Daily Comment (June 5, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Our newest podcast episode, “The Long-Term Effects of COVID-19,” is available.  In this episode, we discuss how the COVID-19 pandemic will likely accelerate the reversal of the equality/efficiency cycle toward equality.

Good morning and happy employment Friday!  We go into the details below, but the quick snapshot is that the numbers are much better than forecast and mostly confirm the ADP data from earlier in the week that was stronger than expected.  Global equities are mostly higher this morning as optimism over economic reopening and policy support continues.  China remains in the news.  As usual, we update what we know about COVID-19.  There was an Iranian prisoner swap.  This week’s Asset Allocation Weekly (AAW) is posted; this week’s report shows how the equity markets recover before the peak in unemployment.  Onward!

China:

Foreign news: 

  • The U.S. and Iran engineered a prisoner swap. Iran released Michael White, a Navy veteran who had been detained while visiting Iran.  The U.S. deported Sirous Asgari, a scientist who was detained on charges of violating U.S. sanctions.  Although relations between Iran and the U.S. remain tense, the fact that this swap occurred does suggest backchannel contacts are operable.
  • One of our concerns with any administration is the problem of bandwidth. A government can find itself under great strain due to multiple simultaneous problems.  That is what the Trump administration is facing currently.  The deteriorating relations with China, trade issues with the EU, civil unrest at home, the pandemic—it’s a lot happening in real time.  It is under conditions of stress that foreign nations try to take advantage of the distraction in Washington.  We note that recently Iran and Venezuela jointly violated U.S. sanctions; so far, neither has seen any retaliation.  Expect more problems to develop in the coming weeks.  We are watching North Korea and Russia to see if they try to take advantage of the situation.
  • A major diesel fuel spill has occurred in Siberia.
  • When political systems fracture, fringe groups emerge. The latest in Italy is dubbed the “orange jackets,” a movement with overtures to France’s “yellow jackets.”  This new movement is so extremely populist that the League party won’t affiliate with it.  Although sympathizers with such political extremes always exist, it is during periods of turmoil that they can coalesce into political movements.

COVID-19:  The number of reported cases is 6,658,334 with 391,588 deaths and 2,886,183 recoveries.  In the U.S., there are 1,872,334 confirmed cases with 108,211 deaths and 485,002 recoveries.  For those who like to keep score at home, the FT has created a nifty interactive chart that allows one to compare cases between countries, scaled by various variables.

Policy news:

  • The expanded unemployment benefits of $600 per week expire at the end of July. There is a debate on whether they should be extended.  The Congressional Budget Office has weighed in on the debate.  Its research suggests that over 80% of recipients would get more in benefits than they would earn working and that extending the benefits would likely lead to lower growth this year.  However, not extending the benefits will lead to lower growth and employment in 2021, most likely because the growth and employment occurred in 2020.  Our read on the report likely means the expanded benefits probably won’t be extended.
  • Chile is asking the Fed to extend swap lines to the country and is asking the PBOC to increase the swap line with China.

Economy news: 

View the complete PDF

Daily Comment (June 4, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Good morning.  It’s ECB day!  The ECB continues to support the EU economy.  It’s June 4, the 31st anniversary of the Tiananmen Square Massacre; we note China is playing up the current U.S. civil unrest as a counterpoint to Beijing’s actions in Hong Kong.  Global equities are mostly lower this morning, as risk markets take a breather from recent strength; however, we have seen some recovery on the ECB news.  We cover the ECB meeting and look at the latest with China.  As usual, we update what we know about COVID-19.  We have a new Weekly Energy Update, with a special look at natural gas. Let’s get to it…

ECB:  In its prepared statement, the European Central Bank announced it will expand its emergency QE by €600 billion.  Interest rates remained unchanged.  It also said purchases will continue into June 2021.  Market reaction was swift; as the global risk-on rally has been supported by central bank action, news of the ECB’s move lifted global equities.  In something of a surprise, the EUR rallied as well.  Usually, QE is bearish for a currency.  In the press conference, ECB President Lagarde didn’t offer any major surprises

China:  Lots of China news:

Civil unrest:  The widespread civil unrest is further delaying the reopening of small businesses.

