Daily Comment (June 22, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Good morning and happy Monday.  U.S. equity futures are higher this morning, while Europe is lower.  Treasuries yields are lower, as well as the dollar, while gold is up. EU leaders are talking to Chairman Xi today; the new security law passed in Beijing, meaning it has become law in Hong Kong.  We recap banking data.  President Trump says he will talk to Maduro.  Our usual commentary on COVID-19 is available.   Here are the details:

China news: 

  • EU and Chinese leaders are scheduled to have a video conference today. European leaders have become increasingly alarmed by China’s behavior.  As we have discussed before, the EU has noted Beijing’s aggressive narrative control over COVID-19.  In addition, China’s investment activities in Europe has raised fears that China will use the weakness caused by the pandemic to take control of European businesses.  Expectations surrounding the talks are low, suggesting that not much will come from the conference.
  • Although the news was no surprise, Beijing is moving to ratify the new security law for Hong Kong. The Standing Committee of the Politburo will convene a special session on June 28 and impose the new law on the former colony.  One part of the new law will establish a new agency to execute national security in Hong Kong, signaling it is taking concrete steps to apply the new legislation.  The decision to create this new bureaucracy quashes any hope that the law would be passed but implemented with a “light touch.” This law will effectively end Hong Kong’s “one country, two systems” approach.  We expect this decision to further undermine U.S. and U.K. relations with China.
  • China has had a new surge of COVID-19 cases, with the outbreak centered on food markets in Beijing. As we noted last week, Nordic salmon was said to have tested positive for the virus, although it was generally believed the virus likely came from infected workers handling the product.  Although handling or eating food that has been found to have the virus hasn’t been reported as a vector for spreading the disease, blaming the outbreak on imported food does fit Beijing’s narrative of the virus coming from outside China.  Over the weekend, China has banned some chicken imports coming from a Tyson (TSN, 63.22) plant with a high number of COVID-19 cases.   We would not be surprised to see China use this news as an excuse for failing to meet its obligations set in the Phase One trade agreement.
  • The PBOC held its loan prime rate steady, suggesting that we are probably approaching the end of the rate cutting cycle in China.

Economic news:

  • The Fed has updated its May data on the banking system. There were three items that are worth noting.  First, households are being very cautious.  Consumer credit fell 1.1% from last year.

Second, deposits have soared, rising 20.7% from last year, the fastest growth for this data (which goes back to 1973.

Third, business lending has soared (and partly accounts for the jump in deposits).

What does this tell us?  Households are cutting their borrowing and increasing their cash holdings, while businesses are tapping credit lines and gathering cash too.  There is a pile of liquidity in the financial system and where it eventually ends up will be critical for financial and commodity markets.

Policy news:

COVID-19:   The number of reported cases is 8,975,776 with 468,724 deaths and 4,448,281 recoveries.   In the U.S., there are 2,280,969 confirmed cases with 119,977 deaths and 622,133 recoveries.  For those who like to keep score at home, the FT has created a nifty interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.

Virology:

View the complete PDF

Asset Allocation Weekly (June 19, 2020)

by Asset Allocation Committee

By now, investors have rightly come around to the idea that the equity market’s strong rebound since late March can be largely ascribed to the aggressive monetary and fiscal policies put in place to counter the coronavirus crisis.  The economic downturn from the pandemic lockdown has been severe, pushing unemployment to its highest level since the Great Depression and freezing demand for most products.  All the same, the Federal Reserve’s massive bond-buying and the federal government’s gigantic spending programs have convinced many people that the public sector is doing what’s necessary to support a quick recovery and minimize the long-term damage.  Investors have bid up stocks in response.  The technology-heavy NASDAQ has even reached a new record high.

What’s gotten less attention is that the policy moves have also helped limit the damage in the debt markets.  That’s especially clear in the market for riskier debt that the credit rating firms consider to be below-investment grade, i.e., “high yield” or “junk” bonds.  One way to measure the demand for that kind of debt is to compare the yield investors are requiring for that kind of bond versus the yield on a risk-free bond of similar maturity, such as the five-year Treasury note.  As shown in the chart below, the effective yield on the BofA Merrill Lynch High-Yield Master II Index spiked to as much as 8.57% at the peak of the coronavirus crisis in March and April.  At the same time, safe-haven buying drove down the yield on the five-year Treasury note to just 0.39%.  That boosted the high-yield spread over the five-year Treasury all the way to 8.18% compared with an average spread of 5.61% over the last several decades.

