Daily Comment (April 24, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with new data showing how China’s post-pandemic economic reopening is boosting its imports from other countries, including Australia.  We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including a worrying statement by the Chinese ambassador to France and new research suggesting auto dealers’ markups have been a big driver of U.S. inflation.

China-Australia:  New data shows that China’s imports of Australian coking coal quadrupled in March compared with February, while its imports of Australian thermal coal were 14 times higher.  Chinese coal imports from Australia remain far below their levels from early 2020, when Beijing banned a number of Australian products in retaliation for Canberra’s call to investigate China’s role in the coronavirus pandemic.  Nevertheless, the big jump in the coal trade during March shows that a recent trade thaw between the countries is continuing.

  • Beijing’s willingness to drop its trade barriers against Australia probably aims to ensure sufficient supply as the Chinese economy recovers from the government’s strict pandemic lockdowns.
  • That reflects the extent to which Beijing has prioritized its post-pandemic economic recovery, which is likely to boost global growth and help support the world’s stock markets in the near term. A major beneficiary is likely to be Australia.

China-European Union:  In an interview on French television, Chinese Ambassador Lu Shaye asserted that ex-Soviet republics such as Latvia, Lithuania, and Estonia have no legal status as independent countries.  The three Baltic states, which are all members of the European Union, have summoned their respective Chinese ambassadors to register their complaints.

  • The Chinese government has already shown at least tacit support for Russian President Putin’s illegal invasion of Ukraine. Even though the Chinese foreign ministry today disavowed Ambassador Lu’s assertion, the slip of the tongue suggests at least some Chinese officials are willing to also support Putin’s attitude toward the other formerly Soviet states.
  • Lu’s statement illustrates the increasingly tight policy coordination between Beijing and Moscow. With China and Russia offering each other mutual support, the statement suggests Western countries may no longer be able to differentiate between the two rogue nations.  Growing China-Russia policy coordination is likely to further exacerbate the fracturing of the world into relatively separate geopolitical and economic blocs.

Russia-Ukraine War:  New reports indicate that Ukrainian forces have now established a sustained presence on the east bank of the Dnipro River for the first time since early in Russia’s invasion.  Meanwhile, Yevgeny Prigozhin, head of the Wagner Group of Russian mercenaries, late last week called for the Russian forces to adopt defensive positions ahead of an expected Ukrainian counteroffensive.

  • The reports suggest the Russians may be conserving ammunition or are otherwise paralyzed by the likelihood of new Ukrainian attacks in force with modern Western weapons. If so, it could point to a coming sea change in the conflict, with Ukraine taking the initiative and potentially forcing the Russians to retreat in at least some areas.
  • Separately, officials in Crimea stated that Ukrainian drone boats tried to attack the Russian fleet at Sevastopol, but they were repelled before they could cause any damage. Other Russian reports say a Ukrainian drone aircraft crashed in the forests outside Moscow, but it also apparently caused no damage.

Eurozone:  National Bank of Belgium Governor Pierre Wunsch, who sits on the European Central Bank’s rate-setting committee, warned in an interview that investors are underestimating how high Eurozone interest rates will rise.  Since ECB policymakers want to push down both wage growth and price inflation, Wunsch said the ECB’s benchmark short-term interest rate may have to go to 4.00% at some point, slightly above current market expectations for a peak of 3.75% and well above the current rate of 3.00%.

Switzerland:  First-quarter results show customers of Credit Suisse (CS, $0.8912) yanked about $68.6 billion of deposits from the institution during the first quarter, mostly in the run up to its forced takeover by UBS (UBS, $20.29).  The big drop in business illustrates how severely Credit Suisse was damaged amid the fallout from the March banking crisis in the U.S.  The drop in business means Credit Suisse could be an even bigger challenge for UBS to integrate than previously thought.