Foreign news: 

COVID-19:  The number of reported cases is 6,530,067 with 386,392 deaths and 2,820,488 recoveries.  In the U.S., there are 1,851,520 confirmed cases with 107,175 deaths and 479,258 recoveries.  For those who like to keep score at home, the FT has created a nifty interactive chart that allows one to compare cases and fatalities between nations, scaled by population.  Axios has updated its U.S. infection map.

  • The good news:
    • When thinking about a problem, it is helpful to know more about the issue one is trying to resolve. For the most part, medical researchers have been treating COVID-19 as primarily a respiratory disease.  This led to the crash production of ventilators and the search for antiviral medicines.  However, there is growing evidence that although the virus spreads through the lungs, the biggest impact may be vascular.  The virus’s primary impact may be to infect the endothelial cells in blood vessels.  When these cells become inflamed, it could lead to microclotting and would explain the wide variety of symptoms.  Unlike seasonal flu or SARS, which tend to remain in the lungs, COVID-19 spreads throughout the body, causing damage to kidneys, conditions close to frostbite in toes, and strokes.
      • If this is how the virus works, the best protection may come from ACE inhibitors, statins and blood thinners. There are trials now underway to see if losartan, a common high blood pressure drug, may prevent the worst symptoms of the disease.  In other words, if taking cardiovascular medicine prevents fatalities and hospitalizations, we could treat COVID-19 with common drugs and extreme measures to avoid the disease may not be necessary.
    • Scientists are studying patterns to see if there is a genetic basis that might explain the wide variation seen in the reaction to infection. There is evidence to suggest that there are sizeable numbers of asymptomatic cases and, at the same time, fatalities.  If a common genetic threat could be found, it may allow for less stringent lockdowns and could help in determining who should get vaccinated before others.  A recent European study suggests that having Type A blood increases the likelihood of a more serious reaction to infection.
    • The U.S. has selected five firms as vaccine finalists. Narrowing the list will allow the government to focus its efforts on producing a vaccine once an effective candidate emerges.  In related news, Eli Lilly (LLY, 152.53) is testing a new drug that is derived from antibodies developed from patients infected with the virus.
  • The bad news:

Policy news:

Finance news: 

Economy news: 

View the complete PDF

Weekly Energy Update (June 4, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

Here is an updated crude oil price chart.  The oil market continues to recover after April’s historic collapse.

(Source: Barchart.com)

Crude oil inventories surprised the markets for the fourth straight week with stockpiles falling 2.1 mb compared to forecasts of a 3.0 mb build.

In the details, U.S. crude oil production fell 0.2 mbpd to 11.2 mbpd.  Exports fell 0.4 mbpd, while imports declined 1.0 mbpd.  Refining activity rose 0.5%, a bit below expectations.  As we saw last week, there was another jump in unaccounted-for crude oil.

Unaccounted-for crude oil is a balancing item in the weekly energy balance sheet.  To make the data balance, this line item is a plug figure, but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t matter.  This week’s number of -1.01 mbpd is the largest negative number on record.  For the fourth week in a row, this number is running nearly 1.0 mbpd.  The 12-week average is on the verge of going negative for the first time since October 2017.  It may mean that in the scramble for finding storage, some oil is being inventoried outside the survey system.  This week, the SPR took 4.0 mb, but that doesn’t resolve the unaccounted-for crude issue.  This week, some 7.0 mb of crude oil went into storage somewhere, just not where it can be recorded.  Or, production is falling much faster than the DOE estimates are capturing so there aren’t any missing barrels; simply put, production is cratering.  We still don’t know which thesis is correct.  However, given the persistence in the unaccounted number, it is looking increasingly likely the DOE is overestimating production.