As shown in the chart, the April spread of 8.18% was one full standard deviation above the average spread since 1988.  But instead of rising even further above the one-standard deviation mark as typically happens during a recession, the spread has fallen modestly in May and June.  We think that’s a clear indication that investor nerves have been calmed by the aggressive monetary and fiscal policy already put into place.  One particularly helpful move was the Fed’s decision to purchase corporate debt, ultimately including debt that had been downgraded to junk status after March 22 and corporate bond ETFs that might hold high-yield obligations.

By pumping liquidity into the economy and helping many firms avoid bankruptcy, the U.S. policy moves have helped bolster not only junk bonds, but also investment-grade bonds and equities.  For example, the chart below shows how the spread of corporate investment-grade yields over the 10-year Treasury also initially spiked and then narrowed after the policy moves were implemented.  The pattern looks very similar to the narrowing of high-yield spreads.  Although the financial markets remain volatile and credit spreads could widen again, we think the early signs of credit spread narrowing support increasing exposure to corporate credit in portfolios.

View the PDF

Daily Comment (June 19, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Good morning and happy Friday! U.S. equity futures are higher this morning as optimism over the economy continues to rise.  China remains in the news.  The forbearance being offered by lenders is having an adverse impact on the industry designed to deal with bad debt—bankruptcy lawyers and trustees, repossession firms, auction houses, etc.  Our usual commentary on COVID-19 is available.  Additionally, there are a couple of interesting market items.  Here are the details:

China news: 

  • SoS Pompeo met with Yang Jiechi yesterday in Hawaii. Both sides have been mostly tight-lipped about the outcome; it appears that the U.S. and China stated their positions on various issues but if there was any attempt to find commonality, it isn’t obvious.  Meanwhile, President Trump indicated the U.S. could still sever relations with China.
  • Large changes create opportunities. As conditions change in Hong Kong, other nations are looking to provide a home for various businesses currently in the former colony.  Japan is attempting to bring financial firms to Tokyo, for example.  At the same time, as the U.S. considers making Chinese firms delist from U.S. stock exchanges, Hong Kong bankers are trying to get these firms to list in Hong Kong.  Although only time will tell, it is possible that China will attempt to preserve Hong Kong’s financial power; as the U.S. leans toward closing off American financial markets from China, the Xi regime may need Hong Kong’s financial expertise.  That doesn’t mean that the CPC won’t try to end democracy in Hong Kong, but it may give the financial industry wide latitude to operate.
  • We continue to closely monitor the situation on the Indian/Chinese frontier. The leadership of both nations appear to be trying to contain nationalist fervor that could force escalation.  China, due to its social controls, can generally manage such issues.  India, on the other hand, has an active tabloid press and thus PM Modi will have his hands full trying to keep group emotions in check.
  • One outcome from the border clash is that New Delhi may decide to join the West in dealing with China. India has traditionally avoided such arrangements.  It was a key member of the non-aligned movement during the Cold War and tried to avoid joining either the Communist Bloc or the Free World.  If the border issue leads to India joining the West, it will add to the encirclement of China and would be seen as a major loss for Beijing.

Policy news:

  • One of the strengths of the U.S. system of capitalism is the ability to deal with failure. In Europe, going bankrupt could put a person in debtor’s prison; in the U.S., debts are written down and the debtor could start over.  The U.S. system isn’t perfect, but it works remarkably well compared to other nations.  An infrastructure has developed around bankruptcy and bad debt; there are law firms that specialize in bankruptcies.  Towing firms engage in repossession; banks have workout groups.  Auction houses specialize in selling off the assets that are repossessed.  Firms clean up houses after evictions to prepare for sale or lease.  All this activity forces creditors to quickly adjust the value of their loan assets and allows debtors to start over.  Additionally, the repossessed asset then gets put back into the economy, usually at an attractive price, to find a new use.
    • That process is mostly on hold. Despite rising bankruptcies on the horizon, at present, a set of policy decisions has effectively frozen the process.  In many states, evictions have been postponed.  Banks have been encouraged to offer debt service forbearance.  If the current downturn is mostly a short-term phenomenon and all will return to normal soon, these actions make sense.  However, if the recovery turns out to be long (as we expect), these policies will tend to keep debt backed by assets that have fallen in value in limbo.
    • If policy prevents the process of foreclosure, as we see in China and Japan, it can lead to slower growth. At the same time, the bankruptcy process, much like insurance, isn’t designed for systemic events.  In other words, the process works if bankruptcy is caused by poor management or bad luck for an individual; it doesn’t work as well if the bankruptcies are due to an event that causes widespread failure.  That’s what we saw in the Great Depression; the policy of the Hoover administration was to liquidate the loans aggressively, but that led to a debt/deflation spiral that collapsed the economy.
    • Policymakers seem to be leaning toward this event as systemic, so it has encouraged lenders to avoid immediate repossession and the Fed has been buying up corporate debt. The problem is that some of these loans are simply not going to get serviced and should be liquidated.  Unfortunately, it is hard to discern who is facing a solvency issue and who is facing a liquidity issue.  What we are doing works if it’s mostly the latter; it will create a Japan-like situation if it’s the former.
  • There is a growing call for a better way to fund small business. Although the SBA exists, its lending doesn’t appear to be filling the need.  So, there is some speculation that the Fed’s current program may become permanent.
    • Our two cents? A better way would be to reduce consolidation in the financial system and support the expansion of small banks.  Smaller banks seemed to do a better job of managing the PPP program; large banks do a good job with (a) massive loans to large borrowers, and (b) lending that is rules-based, like mortgages.  However, larger banks can only make money on operations that they can scale up and making individual lending decisions by human loan officers isn’t in their “sweet spot.”  That is a business that smaller banks can do more effectively.
  • European nations are on their way to implementing digital taxes. This will exacerbate trade tensions.

COVID-19:  The number of reported cases is 8,513,725 with 454,513 deaths and 4,181,443 recoveries.   In the U.S., there are 2,191,200 confirmed cases with 118,435 deaths and 599,115 recoveries.  For those who like to keep score at home, the FT has created a nifty interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.

Virology:

Markets:

View the complete PDF

Daily Comment (June 18, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Good morning!  U.S. equity futures are weaker this morning, but off the worst levels of the overnight session.  Our usual commentary on COVID-19 is available.  We cover a myriad of policy issues this morning, including global taxes and the increased scrutiny facing U.S. tech firms.  In policy, a number of central banks took action overnight.  Australia looks like it is in recession and we examine the difference between expectations and reality in the economic reports.  The Weekly Energy Update is available.  Here are the details:

COVID-19The number of reported cases is 8,367,894 with 449,397 deaths and 4,091,978 recoveries.  In the U.S., there are 2,163,894 confirmed cases with 117,717 deaths and 592,191 recoveries.  For those who like to keep score at home, the FT has created a nifty interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.  Additionally, we have the weekly Axios U.S. state map.

Virology:

Policy news:

  • One of the issues that has developed in public finance is taxing multinational corporations. In the U.S., we often see tax breaks offered to companies to move facilities into a state.  It can become a race to the bottom as states are continually faced with the need to offer deals to keep companies within the state.  Because public goods must usually be provided to the company and workers (workers need police and fire protection, schools and company facilities need the same, plus infrastructure) the incidence of funding these services tends to fall on those who lack the resources to “shop around.”  Something similar occurs at the international level.  Nations can attract businesses by becoming tax havens.  Ireland is perhaps the most developed nation example.  Multinational firms have the resources to establish outlets in tax favorable environments and extract subsidies and other support.  In an effort to stop this process, the OECD had sponsored talks to harmonize global tax policy.  However, in any tax regime, there are those who benefit from the current situation and see little reason to change, and those who want to shift the incidence of a tax to others.  Europe has been keen on taxing technology, which, in reality, becomes a tax on U.S. firms.  The EU would gain the revenue and the U.S. would mostly bear the incidence of the tax payment.  Needless to say, the U.S. isn’t all that supportive of this effort.  As a result, yesterday, talks broke down.  We would expect the EU to go ahead with digital taxes and the U.S. to treat this move as targeting the U.S. and respond with tariffs and other penalties.
  • The tech industry is coming under increased scrutiny as part of the Communications Decency Act. Initially, in the 1990s, the government was concerned if young tech firms were sued for user content, they would be unable to survive and so the industry was given broad protections against lawsuits from user content.  So, the Communications Decency Act protected the firms from lawsuits.  However, as the firms have grown in size and power, policymakers are taking another look at this issue.  For example, Hawley (R-MO) is introducing legislation that would reduce the protections tied to censorship.  The DOJ is looking at similar measures to reduce immunity.
  • Apple (APPL, 353.94) is facing antitrust investigations from the EU over its app store.
  • Chair Powell finished this second day of Congressional testimony yesterday. What we noted was that the Chair does not want Congress to begin withdrawing fiscal support quite yet.  He wants some form of jobless benefits to continue, and the extension of other measures as well.
  • One of the factors we have been monitoring since 2008 has been the rise of populism which includes opposition to globalization. Within the political parties, this pits the establishment against the populists.  This issue has come up again recently, as the Chamber of Commerce warns against restricting visas for foreign workers, indicating that if businesses can’t get these workers from abroad, they will be forced to bid up wages for local workers…which is exactly the point the populists have been making.
  • USTR Lighthizer weighed in on the WTO yesterday. The body is searching for a new leader and the U.S. clearly wants to shape global trade policy in a more favorable manner.  What we find interesting is that Lighthizer doesn’t want to see the WTO scuttled (as some in Congress do), but does want it to fit trade policy to favor the U.S.
  • Several central banks eased credit yesterday, with the notable exception of Taiwan, who kept policy steady. This morning, the BOE expanded QE but didn’t move rates below zero.  The PBOC, who so far has been reluctant to expand policy stimulus, appears to be moving to boost growth.

China:

Markets:  Insurance companies are reviewing their exposure in collateralized loan obligations (CLOs).  CLOs are usually pooled corporate debt, originated by banks.  CLOs can be separated into different tranches by credit risk and payment priority.  In recent years, insurance companies have been avid buyers of these instruments to take advantage of their higher yield.  However, recently, there has been growing concerns about the credit quality of these instruments.

There is a rising level of delayed loan payments.  Student loans are showing the highest delinquencies.

Economy news:

The country, which hasn’t had a recession since the early 1990s, is clearly in one now.

  • One of the concepts a new analyst always has to learn is that the actual data matters less than the data relative to expectations. Recent data has been far better than forecast.
(Source:  Bloomberg)

This chart shows the economic surprise index from Bloomberg. It measures the difference between the actual data and expectations; the data included are weighted based on their effects on foreign exchange behavior.  What the index is telling us now is the economic data is coming in much better than forecast.  That doesn’t mean the data is good; it means that expectations are so depressed that even soft numbers are still better that deeply depressed forecasts.  What we have observed over the years is that the expectations tend to catch up in a few months and so better future data may not look as good, even with the improvement, because expectations will tend to rise even faster.  This could lead to “disappointing” economic data by autumn.

  • One of the consequences of the lockdowns has been that firms and workers are realizing that they probably don’t need to go to the office to be effective. And, if that’s the case, why would someone stay in a crowded expensive city if they can just as easily live elsewhere.  If this becomes a trend, smaller metropolitan areas may benefit from workers moving to new, smaller cities.
  • The massive expansion of central bank balance sheets has raised fears of inflation. Japan, which has seen ballooning government deficits, remains susceptible to deflation.

View the complete PDF

Weekly Energy Update (June 18, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

Here is an updated crude oil price chart.  The oil market has stabilized at higher levels after April’s historic collapse.

(Source: Barchart.com)

Crude oil inventories were mostly in line with market expectations, with stockpiles rising 1.2 mb compared to forecasts of a 0.8 mb draw.  The SPR added 1.7 mb this week.

In the details, U.S. crude oil production fell 0.6 mbpd to 10.5 mbpd.  Exports were unchanged, while imports fell 0.2 mbpd.  Refining activity rose 0.7%, in line with expectations.  As we have seen in recent weeks, the level of unaccounted-for crude oil remains elevated but did decline this week.

Unaccounted-for crude oil is a balancing item in the weekly energy balance sheet.  To make the data balance, this line item is a plug figure, but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t matter.  This week’s number is -0.7 mbpd.  The fact that the decline fell from 1.0 mbpd to 0.7 mbpd and coincided with a sharp drop in oil production suggests that this number is reflecting falling output.  Simply put, oil production is falling faster than the official data suggest.