United States-Sudan:  As rival Sudanese military groups continue to battle for control of the country, the U.S. military evacuated about 100 Americans yesterday, mostly consisting of U.S. Embassy employees.  The United Kingdom, Germany, and France were among the other countries that also evacuated their citizens.

U.S. Price Inflation:  New research from the Bureau of Labor Statistics shows that dealer markups on new cars were a big driver of price inflation over the last three years.  According to the study, those markups alone accounted for 0.3% to 0.7% of the nearly 16% rise in the consumer price index from the end of 2019 to the end of 2022.  The increase in markups was driven by the fact that auto demand surged after customers got their pandemic stimulus checks, while supply-chain snarls reduced supply.

U.S. Retail Industry:  Yesterday, iconic household goods retailer Bed, Bath, and Beyond (BBBY, $0.2935) filed for bankruptcy protection and said that it expects to eventually close all 360 of its Bed Bath & Beyond stores and all 120 of its Buybuy Baby retail locations.  In the meantime, the bankruptcy filing give the company time to conduct going-out-of-business sales at its physical stores and solicit interest from potential buyers for its remaining assets, such as its branding.  If the firm liquidates as expected, it will leave many large retail buildings vacant across the country, dealing another blow to real estate investors.

U.S. Stock Market:  Washington Service, an insider-trading data provider, said more than 1,000 directors and officers at more than 600 publicly traded firms bought their own company’s stock in March, marking the strongest insider buying since last May.  The strong buying activity, despite last month’s bank crisis, suggests that company officials are looking past the bank issues and remain optimistic about the economy and their corporate prospects.

  • Separately, CBOE (CBOE, $139.51) today is launching a new version of the VIX index of stock market volatility. The new one-day Volatility Index, or VIX1D,  is designed to measure expected volatility in the S&P 500 over the next day of trading, rather than over the next month like the VIX.
  • The launch of the new one-day VIX is consistent with the recent rise of ultra-short option trading, which is not reflected in the traditional VIX.

View PDF

Asset Allocation Bi-Weekly – The Fed’s Employment Surprise (April 24, 2023)

by the Asset Allocation Committee | PDF

This is the tightest labor market for Black Americans in U.S. history. The Black unemployment rate fell to an all-time low in March unsurpassed since the Bureau of Labor Statistics began a separate calculation for Black workers in 1972. Meanwhile, the labor force participation rate for Black Americans hit a two-decade high, and the employment/population ratio for Black people exceeded the ratio for white people for the first time since the Labor Department started tracking the data. The improved employment conditions for Black Americans will be cheered by policymakers at the Federal Reserve, which has long pushed for an inclusive recovery. However, this doesn’t make the Fed’s future interest rate decisions any easier.

In March 2021, the Federal Reserve reframed its maximum employment goal mandate to include minority unemployment. At the time, the Black unemployment rate stood at 9.6% and the Hispanic unemployment rate was 7.7%, both well above the national rate of 6.1%. The disparity led to concerns that the Fed’s tightening would disproportionately impact minority groups. To help justify why he was not ready to lift rates, Fed Chair Jerome Powell argued that high unemployment in minority groups is a sign of slack within the labor market.

Powell’s reluctance to tighten policy made him a target of criticism. Annual inflation as measured by the consumer price index reached 7.5% before the Federal Reserve finally decided to raise rates in March 2022. Powell’s lack of response led to complaints that the central bank had allowed inflation to get out of control. During his renomination hearing, politicians accused Powell of allowing economic inequalities distract from the central bank’s mandate of maintaining price stability. As a result, Powell reassured lawmakers that the Fed was ready to increase borrowing costs as needed to address the rising price pressures.

In contrast to Fed expectations, labor market conditions improved for Black workers even as the central bank tightened policy. In just over a year, the Fed increased its policy rate by 475 bps, its fastest hiking cycle in history. During the period between February 2022 and March 2023, Black unemployment fell from 1.339 million to 1.114 million, for a decline of 16.8%, while total unemployment fell from 5.979 million to 5.839 million, for a decline of 2.3%. In other words, the number of Black unemployed workers fell more than seven times faster than the national rate. Tight policy with lower Black unemployment has added to speculation that the labor market is overly tight.