(Sources: DOE, CIM)

The above chart shows the annual seasonal pattern for crude oil inventories.  This week’s data showed a modest decline in crude oil stockpiles.  We are getting close to the beginning of the seasonal draw for crude oil.  If inventories don’t decline in the coming weeks, oil prices would be vulnerable to a correction.

Based on our oil inventory/price model, fair value is $29.12; using the euro/price model, fair value is $45.01.  The combined model, a broader analysis of the oil price, generates a fair value of $36.57.  It does appear that the worries over storage capacity have been resolved, so the model is more reliable.  We have been seeing a steady drop in the dollar recently.  The Eurozone is considering a mutualized debt instrument to pay for COVID-19 costs.  It is possible the Eurozone may use this event to create a permanent mutualized Eurobond which would make the EUR an attractive alternative to the dollar for reserve purposes.  A weaker dollar would be bullish for oil prices.

In energy news, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (KSA) moved liquidity from its foreign reserves to its sovereign wealth fund.  The fund has been aggressively buying assets overseas, viewing the current weakness caused by the virus as a buying opportunity.  Foreign reserves act as a buffer to low oil prices and so a decline in reserves may force additional austerity measures on the populous.

This chart shows the KSA’s foreign reserves and Brent oil prices.  Lower oil prices tend to reduce reserve levels with a lag.  Thus, the decision to shift funds to the soverign wealth fund may reflect the idea that oil prices will rebound quickly.

In OPEC news, there are doubts the cartel will hold an early meeting.  This news eased prices modestly.  We expect the cartel and Russia will maintain production cuts for at least another month.  Venezuela says it will increase gasoline prices, a risky move for a nation with heavily subsidized petrol.

VP Biden is considering new climate proposals; if elected, these measures may reduce oil production.  The Trump administration has reduced states’ ability to regulate energy companies; that may reverse under a Biden government.

This week, we want to discuss the natural gas market.  May is the “shoulder month” for demand.  As summer unfolds, demand for electricity tends to rise and, if temperatures are high enough, helps boost natural gas prices.  First, here is the supply/demand balance.

Currently, there is a rather wide supply imbalance, with supply outpacing consumption.  Under these conditions, inventories tend to accumulate.  The chart below shows seasonally adjusted working natural gas storage.  Inventory levels are well above normal as we head into summer.

One bright spot is that the supply/consumption balance is showing some improvement.  If we see hot weather in the coming weeks, it should allow the inventory overhang to dissipate and support prices.  Another bullish factor is that falling oil production will reduce associated natural gas production, which should help narrow the inventory overhang.  However, any bullish scenario rests on an unusually hot summer.  The current summer forecast is leaning hot, so there is the potential for a price recovery in the coming weeks.

View the PDF

Daily Comment (June 3, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Our newest podcast episode, “The Long-Term Effects of COVID-19,” is available.  We continue to build on themes discussed in the previous episode, “The Lessons of History,” in which we examined the effects of earlier pandemics.  In this episode, we discuss how the COVID-19 pandemic will likely accelerate the reversal of the equality/efficiency cycle toward equality.  Deglobalization is a key element of that shift.  Although we believe the world has been steadily moving toward equality, this pandemic is moving the process forward.  The eventual outcome is higher inflation, although it may take several years for higher price levels to become evident.

Turning to the latest news, it appears the U.S. civil rights protests eased notably last night, but risk assets are rallying today mostly on optimism regarding an eventual coronavirus vaccine, a potential recovery in the economy and labor market, and additional monetary and fiscal stimulus.  We discuss all the key developments below.

