.S. act that gives tax credits to consumers who buy electric cars made in North America. If the EU were to follow through on the initiative, it could pave the way for stimulus throughout the bloc.
  • The possibility of a joint EU venture reinforced investor optimism that a recession within the region will not be as severe as originally thought. The gap between Italian and German 10-year bonds, a gauge of European financial stress, has shrunk by 53 bps to start the year. Meanwhile, the EUR has surged to parity with the CHF and has been able to hold its value against the USD. The improved outlook has encouraged investors to pour in half a trillion dollars to purchase European bonds, suggesting strong demand for more European assets. However, despite Scholz’s tough talk, we are not confident that he is serious about a push for EU-wide investment.
  • Although Scholz’s proposal suggests that he supports a pro-European stimulus package, it isn’t clear if it is a genuine plan. In theory, Germany could implement a similar policy unilaterally without EU consent as it did with its controversial energy subsidy. Its unwillingness to do so suggests that it is ambivalent toward the U.S. incentive program. If true, this may disappoint the Biden administration as we suspect it wants the EU to implement a stimulus program supporting European firms. In our view, Washington believes that with increased state action, the EU could become less dependent on China.
    • That said, if Scholz follows through on the proposal, the EU will likely create a plan that favors lending and subsidizing firms. This scenario would benefit European equities; however, such a plan could take months or maybe years to implement.

View PDF

Weekly Energy Update (January 12, 2023)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA | PDF

Crude oil prices continue to come under pressure on worries over economic growth, although there is some evidence that prices may be basing between $72 and $82 per barrel.

(Source: Barchart.com)

Crude oil inventories jumped 19.0 mb compared to a 3.0 mb draw forecast.  The SPR delined 0.8 mb, meaning the net build was 18.2 mb.  The unusually large build was caused by a large drop in exports, a rise in imports, and continued depressed refinery operations due to the deep cold snap late last year.

In the details, U.S. crude oil production rose 0.1 mbpd to 12.2 mbpd.  Exports fell 2.1 mbpd, while imports rose 0.6 mbpd.  Refining activity rose 4.3% to 84.1% of capacity.  The Christmas cold snap closed in a significant level of refining activity, and the industry is slowly recovering.

(Sources: DOE, CIM)

The above chart shows the seasonal pattern for crude oil inventories.  Because we are starting the new year, we only have one datapoint for 2023.  The chart does show that the usual seasonal pattern was not followed last year.  This is because the average still reflects the restrictions on U.S. oil exports whereas there isn’t much of a discernable pattern to this data now that exports are allowed.

This chart shows the sharp drop and partial recovery in refining operations.

(Sources:  DOE, CIM)

Since the SPR is being used, to some extent, as a buffer stock, we have constructed oil inventory charts incorporating both the SPR and commercial inventories.

Total stockpiles peaked in 2017 and are now at levels last seen in 2001.  Using total stocks since 2015, fair value is $107.08.

Market News:

  • As China reopens from its COVID-19 lockdowns, it is increasing its oil import quotas. This decision is likely bullish for crude oil prices.  China is expected to buy a significant amount of Russian crude for this reopening, which should be available as the EU price cap has reduced Russian exports.
  • OPEC+ production rose modestly in December.
  • The DOE is forecasting lower oil prices in 2023 and 2024. For 2023, it is expecting Brent to average $83 per barrel, with $78 per barrel in 2024.  Expectations of rising output are behind the lower price forecast.
  • We discussed proposed rules for U.S. refiners last year. Further analysis suggests that the costs of the new rules could lead to about a 700 kbpd loss of gasoline production as older refineries become unprofitable.  Although we could see some “grandfathering,” refining issues remain a concern.
  • As we went into winter, the worry for the EU was that a cold winter would lead to a shortage of natural gas and therefore higher prices. Instead, Europe is being blessed with a historically mild winter.  Although these mild temperatures have helped Europe avoid a price crisis this winter, it could portend a hot, dry summer, which could lift natural gas prices later this year.  Last year’s dry summer caused havoc in Europe, affecting river travel and reducing nuclear power production, which was adversely affected by the water being too warm and too scarce to cool reactors.  Although summer remains a secondary demand season for natural gas, rising temperatures will lift natural gas-fired-electricity demand and may disrupt the inventory cycle, increasing the price risk when the eventual cold winter does occur.

(Source)

 Geopolitical News:

 Alternative Energy/Policy News:

  View PDF

Daily Comment (January 11, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EST] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with an update on the Russia-Ukraine war, where a key Russian blogger has broken taboo and directly criticized President Putin for his management of the invasion.  We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including some welcome signs of increased investments in U.S. manufacturing and energy production.