The improvement in employment conditions for Black workers reflects a secular demographic trend. The white civilian labor force participation rate has steadily declined since 1997, when it peaked at 67.6%. The pandemic accelerated this trend as older white males were reluctant to return to the workforce after being sidelined during lockdowns. Their exit reflects the age divide among racial groups. At 58 years old, the median age for white workers is more than twice that of minority workers, suggesting that many of the white workers likely left the market for good.

The participation gap shows that the Fed may need to rethink its view on minority employment. The lack of white workers means that minority groups will have more job opportunities than in previous generations. Additionally, the shortage of workers should lead to a lower overall unemployment rate and higher wage gains for minority workers. These labor market conditions suggest that the Fed could tighten policy without hurting marginalized groups. As a result, the Fed may now keep rates higher for longer.

However, the recent change in the labor market implies that the Fed’s full employment target may be too high. Its labor tightness gauge, known as the non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment (NAIRU), currently sits at 4.42%, although this may not be accurate. NAIRU is calculated using the historical relationship between the unemployment rate and changes in the rate of inflation. This relationship likely does not account for the acceleration of white workers exiting the labor market due to the pandemic. The actual NAIRU may be lower, so it is possible that the Fed may need to lower rates sooner than the NAIRU would suggest.

The major dropout of white male workers from the job market has benefited minority workers but may complicate Fed policy. Because the drop in Black unemployment reflects a demographic shift, it may not be a valid tool for measuring employment slack in the labor market. That said, employment conditions for Black Americans suggest that the Fed will likely not return rates to zero any time soon. This market environment should be favorable to “value” assets as higher interest rates should dissuade investors from holding riskier, longer-duration securities.

View PDF

Daily Comment (April 21, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning! Today’s Comment begins with a discussion about the growing popularity of generative artificial intelligence. Next, we give our thoughts on crypto’s sudden resurgence this year. Lastly, we review the latest developments in the race for clean technology and how they may impact the rivalry between the U.S. and China.

Artificial Intelligence: Five months after the launch of ChatGPT, generative AI has sparked both concerns from lawmakers and the imagination of Big Tech firms.

  • That said, the largest tech companies are clamoring to join the generative AI market. The innovation is expected to revolutionize the way businesses generate content. Google (GOOGL, $105.91) is using the technology to create sophisticated ad campaigns. Meanwhile, Amazon (AMZN, $103.81) intends to utilize AI in its web services cloud business. After investing $10 billion into parent company Open AI, Microsoft (MSFT, $286.11) plans to integrate artificial intelligence into its employee platform Viva. We suspect more companies will follow this trend. The year-to-date performance of Microsoft’s stock has outpaced the NASDAQ, 20.58% to 16.10%, in a possible sign that investors are confident in AI’s earning potential.
  • AI will likely be a boon to tech companies as long as governments do not stand in the way. These machine learning apps will be able to provide major tech firms with an alternative source of revenue and could improve company efficiency. However, if the technology leads workers to being displaced, lawmakers may implement regulations to limit the use of these algorithms. The biggest winners of the growing popularity of AI may be the semiconductor industry, as special chips will be needed to handle the large amounts of data required for training and interfacing with AI applications.

Is Crypto Cool Again? Investors have flocked to digital currencies despite fears of a regulatory crackdown as some traders view crypto as an alternative safe-haven asset.