United States:  The latest reports suggest the intense civil rights protests of the last week eased somewhat on Tuesday night, possibly because many cities toughened their curfews and state and local officials began taking action to address protestors’ anger over law enforcement practices and a perceived impunity for police brutality.  In Minnesota, where the protests first erupted, Governor Tim Walz said the state is launching a civil rights investigation into “systemic discriminatory practices” by the Minneapolis Police Department.  State officials also said the economic cost of the violence in Minnesota alone was at least $1 billion, not including the impact of lost jobs and looting.  As we’ve mentioned previously, investors have generally overlooked the violence on the assumption that it will be short-lived.  The more salient issue is that the violence could have political implications for the November elections.  If the protests continue to ease, the political impact will become less likely.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 6,411,023 worldwide, with 380,880 deaths and 2,750,891 recoveries.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 1,831,821, with 106,181 deaths and 463,868 recoveries.  Here is the interactive chart from the Financial Times that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population.

Virology

Real Economy

Financial Markets

  • While the U.S. yield curve as measured by the 10-year Treasury versus the 2-year note or the 3-month bill has recently held steady, with both spreads in the range of 50-60 basis points, the less popular 30-year/5-year spread has widened to almost 120 basis points for the first time since 2017.  Traders ascribe the widening to a greater supply of longer-term debt and moderating Fed purchases due to the relative stabilization in the economy.
  • Ten weeks after the Fed calmed the corporate bond market by promising to buy up to $750 billion of individual businesses’ debt obligations, not a single company has signed up for the program.  The Fed’s sole purchases in the market have been $3 billion in corporate bond ETFs.  Echoing the traditional reluctance of banks to access Fed backstops, it turns out that companies are reluctant to sign up for Fed purchases because such a move could be seen as a sign of weakness during the market’s rebound.

U.S. Policy Response

  • President Trump will meet this week with his top economic advisors to discuss policy options for the next economic support bill.  Although the scope of the plan is still in flux, reports suggest a wide variety of measures are under consideration:
    • One top focus will be on ways to encourage people to go back to work, including a proposal to cut the federally funded enhanced unemployment benefit from $600 per week now to as little as $250 per week through the second half of the year.
    • The administration is also discussing a tourism tax deduction, or credit for people who take a vacation somewhere in the U.S. in the next three to six months.
    • The president and his aides also continue to push proposals for which they have long been advocating, including a payroll-tax holiday and a capital-gains tax cut.
    • A longer-term priority will be measures to encourage companies to do business in the U.S., including making certain rules permanent that allow firms to deduct the cost of relocating manufacturing operations from China and other countries.

Foreign Policy Response

  • As Europe continues to play catchup with the aggressive monetary and fiscal programs put into place by the U.S. to support the economy during the coronavirus crisis, the ECB is expected to unveil some €500 billion in additional bond purchases at its policy meeting tomorrow.  That would boost its total firepower to almost €1.5 trillion, or $1.68 trillion, putting it on a par with the U.S.’s spending plan and setting the stage for the central bank to buy most of the new debt that Eurozone governments will issue this year to fight the crisis.

United States-Venezuela:  The Trump administration further increased its economic pressure on the Venezuelan government by imposing sanctions on four shipping firms allegedly involved in supplying the country with fuel products.

United States-China: Adding to the general trend of U.S.-China decoupling, Senator Rob Portman (R-Ohio) and Senator Tom Carper (D-Del.) today plan to introduce legislation to stop China and other “malign state actors” from stealing U.S. taxpayer-funded research at universities by enhancing the authority of federal agencies to monitor and punish the schools and scientists.

View the complete PDF

Daily Comment (June 2, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

The general uptrend in risk assets continues to stem mostly from the gradual easing of coronavirus lockdowns and progress on vaccines and treatments.  Today’s market action also reflects signs that the major oil-producing countries will extend their production cuts, which has boosted crude oil prices.  Those developments continue to outweigh the violent civil rights protests in the U.S., though we note that the demonstrations do carry political risks.