(Sources: DOE, CIM)

The above chart shows the annual seasonal pattern for crude oil inventories.  This week’s data showed a modest rise in crude oil stockpiles.  We are on the cusp of the beginning of the seasonal draw for crude oil.  If inventories don’t decline in the coming weeks, oil prices would be vulnerable to a correction.

Based on our oil inventory/price model, fair value is $27.27; using the euro/price model, fair value is $52.74.  The combined model, a broader analysis of the oil price, generates a fair value of $40.24.  We are starting to see a wide divergence between the EUR and oil inventory models.  The weakness we are seeing in the dollar, which we believe may have “legs,” is bullish for crude oil and may overcome the bearish oil inventory overhang.

Although conditions in energy are improving, the recovery is slow.  Refining operations are 20 points below average.

(Sources: DOE, CIM)

The IEA forecast a sharp recovery in oil demand in 2021, which we would expect.  This year’s crude demand is expected to fall 8.1 mbpd but rise 5.7 mbpd next year.

View the PDF

Daily Comment (June 17, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Risk assets have wind in their sails today, in large part due to easing coronavirus lockdowns, signs of rapid economic recovery and continued policy support around the globe.  However, those positives are being offset to some extent by serious new geopolitical tensions between China and India, as well as a worrisome new outbreak in Beijing.  We review all the key news below.

China-India:  It now appears that yesterday’s China-India military clash along the countries’ border in the Himalayan mountains was substantially more lethal than first known.  The Indian government now says 20 of its soldiers died, including not just the three direct fatalities that we reported yesterday, but also 17 more who perished after falling into a deep ravine, or succumbing to the freezing temperatures.  To minimize the risk of a shooting war along the disputed border like the major 1962 confrontation, Chinese and Indian troops patrolling the area don’t carry firearms.  The current tensions have evolved from fistfights last month to attacks with rocks and clubs wrapped in barbed wire this week, resulting in the border troops’ first fatalities in decades.

  • Ultimately, the confrontation can be traced back to the heightened nationalist disposition of Chinese President Xi Jinping and Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi.  Both leaders want to assert their country’s sovereignty to the fullest extent possible, including in disputed areas like the Himalayan border.
    • Xi’s efforts to assert control in Hong Kong, Taiwan and the South China Sea are well known.
    • Modi has also been working to assert India’s control over the Kashmir region.  India’s warming ties with the U.S. and an ill-timed decision to postpone a major military exercise in the area probably also tempted Xi to take a tougher stance.
  • According to Indian sources, several Chinese troops also died in the melee, so a key risk now is that if the Chinese losses were substantial, Xi may find it hard to back down.  On the Indian side, Prime Minister Modi warned today that his country would provide a “befitting reply” if China tried to worsen the situation.
  • As a result of the initial fistfights last month, high-level Chinese and Indian military officers have been meeting to diffuse the situation, and they reportedly met again as recently as yesterday.  Calming tensions and averting a downward spiral in the conflict may require Xi and Modi to swallow some pride and pull back from the precipice.  If they don’t, any shooting conflict in the area would be a major risk to local and global financial markets.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 8,199,838 worldwide, with 444,368 deaths and 3,978,358 recoveries.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 2,137,731, with 116,963 deaths and 583,503 recoveries.  Here is the interactive chart from the Financial Times that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population.

Virology

Economic Impact

United States:  Congress will scrutinize the Trump administration’s aggressive international trade initiatives today, as U.S. Trade Representative Lighthizer, appears before House and Senate committees.  Lighthizer’s testimony will give lawmakers an opportunity to question how the administration’s recent trade deals are playing out.  We also expect them to probe how the administration sees the U.S. economic relationship with other trading partners, including the European Union and the United Kingdom.

United States-United Kingdom:  Even as the U.K. and the EU struggle to develop a post-Brexit trade agreement, with EU demands for a “level playing field” with lower-regulated Britain, it turns out that many British farmers are worried that the U.K.-U.S. trade deal now being negotiated will leave them unable to compete with even lower-regulated U.S. producers.  The result?  They’re also hoping for a “level playing field” with the U.S.