  • Governments are studying ways to prevent speculation within the crypto market from spreading into the economy. Lawmakers in the European Union just approved a comprehensive regulatory framework for the crypto industry. Meanwhile, the United Kingdom is set to roll out its own set of rules over the next few months. The push to regulate digital currencies is due to concerns that the multi-trillion-dollar industry is rife with scams. During his testimony before Congress, U.S. Security and Exchange Commission Chair Gary Gensler testified that he has never seen an industry so non-compliant with laws.
  • Crypto has come back into focus with investors as they look to hedge against exposure to the U.S. dollar. Bitcoin has gotten off to a strong start in 2023. The most actively traded cryptocurrency is up 69.72% since January, significantly outpacing the U.S. dollar index, which is down 1.56% in the same period. The rush into digital currencies is largely related to the speculation that the Fed will end its hiking cycle before it has successfully tamed inflation. Additionally, the strong returns of crypto may be a reflection of investor wariness of U.S. dollar dominance.
  • The surge into digital currencies will likely be bumpy but may be suitable for an investor with a substantially high risk tolerance. The strong performance of crypto is likely being driven by a relatively small group of traders. For example, cryptocurrency exchange volume, by month, peaked at over $2 trillion in May 2021, less than a third of the $6.6 trillion in volume during a typical forex trading day in 2019. As a result, the crypto market has a lot of liquidity concerns for those traders looking to invest in digital assets. That said, as the world moves toward deglobalization, we suspect that crypto may benefit as countries look to diversify away from the greenback.

Climate Change Competition: Competition for market share in the renewable tech industry is heating up.

  • The Chilean government has announced its plan to nationalize the country’s lithium industry. As the world’s second-largest producer of the metal, Chile has decided to seize control of this key mineral resource to prevent the country’s resources from falling into foreign hands. Chile is the latest country to seek greater control over lithium. Last year, Mexico nationalized its lithium sector, while Zimbabwe banned unprocessed lithium exports. Meanwhile, Indonesia is expected to restrict the export of battery-related commodities. The move to protect key renewable commodities is a reflection of the growing importance that green technology will play over the next few years.
  • Additionally, there is a growing turf war among EV automakers as new firms begin looking to expand into foreign markets. On Thursday, Tesla (TSLA, $162.99) announced another round of sweeping price cuts for some of its vehicles as it looks to compete with rivals entering the space. The move was shunned by investors, which led the automaker to adjust the prices of its higher-end vehicles but appears to be a part of the company’s long-run strategy to remain competitive. Meanwhile, motor shows in Shanghai have allowed Chinese automakers to display advancements in vehicle and battery technology. The country is already the world’s biggest market for electric vehicles but there are expectations that Chinese firms may look to sell to other countries. After overtaking Germany in 2022, China is now set to dethrone Japan as the top exporter of cars in terms of volume later this year.
  • The fight over clean energy supremacy will play a major role in the rivalry between the U.S. and China. Renewable technology is one area where China performs better than anyone else. Despite being the world’s top carbon emissions emitter, China has been at the forefront of green technology development. The government has invested significantly in its clean technology and is currently better positioned to capitalize on the global pivot toward sustainable energy. Many U.S. renewable companies use Chinese technology in their products, which explains why the Biden administration has been so adamant in its quest for automakers to source materials from firms operating in North America. Although U.S.-China cooperation is ideal for these countries to meet their climate goals, it doesn’t seem likely at this juncture.
    • If we are correct, governments will be reluctant to completely move away from fossil fuels as the green energy transition is going to take longer than lawmakers realize.

View PDF

Daily Comment (April 20, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning! Today’s Comment begins with a discussion about concerns regarding bank lending. Next, we explain why stubborn inflation has led to greater scrutiny of the central banks. Lastly, we give our thoughts on supply chain efficiencies and the performance of the U.S. dollar as tensions between the U.S. and China continue to escalate.

Lending Sentiment Sours: The latest earnings report has added to concerns that a credit crunch is imminent.