United States:  With civil rights protests continuing to devolve into violence across the country, President Trump yesterday said he would deploy military forces to take control of the situation in Washington, D.C. and other cities if state and local governments don’t “take the actions that are necessary to defend the life and property of their residents.”  The federal troops would be in addition to the 67,000 National Guard troops already called up by the states.

  • It wasn’t immediately clear whether Mr. Trump had invoked the Insurrection Act, a law that allows a president to deploy the military in response to civil unrest. If he did invoke the law, it would be the first use of active duty military troops to quell civil disorder in nearly 30 years.
  • Although the financial markets typically look past such protests in the U.S., as they’re generally short-lived, the current riots bear watching because they have implications for the November elections.  It’s easy to imagine the violence is a spontaneous outpouring of anger related to law enforcement practices, a perception of impunity for police brutality and the frustrations of the long coronavirus lockdown.  However, reports also suggest the violence is being further fueled by extremist groups on both the far right and the far left, which politicians are sure to try to exploit for their own gain.  Just as important, the deployment of National Guard and federal troops raises the risk that someone with a happy trigger finger could spark bloodshed.  In Kentucky, police and National Guard troops killed one man on Sunday night, and here in St. Louis, four police officers were hit by gunfire last night.  Any situation in which federal troops killed multiple protestors would likely morph into an even greater political controversy.
  • The rioting also has implications for international politics.  Chinese officials and state media outlets have already savaged the Trump administration’s response to the protests, describing the president as a hypocrite after he supported Hong Kong’s demonstrations.  China’s foreign ministry sent a taunting tweet to the U.S. State Department simply saying, “I can’t breathe.”  Other reports say Russia and China are both flooding social media with content criticizing the U.S. for its handling of race issues.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 6,294,222 worldwide, with 376,177 deaths and 2,714,922 recoveries.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 1,811,277, with 105,147 deaths and 458,231 recoveries.  Here is the interactive chart from the Financial Times that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population.

Virology

Real Economy

  • The Congressional Budget Office said the sharp contraction triggered by the coronavirus caused it to mark down its 2020-30 forecast for U.S. economic output by a cumulative $7.9 trillion, or 3% of GDP, relative to its January projections. GDP isn’t expected to catch up to the previously forecast level until the fourth quarter of 2029.
  • Although yesterday’s May ISM Manufacturing Index for the U.S. showed a modest rebound to 43.1, from 41.5 in April, the figure continues to be distorted by the sub-index on supplier deliveries.  The ISM indexes and sub-indexes are designed so that readings over 50 point to expanding activity.  The sub-index on supplier deliveries is higher when deliveries are slower, on the assumption that delivery delays reflect high activity and bottlenecks.  However, in the coronavirus crisis, deliveries are slow and the supplier delivery index is elevated in large part because of lockdowns.  Therefore, we think we can get a better feel for the true level of activity by looking at our own, proprietary estimate of the overall ISM index excluding supplier deliveries.  As shown in the charts below, that measure rebounded only to 36.9 in May from 33.0 in April, suggesting factory activity continues to contract sharply.

Financial Markets

Democratic Republic of Congo:  The government has declared a new Ebola epidemic after it identified six cases in the west of the country, far from the previous outbreak in the east.  The outbreak is the country’s fourth in the last three years and the 11th since the first cases were detected in 1976.

Russia: President Putin announced the vote on constitutional revisions that would allow him to remain in power for up to 16 more years will be held on July 1, after being postponed by the coronavirus crisis.  Actual voting will begin a week before the official ballot date.

Russia:  After three medical doctors mysteriously “fell” out of windows in recent months, raising suspicion that they were assassinated for resisting or exposing government missteps related to the coronavirus crisis, now a female police forensic officer has fallen out of a window at a hospital where she was being treated for the virus.

View the complete PDF

Weekly Geopolitical Report – The Geopolitics of the 2020 Election: Part II (June 1, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady | PDF

In this five-part series on the geopolitics of the 2020 election, we have broken the reports into nine sections. In Part I, we covered the basics of public finance.  This week, we will cover the second and third sections, understanding the electorate and party coalitions.