Hungary:  Parliament voted to end a controversial state of emergency that gave Prime Minister Viktor Orban the right to rule by decree, after leaders in the U.S. Congress and the European Union accused him of using the coronavirus pandemic to amass authoritarian-like powers.  However, the legislators left in place some of the measures the government took during the height of its outbreak to concentrate fiscal control over the country’s largely liberal cities.

View the complete PDF

Daily Comment (June 16, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Risk assets are on a tear so far today in response to a blockbuster report on U.S. retail sales suggesting that the economy may be rebounding from the coronavirus crisis more rapidly than expected.  At the same time, officials across the globe continue to signal more monetary and fiscal stimulus, though geopolitical risks are also rising on the China-India border.  As always, we review all the key news below.

United States:  Federal Reserve Chairman Powell will testify before Congress this morning.  While the Fed’s recent forecasts calling for a long post-coronavirus recovery have buttressed expectations that monetary policy will remain extremely accommodative, we’ll be watching closely for any sign that today’s better-than-expected retail sales data may have shifted his views or policy preferences.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 8,058,427 worldwide, with 437,473 deaths and 3,893,780 recoveries.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 2,114,026, with 116,127 deaths and 576,334 recoveries.  Here is the interactive chart from the Financial Times that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population.

Virology

Real Economy

U.S. Policy Response

Foreign Policy Response

  • In a move that would align the ECB’s monetary policies more closely with the Fed’s policies, ECB Executive Director Fabio Panetta offered assurances that his central bank would consider buying “fallen angel” bonds that have recently lost their investment grade rating if necessary to combat the financial fallout from the coronavirus crisis.  Even though the ECB increased the size of its bond-buying program to €1.35 trillion earlier this month, Panetta said it still hasn’t unleashed the “full monty” of its available stimulus.

European Union-United Kingdom:  In their video summit yesterday, top leaders from the U.K. and the EU agreed to redouble their efforts to strike a post-Brexit trade deal in the coming weeks.  The surprisingly cordial post-summit statements from the likes of British Prime Minister Johnson and European Council President Michel are reassuring, but we note that there is still some risk that the two sides won’t come to an agreement and Britain could be facing a sudden stop in its trade with the EU at the end of the year.  Naturally, such a hard break would be negative for European, and particularly British, stocks.

United States-European Union:  Following a preliminary investigation, the European Commission said it has opened two formal antitrust investigations into Apple (AAPL, 342.99).  The investigations will look into the company’s practice of charging media firms’ large commissions to sell their products through its App Store and Apple Pay payment system, even as it uses the information gleaned to promote its own music and book services.  The launch of yet another regulatory move against a major U.S. technology firm is likely to further sour U.S.-EU relations.  The move is also likely to sit badly with Washington because, at the same time, the EU is loosening its state-aid rules to make it easier for member governments to help their own tech start-ups.

United States-China:  As more evidence of cooling U.S.-China tensions, the Department of Commerce yesterday slightly loosened its sanctions against Chinese telecom equipment giant Huawei (002502.SZ, 2.87).  The move will allow U.S. firms to collaborate with Huawei on setting technical standards for 5G and other emerging technologies.  Separately, U.S. Secretary of State Pompeo and Chinese Foreign Minister Yang Jiechi will meet tomorrow in Hawaii.

China-India:  In a dangerous escalation of tensions, the Indian military said three of its soldiers have been killed in clashes with Chinese troops along the countries’ disputed border high in the Himalayan mountains.  The deaths, which were the first since the 1970s in the two countries’ long-running border dispute, came despite multiple rounds of talks by Indian and Chinese military commanders intended to de-escalate tensions.  Those talks had pointed to some easing in the latest round of tensions, but the surprising deaths are a sign that things aren’t going as well as previously thought.  Therefore, the news has weighed on Indian stocks so far today.

North Korea:  In a dramatic display of its frustration with the stalled denuclearization talks and continued sanctions, North Korea has blown up the inter-Korean liaison office near the country’s border with South Korea.  The explosion came just hours after North Korea said via state media that its military would potentially enter border areas that had been disarmed after a 2018 summit between Kim Jong Un and South Korean President Moon Jae-in.

View the complete PDF

Weekly Geopolitical Report – The Geopolitics of the 2020 Election: Part IV (June 15, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady | PDF

In this five-part series on the geopolitics of the 2020 election, we have divided the reports into nine sections. Last week, in Part III, we covered the incidence of establishment policy and the role of social media.  This week, we reveal the sixth and seventh sections; we handicap the race as it stands and discuss how foreign nations are likely to intervene in the election.