  • Tightening credit conditions raises the likelihood of a hard landing. The Federal Reserve is expected to raise its target range for interest rates to 5.00%-5.25% in May. The Fed’s decision to increase borrowing costs will raise transaction expenses for bank dealmaking and reduce the value of bond holdings, thus weighing on the profitability of financial institutions. The Fed’s new emergency facility did relieve pressure on the regional banks from needing to lift rates in order to keep borrowers, but banks may still be reluctant to lend due to interest rate uncertainty. As a result, businesses and consumers may be unable to obtain loans when they need them as the economy slows.

It’s Getting Sticky: Stubborn inflation adds to concerns that the central banks are not finished tightening monetary policy.

  • The lack of progress toward price stability has hurt the credibility of the central banks. The current board of the Reserve Bank of Australia is set to lose responsibility for setting interest rates because it has come under scrutiny for its poor guidance. The task will be given to a separate board within the RBA that will specialize in managing monetary policy. Several months before it started its most aggressive tightening cycle in three decades, the RBA had stated that a rate hike was unlikely before 2024. Additionally, its inflation forecast failed to detect the acceleration in price pressures. The revamp of the central bank is expected to take place in July of this year after the RBA Act is amended.
  • Australia is not the only country with a central bank currently under pressure. The Bank of England, the European Central Bank, and the Fed have all moderated expectations of a pause due to higher-than-expected inflation. Their inability to succeed in reining in price pressures may be related to demand-side inflation. The chart below breaks down inflation by demand, supply, and ambiguous contributors, as determined by the U.S. personal consumption expenditure price index. The series suggests that improvements in the supply chain are the primary drivers in the recent decline of price pressures.
    • The chart may reflect issues with containing service-related inflation figures.

  • A tight labor market and a resilient economy have given central banks more leeway to increase benchmark interest rates. The Federal Reserve Beige Book, which provides anecdotal information on economic conditions within regional Fed districts, showed that the country is not currently in a recession. Meanwhile, better-than-expected growth from China has boosted confidence that a global recession is not imminent. These positive signs have forced market participants to push back their expectations of a shift in central bank policy. The latest CME FedWatch Tool now forecasts a Fed pause or cut in interest rates to take place at the September meeting, a month later than investors were predicting last week. Overnight index swaps for the EUR and GBP have also shown a similar trend.
    • That said, we believe that many central banks will be finished hiking rates by the third quarter.

 The Great Decoupling: Supply chain efficiency and the dominance of the U.S. dollar may be casualties as the world splits into separate blocs.

  • Companies are accepting that they may have to prioritize supply chain resiliency over efficiency as a way to hedge against geopolitical risks from rising U.S.-China tensions. India appears to be an attractive destination target. A day after opening its first store in India, Apple (AAPL, $167.63) CEO Tim Cook met with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi to discuss plans for future investment in the country. The iPhone maker is expected to double or triple its investment expenditure in Asia’s second-biggest economy which could pave the way for more companies to follow suit.
  • The decision to broaden supply chains comes amidst heightened rhetoric from the U.S. regarding China. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen is expected to warn Beijing of a U.S. response if it continues unfair trade practices. Her remarks will reinforce the notion that China and the U.S. are headed for a divorce as the two sides grapple with disagreements over human rights, support for Russia, and accusations of industrial espionage. Although U.S.-China trade increased to an all-time high last year, it is now showing signs of slowing.

Source: Investors.com

  • Frictions between the U.S. and China will lead to a decline in the usage of the dollar for global trade. Beijing has already gotten a head start in this process as its foreign exchange reserves have declined from nearly $4 trillion in 2014 to slightly above $3 trillion as of March of this year. Meanwhile, Brazilian President Lula has called on emerging economy countries to reduce their reliance on the U.S. greenback for trade. We suspect countries that align with China will be persuaded to use other currencies for trade, especially if they want access to the world’s second-largest economy. If we are correct, the U.S. dollar should be headed toward a secular decline against other global currencies.

View PDF

Weekly Energy Update (April 20, 2023)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA | PDF

After gapping last week, prices are consolidating.