Understanding the Electorate
Understanding the electorate is about divining the psychological and economic interests of voters.  In this section, we describe how we examine the voting public.

There is a distinction between class and identity.  Identity is complicated.  All of us belong to various groups based upon our gender, race, religion, age, geographic location, education, etc.  The interlacing of these various memberships is known as intersectionality.  Although the term is often applied to those who face discrimination, in general, this term captures the various “tribal” groups to which we find ourselves belonging.  Thus, a white, gay, Catholic with a graduate degree may have something in common with a Hispanic, straight, Catholic with a high school diploma through their religious affiliation.  However, it is unlikely the commonality would be very strong.  In general, the greater the identity overlap a person has with others the higher the probability they will vote for or favor candidates of a similar persuasion.  At the same time, each person tends to “rank order” their identities; some put a much higher rank on race relative to religion, for example.  Or, their geographic location is the most important identity classification.

Class is rather straightforward, determined by the decile in which one’s income and wealth falls.  This breakdown isn’t perfect, however, as the class interests between two people with equal income can differ.  For example, if two middle managers at different firms make the same income, but one manager’s firm benefits from free trade and the other does not, they may favor different economic policies.  But, in general, policies favored by class tend to be uniform.  For example, the wealthy tend to have similar positions on taxes, while the less affluent tend to think very highly of Social Security.

We define a group as the cross-section of identity and class.  A group is a set of like-minded people who tend to support similar political, economic and social positions.

To describe the interplay between identity and class, we have borrowed this grid from Peter Zeihan.

Read the full report

Daily Comment (June 1, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Good morning.  It’s Monday and the beginning of another month.  Global equities are mixed this morning, although we do note the Hang Seng rallied.  Over the weekend, civil disorder occurred around the U.S.  We discuss the latest with China.  The G-7 was cancelled.  As usual, we update everything we know about COVID-19.  Let’s get to it…

Civil unrest:  In the wake of the death of George Floyd, protests and violence occurred in numerous U.S. cities.  For the most part, financial markets are generally unaffected by these sorts of events, mostly because they don’t last long.  That isn’t to say they are not having an effect on the economyRetailers are being forced to close stores.  We also note the protests are undermining America’s credibility in reference to human rights; China is pointing this out with reference to Hong Kong.  However, overall, equity markets are not showing much effect.

China:  On Friday, as expected, President Trump unveiled U.S. policy with regard to Hong Kong.  Equities rallied, which suggests financial markets were expecting much harsher policy actions.  Still, it is unmistakable that relations are deteriorating and are expanding beyond trade.  At the same time, the EU is making it abundantly clear that it won’t take any steps to jeopardize trade relations.  For the first time in three decades, security officials in Hong Kong have banned the usual Tiananmen Square Massacre vigil, normally held on June 4.  They have cited pandemic issues, but few believe that is the primary concern.  Additionally, Beijing has told its state-run commodity firms to “pause” the purchases of U.S. agriculture products.  If this persists, it will put doubt into the Phase 1 trade deal.

Foreign news:  After German Chancellor Merkel indicated she would not travel to Camp David for the G-7 summit, President Trump decided to postpone the entire affair until autumn.  He has indicated he would like to invite Russia, South Korea and Australia to the meeting to discuss how the world should deal with China in the future.

COVID-19:  The number of reported cases is 6,193,548 with 372,479 deaths and 2,656,267 recoveries.  In the U.S., there are 1,790,191 confirmed cases with 104,383 deaths and 444,758 recoveries.  For those who like to keep score at home, the FT has created a nifty interactive chart that allows one to compare cases and fatalities between nations, scaled by population.

Policy news: The next big worry for the financial markets is state and local governments.  As revenues crater and virus-related spending soars, cities and states are facing the problem of either increasing borrowing or cutting services.  In 2010, local governments cut back spending to the point where it more than offset federal spending.  If that is repeated, it increases the threat of an economic relapse.  The alternative may be either direct fiscal support from the federal government, or expanding Fed buying of municipal debt.