Who is Going to Win?
Before we discuss our expectations of the outcome, we want to note that we analyze elections with an eye toward answering two questions.  First, who is going to win? Second, what will they do once elected?  In our primary role of managing money, we cannot afford to allow any political preference to distort our process as that bias could affect investment performance.  And, being well ensconced in the flyover zone of the U.S., our political biases don’t matter anyway.  It’s not as if our analysis affects the actual outcomes of elections.  Our position is that, as a money manager, we want to know what the future looks like, not necessarily root for a certain outcome.  So, here goes.

To forecast the outcome of elections, we have various factors we examine that have signaled the outcomes of previous elections.  These factors are:

  1. Incumbency
  2. The Economy
  3. Polling
  4. Prediction Markets
  5. Base of Support
  6. Money
  7. Social Media Presence

We are also sensitive to the fact that we don’t directly elect presidents; we elect electors to the Electoral College who, in most states, vote for the president based on the majority of votes in that state.[1]  So, our focus is on determining our best estimate of the Electoral College based on polls and available decision markets, along with  economic activity at the state level.

Read the full report


[1] Maine and Nebraska can have split electoral votes.

Daily Comment (June 15, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Good morning and happy Monday!  It’s another risk-off day as financial markets recoil from reports of rising COVID-19 infections.  Our usual commentary on COVID-19 is available.  We update on China and trade issues with the U.K./EU/U.S.  We are watching U.S./Russian relations as Paul Whelan was found guilty of espionage.  We look at the economy and policy news.  Here is what we are watching:

COVID-19:   The number of reported cases is 7,934,277 with 433,919 deaths and 3,789,462 recoveries.   In the U.S., there are 2,094,069 confirmed cases with 115,732 deaths and 561,816 recoveries.  For those who like to keep score at home, the FT has created a nifty interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.

Virology:

China:  Although the virus surge in Beijing is catching most of the attention this morning, overall economic conditions do show improvement.  Consumers continue to show caution, but are spending on big-ticket items.  Also, as usual, China is using investment spending to lift growth.

(Source:  Capital Economics)

This chart shows a steady rebound in the Chinese economy.

SoS Pompeo is meeting with EU foreign ministers to craft a common policy on China.  He is getting some pushback from the EU, which wants to tie cooperation on China with an easing of the trade conflict with Washington.  Of course, Pompeo will try and insist that the issues are separate, but we doubt he will be able to make his case.

Trade:  PM Johnson and EC President von der Leyen will hold video talks today to discuss Brexit.  Johnson is hoping his personal touch will push talks forward while von der Leyen intends to reiterate the EU position on either integration, or a hard border.  At the same time, trade talks between the U.K. and the U.S. will resume today.  There is speculation that Westminster is using talks with the U.S. to extract concessions from the EU; however, Washington could just as easily insist on difficult concessions from the U.K., given its precarious position with the EU.

Russia:  Paul Whelan was found guilty of espionage and sentenced to 16 years in prison.   Although Russia accuses Whelan of spying, his background suggests he probably isn’t one.  He is a corporate security official for a car parts manufacturing firm and was in Russia for a wedding.  He is a Marine, but was discharged under less than stellar circumstances.  We suspect Russia seized Whelan and intends to use him for swap purposes in the future.  We will monitor this case to see if his cause is taken up by the government.

Economy news:  There is growing evidence that the U.S. economy is improving; given how deep the initial decline was, it is almost impossible for things to not look better.  However, it is still good to see signs of life.  Nevertheless, coping with COVID-19 remains a challenge.  We note that manufacturing firms are slow to recover, due to the costs of protective measures and continued infections.

Policy news:  This week, Chair Powell will travel to Capitol Hill to give his semi-annual testimony to Congress.  Given the forecasts from the Fed, we expect him to give testimony that the economy needs additional help.  National Economic Council head Kudlow opposes extending the $600 per week boost to unemployment insurance, but does support a smaller bonus for workers returning to their jobs.  There is worry that the unemployment insurance benefit may be an impediment to returning to work.  At the same time, Peter Navarro says the president wants another stimulus program of at least $2.0 trillion.

View the complete PDF