(Source: Barchart.com)

Commercial crude oil inventories fell 4.6 mb compared to the forecast draw of 0.9 mb.  The SPR fell 1.6 mb, putting the total draw at 6.2 mb.

In the details, U.S. crude oil production was unchanged at 12.3 mbpd.  Exports rose 1.8 mbpd, while imports rose 0.1 mbpd.  Refining activity rose 1.7% to 91.0% of capacity.

(Sources: DOE, CIM)

The above chart shows the seasonal pattern for crude oil inventories.  After accumulating oil inventory at a rapid pace into mid-February, injections first slowed and have since declined, putting storage levels in line with seasonal norms.

Fair value, using commercial inventories and the EUR for independent variables, yields a price of $56.81.  The recent actions of OPEC+ are clearly designed to prevent this sort of price from emerging.

Since the SPR is being used, to some extent, as a buffer stock, we have constructed oil inventory charts incorporating both the SPR and commercial inventories.  With another round of SPR sales set to happen, the combined storage data will again be important.

Total stockpiles peaked in 2017 and are now at levels last seen in 2001.  Using total stocks since 2015, fair value is $94.11.

Market News:

 Geopolitical News:

  • Saudi Crown Prince Salman announced that 4% of Saudi Aramco (2222, SAR, 34.65), worth about $80 billion, will be moved to the nation’s sovereign wealth fund. The reason is to support the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s economic diversification.  Although the amount doesn’t necessarily suggest a rapid move away from fossil fuels, the “direction of travel” suggests less investment in oil and gas, and more in other parts of the economy.
  • The IEA admits that the price cap on Russian oil has been violated. Russian oil exports are now exceeding prewar levels with nearly all of the oil flows going to China and India.  Russia is also apparently selling oil in the Far East that is being exported by tanker, but this voyage is short enough to avoid insurance, which means that buyers can violate the price cap.  The U.S. is warning that it will begin cracking down on this practice.
  • Russia has surprisingly little domestic oil storage. Because of this lack of storage capacity, it must sell most of what it produces.  The country has announced that it will build new storage facilities which will give it more flexibility for timing sales.
  • China is proposing new natural gas pipelines from Kazakhstan to diversify its sources of the product.
  • Given China’s dominance in renewable energy and EV components, Chinese companies are often participants in foreign investment projects. However, due to deteriorating relations between China and the West, political resistance to these projects is growing.

 Alternative Energy/Policy News:

  View PDF

Daily Comment (April 19, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with several new initiatives in European economic policy, including subsidies for semiconductor manufacturing and a tax on imports tied to greenhouse gas emissions.  We next review a range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including a report on consumer price inflation in Britain that has raised concerns about more interest-rate hikes in the advanced countries.

EU Industrial Policy:  The European Commission formally unveiled its proposed “EU Chips Act” yesterday, which would provide some €43 billion ($47 billion) in subsidies and other assistance for semiconductor manufacturers operating in the EU.  The support represents an attempt to compete with the subsidies in last year’s U.S. Chips Act and could make the EU more self-sufficient in both commoditized and advanced computer chips.  The proposed program also illustrates how it has become more acceptable for governments to use active “industrial policy” to offer protections and backing for certain industries.

EU Environmental Regulation:  The EU parliament approved a first-of-its-kind law yesterday that will tax imports into the bloc based on the greenhouse gases emitted to make them.  The new legislation is designed to make sure that EU manufactured goods are not put at a competitive disadvantage by imports from countries with looser, less costly environmental regulations.

Eurozone Bank Health:  Concerns are growing ahead of the late-June expiration of the European Central Bank’s pandemic bank-support program known as “targeted longer-term refinancing operations,” or TLTROs.  Expiration of the program will require banks in the Eurozone to repay hundreds of billions of euros back to the ECB, replacing them with more costly sources of funding.  Many banks, especially some in Italy, may find it challenging to raise the required liquidity.