Russia-Ukraine War:  Reports indicate that Aleksandr Lapin, the former commander of the Central Military District forces that allowed the Ukrainians to recapture huge swaths of territory in eastern Ukraine last summer, has been reassigned to take over as chief of staff of the Russian ground forces.  In response, influential Russian military blogger and former rebel commander Igor Girkin published a criticism of President Putin for appointing and refusing to remove Russian military leaders who oversee frequent and disastrous military failures.  The criticism marks one of the first times an influential nationalist has directly criticized Putin for his management of the war.  It therefore signals how the disastrous invasion continues to undermine Putin’s political position within Russia.

Saudi Arabia-Pakistan:  The Saudi government said yesterday that it is considering offering some $11 billion in aid to Pakistan to help it avoid a threatened default on its foreign debt.  Along with earlier offers of aid from the United Arab Emirates and Qatar, the major Middle East oil producers have now said they may provide up to $22 billion to Pakistan.

  • The support could strengthen Pakistan’s hand in negotiating a restart to a stalled bailout from the International Monetary Fund.
  • Pakistan has so far been unwilling to agree to the IMF’s terms for a deal, which include raising electricity and gasoline prices and increasing taxes.

Egypt:  As part of its negotiations for a $3-billion bailout from the IMF, the Egyptian government has reportedly agreed to reduce the role of the military in the country’s economy, including via the privatization of military-owned businesses.  The military’s economic activity has spread through the economy since President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi took power in a coup in 2013, reducing opportunities for private business owners.

Brazil:   As prosecutors in Brazil continue to investigate last weekend’s capital rioting by supporters of Former President Bolsonaro, the former leader said he will leave the U.S. and return to Brazil within a few weeks.  Bolsonaro’s return to Brazil would likely be welcomed by the White House, which has come under pressure from some Democrats to expel him.

Peru:  At least 17 people have been killed in political protests this week, as the demonstrations intensify against last month’s removal and detention of Former President Castillo.  According to the country’s independent human rights office, 39 civilians have been killed in the unrest since Castillo’s arrest, while the defense ministry says 75 police officers have been injured.  The continued violence could threaten production at Peru’s globally important mines producing copper and other key minerals.

United States-China-Taiwan:  A series of 24 war games held by the Center for Strategic and International Studies found that an alliance of the U.S., Japan, and Taiwan would likely be able to repel a full-scale Chinese invasion of the self-governing island, but at the high cost of dozens of navy ships, hundreds of aircraft, and tens of thousands of troops over three to four weeks of fighting.  The report recommends that the U.S. improve its effort to increase deterrence against the Chinese by raising the expected costs that they would pay for an invasion.

U.S. Demographics:  A new study from the Aspen Economic Strategy Group finds that falling birth rates, declining population growth, and population aging are among the biggest risks for the future U.S. economy.  To address the threat, the study recommends that the U.S. adopt policies to increase fertility and boost immigration.

U.S. Monetary Policy:  At an event with other central bankers in Sweden yesterday, Federal Reserve Chair Powell said that he remains strongly committed to lowering inflation by restraining economic growth through interest-rate increases, even if doing so fuels political blowback.  In fact, he stressed that preserving the Fed’s ability to make tough economic calls without political interference would require it to avoid straying into issues that aren’t directly related to its economic-management objectives, such as climate change.

U.S. Industrial Policy:  South Korean conglomerate Hanwha Group (000.880.KS, KRW, 27,200) said that it will invest $2.5 billion to expand the production of solar panels and components at a facility in Georgia.  The commitment would reportedly be the biggest foreign direct investment in U.S. solar manufacturing ever.

  • The South Korean plan is also a sign that the big green-energy subsidies in the recently passed Inflation Reduction Act are already drawing increased investment to the U.S. that otherwise may have gone to other countries.
  • That risk has already generated pushback from the European Union, prompting some limited concessions from the U.S. We suspect that the U.S. subsidies will continue to spur concerns by other countries as more investment is redirected toward the U.S.  The U.S. program will also likely spur calls for similar subsidies in other countries.

U.S. Oil and Gas Industry:  Despite popular perceptions that U.S. oil and gas drilling is at a standstill, the Wall Street Journal has an interesting article today showing that activity in at least some regions is actually beginning to boom again, especially in natural gas fields.  We still suspect that environmental regulations, the rise of green energy, and investor demands for capital discipline will slow new energy investment and contribute to higher energy prices in the future, but today’s article points to at least some new activity after a long period where high prices failed to prompt the usual supply response.

U.S. Air Travel Industry: This morning, the Federal Aviation Administration halted all domestic air departures until at least 9:00 am ET due to an outage of its computer system that alerts pilots to advisories and other flight information.  The halt has reportedly produced numerous flight delays, pushing airline stocks lower.

View PDF

Daily Comment (January 10, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EST] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with the news of a potential mine shutdown that would affect global copper supplies and the increased tensions between China, Japan, and South Korea.  We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including signs that Pakistan is getting closer to defaulting on its foreign debts, and more indications that the Federal Reserve could soon slow its interest-rate hikes to just 25 basis points per meeting.