Finance news:  We are paying close attention to the dollar’s recent slide.  There are likely two factors behind the weakness.  First, as the world economy recovers, flight-to-safety demand for the greenback is likely easing.  Second, the EU’s decision to create a Eurobond for virus spending relief could bring more potent competition for the dollar’s reserve role.  We have serious doubts that the northern European nations will allow this decision to evolve into a general spending Eurobond, but the hope has lifted sentiment toward the EUR.

Economy news:  As we have noted in the WEU, gasoline consumption does appear to be recovering.  GPS requests are rising as well.  An increase in driving activity bodes well for economic recovery.

  • As noted below, global PMI data is showing signs of improvement from a deep trough. However, China’s PMI data, although in expansion mode, is showing few signs of acceleration.
  • It does appear that meat processing has recovered; however, in a pattern often seen, meat prices will likely remain elevated for a few weeks as grocers take advantage of improving margins.

View the complete PDF

Asset Allocation Weekly (May 29, 2020)

by Asset Allocation Committee

The recent strong rally in equities has befuddled investors—how can equities rally with such vigor when the economy is historically weak?  We suspect there are two reasons for this recovery:

  1. Although the drop in economic activity is deep, it will likely be short.
  2. Supportive monetary policy is a powerful elixir for equities.

Equity markets are forward-looking; investors put their money to work on expectations of future economic conditions and earnings, not based on what is occurring today.  The current downturn is historic.  The decline in the economy has been very fast and deep, but it will likely be short.  In fact, the recovery should begin by midsummer at the latest.  We use these words to mean something specific.

This chart shows a stylized path of the business cycle.  Orange represents expansion, when the economy is making new peaks in an indicator.  This can be GDP, industrial production, coincident indicators, etc.  Blue is recession and is measured from peak to trough.  Green is recovery, which lasts from trough until a new peak occurs.  Finally, once a new peak is made, a new expansion is underway.

We expect this recession to end quickly because the trough will probably occur in Q2.  However, the recovery will be long and likely dictated by the path of the virus.  We currently estimate the new expansion will start in H2 2021.

(Data source: Haver Analytics)

This table shows the declines in the S&P 500 for the postwar recessions.  On average, equities tend to peak about six months before the onset of the economic downturn, while the low occurs about six months after the peak in economic activity.  From the market low to recovery, the S&P 500 usually rebounds by about 20%.  But, notice from deep recessions that the rebound from the low is about 33%.  The rebound we have witnessed thus far is in line with a deep downturn, but it appears unusual due to the compressed nature of the current recession.

Also noted above are the aggressive actions taken by the FOMC.  Below is a chart that will be familiar to regular readers.

From early 2009 until November 2016, the path of the S&P 500 closely matched the Fed’s balance sheet.  There was always concern that the relation was a spurious correlation, and the behavior from December 2016 into August 2019 suggested it was.  However, it is important to note that equities were buoyed by expectations of a massive corporate tax cut.  Taking the balance sheet and incorporating the tax cut gives us a model that offers some insight into the impact of current monetary policy.

Fair value is derived from smoothing the higher marginal rate of the corporate tax and the balance sheet.  Adding the impact of the tax cut accounts for some of the rally in equities.  The sharp rise in the fair value in recent months reflects the massive expansion of the balance sheet.

This is not our forecast for the S&P 500, but it does offer some insight into how powerful the Fed’s actions have been.  We doubt the equity index will track this model due to the level of uncertainty surrounding the path of the economy.  Nevertheless, a projected short, sharp downturn coupled with the most rapid increase in the balance sheet since WWII have created strong support for equities that will likely prevent significant corrections, barring a major policy error or an unexpected negative turn in the toxicity of the virus.

View the PDF