United Kingdom:  The March consumer price index came in 10.1% higher than in the same month one year earlier, marking a modest deceleration from the 10.4% rise in the year to February but dashing expectations that inflation would finally fall into single digits.  Excluding the volatile food and energy components, the core CPI in March was up 6.2% on the year, just as it was in February.  The report has rekindled concerns about continued high inflation and additional interest-rate hikes throughout the advanced countries in the coming months, which are weighing on global stock markets so far this morning.

Turkey:  An in-depth article in the Wall Street Journal yesterday linked the massive devastation and loss of life from the country’s February earthquakes to a systemic weakening of building regulations as President Erdoğan relied on construction to goose the economy and boost his political support over the last two decades.

  • The article shows that the government’s deliberate easing of building rules and failure to prosecute rule-breaking likely resulted in tens of thousands of building collapses and deaths during the quakes.
  • Since Erdoğan is now so closely identified with the construction boom of the last two decades, the scandal about building regulations is a key threat to his re-election prospects when the nation goes to the polls on May 14.

India:  The United Nations Population Division released new data today showing that India has now overtaken China as the world’s most populous country.  Reflecting its higher birth rate, India’s estimated population now stands at 1.428 billion, while China, with its low birth rate, has an estimated population of 1.425 billion.  Meanwhile, technology giant Apple (AAPL, $166.47) opened its first retail store in India yesterday, further expanding its commitment to the country after its recent opening of manufacturing facilities there.  The population data and the move by Apple are being taken as further validation of India’s increasingly attractive investment prospects compared with China.

Mexico:  The Supreme Court invalidated part of a law pushed by President Andrés Manuel López Obrador last year that put the country’s national guard under the military’s control.  The ruling is a strong rebuke to the president’s penchant for putting more government functions under the control of the military and means that the national guard must now remain under civilian control.  While the president argues correctly that the Mexican military is one of the country’s most efficient and competent institutions, putting more government functions in its control raises concerns about transparency and whether the military is being given jobs for which it is poorly equipped, including local policing.

China-Taiwan-United States:  Admiral John Aquilino, the head of U.S. Indo-Pacific command, said in testimony before Congress yesterday that he would not join his fellow top military officials in speculating about when China might try to seize control of Taiwan and spark a war with the U.S.  However, Aquilino did say the Defense Department and defense industry need to accelerate their efforts to boost U.S. military power in order to deter China.  We continue to believe that increased geopolitical frictions will boost global defense spending in the coming years, presenting attractive opportunities for investors, but Aquilino’s statement matches our concern that the U.S. military buildup still appears to lack urgency.

U.S. Financial Regulation:  In testimony before the House Financial Services Committee yesterday, Securities and Exchange Commissioner Gensler was heavily criticized by Republicans for his efforts to crack down on the cryptocurrency markets.  In response, Gensler stated that crypto companies flout regulations worse than any firms he has ever seen.  The exchange points to continued muddled enforcement efforts by the SEC and prolonged political pushback in Congress.

U.S. Media Industry:  Yesterday, Fox Corporation (FOX, $31.20) agreed to pay $787.5 million to settle its legal conflict with Dominion Voting Systems just before the start of a trial on the voting-machine company’s allegations that it was defamed by Fox News after the 2020 presidential election.  The settlement avoids a court case that could have ultimately clarified and tightened the legal responsibilities of media companies in potential defamation cases.  All the same, the big payment to settle the case is a shot over the bow of media firms and could make them more cautious about how they report on political news going forward.

View PDF

Daily Comment (April 18, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with a couple of big-picture views on the global economy and a key commodity market.  We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including stronger-than-expected economic growth in China and a range of developments in U.S. economic policy.