Global Copper Market:  Canadian miner First Quantum Minerals Ltd. (FQVLF, $23.19) said that it will shut down its vast copper mine in Panama, which produces about 1.4% of the world’s copper supply, if it can’t resolve a tax dispute with the Panamanian government.  Global copper prices remain in retreat, in large part because of the threat of recession in the West and lower demand from China as it deals with its latest COVID-19 wave.  Nevertheless, any outage at the FQM mine could help put a floor under prices or even give them a boost.

China-Japan-South Korea:  Today, the Chinese government suspended visa issuance to travelers from Japan and South Korea, marking its first formal retaliation for the COVID-19 testing rules those countries and others have imposed on travelers from China because of its massive new wave of infections.

  • The move illustrates how willing China is to wield its massive economic power as a source of coercion or consensus-building to influence other countries’ behavior.
  • As we wrote in our latest Bi-Weekly Geopolitical Report, published yesterday, China will probably grant or deny access to its vast market and capital flows in order to eventually establish a neo-colonial relationship with the countries in its evolving geopolitical bloc.

Russia-Ukraine War:  After weeks in which the front lines from eastern to southern Ukraine were largely static, Russian forces have reportedly been able to capture most of the town of Soledar, just to the northeast of the embattled city of Bakhmut.  That gives Russia a rare but mostly symbolic victory and will make it more difficult for Ukraine to hold Bakhmut, although the city isn’t expected to immediately fall.  The Russian move also comes as reports indicate that the country’s government will soon announce the mobilization of 500,000 more troops in another special draft.

  • Separately, after several countries last week agreed to send light tanks or armored vehicles to Ukraine, British officials said they have been discussing sending their Challenger 2 main battle tanks.
  • Poland, Finland, and other European countries are also considering sending heavily armored, powerful tanks, which in sufficient numbers could provide a major boost to Ukraine’s military power.

Brazil:  Following the weekend’s capital rioting by supporters of right-wing Former President Bolsonaro, the country’s supreme court yesterday ordered the suspension of the federal district’s governor, a Bolsonaro ally.  The move is likely to further anger Bolsonaro’s supporters and could exacerbate the country’s political polarization.  Separately, some Brazilian politicians who accuse Bolsonaro of inciting the unrest have demanded he be extradited from the U.S., where he has been for the last two weeks.  Some prominent U.S. Democrats have echoed that call.  However, the White House has merely said that it would treat any extradition request seriously.

Pakistan:  Facing dwindling currency reserves and a high risk of default on its foreign debts, yesterday the Pakistani government begged the International Monetary Fund to ease the harsh conditions on its funding program for the country in order to unleash billions of dollars of additional loans.  The IMF officials made no commitment to easing the terms.

Canada:  The Canadian government announced yesterday that it will buy 88 advanced F-35 fighter jets from Lockheed Martin (LMT, $458.99) to modernize its air combat capabilities.  The total cost of the purchase will be approximately $14 billion.  The purchase illustrates how much the West’s increasing defense budgets and military modernization efforts are likely to benefit U.S. defense firms, given their cutting-edge technologies and production capacity.

U.S. Monetary Policy:  San Francisco FRB President Daly said yesterday that because of the lags before changes in monetary policy affect the economy, it might make sense for the Fed to slow its interest-rate hikes to just 25 basis points beginning at its next policy meeting.  According to Daly, that would give the policymakers more time to assess how their previous aggressive rate hikes are affecting economic activity.  Meanwhile, Atlanta FRB President Bostic yesterday stated he would consider a 25-bps hike more seriously if Thursday’s inflation report shows that the consumer price index is slowing in line with other recent data releases.  The statements place a spotlight on Fed Chairman Powell’s remarks later today when he may weigh in on the issue.

U.S. Student Loan Market:  Today, the Department of Education released a proposed rule that would make it easier for student loan borrowers to use income-driven repayment plans and get out of their debt sooner.  For example, the minimum amount of monthly discretionary income that would have to be paid on their loans would be cut to 5% from the current 10%.  Borrower loan balances wouldn’t grow as long as they make their payments, which basically would amount to loan forgiveness for the borrowers with the lowest incomes.

View PDF

Bi-Weekly Geopolitical Report – How China Will Manage Its Evolving Geopolitical Bloc (January 9, 2023)

Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA | PDF

In mid-2022, we published a report showing that as the United States begins to step back from its traditional role as the global hegemon, the world is fracturing into relatively separate geopolitical and economic blocs.  Our study looked at almost 200 countries around the world and aimed to objectively predict which bloc each of those countries would end up in, i.e., the evolving U.S.-led bloc, the China-led bloc, the blocs that lean one way or the other, and a neutral bloc.  The study predicted that this global fracturing would have major effects on the world’s economy and financial markets, for example, by boosting commodity prices, inflation, and interest rates.

In this report, we deepen the analysis to examine how the U.S. and China will lead their respective blocs, and what that might mean for the global economy and financial markets.  We pay especially close attention to the implications for the U.S. dollar and the Chinese yuan as well as the broader implications for investors.

Read the full report

The associated podcast episode for this report will be available next week.