Global Fracturing and Inflation:  European Central Bank President Lagarde warned in a speech yesterday that if the world continues to fracture into relatively separate geopolitical and economic blocs, global consumer prices would be boosted by about 5% in the short run and about 1% over the long term due to less efficient supply chains.  She also warned that global fracturing would threaten the position of the U.S. dollar as the world’s key reserve currency.

  • Clearly, Lagarde has been reading the many analyses Confluence has been publishing on this topic. Her analysis is consistent with our view that as the world breaks into U.S.-led and China-led blocs, shortened supply chains and increased geopolitical tensions will lead to higher costs, increased inflation, and rising interest rates.
  • The evolving U.S.-led bloc is likely to look much like today’s group of rich, advanced, highly industrialized countries with a few closely related emerging markets but will have more manufacturing “brought home” to that bloc from China and its bloc. We suspect companies will eventually adjust to this new world, meaning equities and commodities are likely to remain attractive.  However, higher inflation and interest rates will likely contribute to the beginnings of a long-lasting bear market in bonds.

Global Copper Market:  At this week’s World Copper Conference in Santiago, Chile, a key topic of discussion is the worsening outlook for the metal’s supply/demand balance.  Driven by new construction and soaring use in green technologies such as electric vehicles, global demand for copper is expected to rise to 36.6 million metric tons per year by 2031.  However, because of lackluster investment at the present time, which is driven in part by restrictions in South America, global output is expected to grow slowly to just 30.1 million metric tons per year.

  • Analysts expect the supply shortfall to drive prices much higher over the coming years.
  • We agree that tepid investment today is likely to boost prices for a range of commodities in the coming years. We think geopolitical tensions and the fracturing of the world into relatively separate blocs will also tend to drive values higher.  We therefore continue to believe commodities will offer attractive returns in the coming years, once we get through any short-term softness due to the impending recession in the U.S.

China:  As we flagged in our Comment yesterday, first-quarter gross domestic product was up a relatively healthy 4.5% from the same period one year earlier, beating expectations and marking a strong acceleration from the growth of 2.2% in the year ending in the fourth quarter of 2022.  The acceleration in the first quarter came largely from stronger consumption spending as the economy continues to recover from its previous Zero-COVID restrictions, but it also benefited from increased government infrastructure investment and rebounding exports.

  • China’s growth in the first quarter puts it on track to meet the government’s target of having GDP expand about 5% in 2023.
  • The rebound in Chinese GDP growth will likely give a boost to global economic activity and commodity prices, at least to the extent that it relies on investment and imports. However, some economists are concerned that rebounding consumption spending, especially on services, will mute the benefit of economic growth outside of China.

Germany:  The country’s last three nuclear electricity plants were shut off over the weekend pursuant to a law passed two decades ago and strong anti-nuclear protests over the last decade.  The shutdowns come despite an energy crunch touched off by Russia’s invasion of Ukraine last year.  The shutdowns are expected to leave German and European energy supplies more volatile and precarious going into the future.

Saudi Arabia-Iran-Israel:  Reflecting the recent China-facilitated rapprochement between Iran and Saudi Arabia, the Iranian government said it has invited Saudi King Salman bin Abdulaziz to visit the country in the near future.  The invitation comes as Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi has already accepted an invitation to visit Saudi Arabia, although no date has been set for his visit.  Meanwhile, senior Saudi officials on Sunday met with leaders of the Palestinian militant group Hamas, which is backed by Iran, to discuss renewing their ties for the first time since they were put on ice in 2007.

  • The rapprochement with Iran threatens Israel’s strategy of strengthening ties with the Saudis and other Sunni Muslim states to form a bulwark against Shiite Muslim Iran in the Persian Gulf region.
  • Saudi Arabia’s renewed ties with Hamas also threaten to unleash new terrorist attacks directly on Israel.

Ecuador:  In an interview, conservative President Guillermo Lasso said he would dissolve the country’s congress and call new elections if the leftist-dominated legislature tries to impeach him on what he called trumped-up corruption charges.  However, opinion polls indicate Lasso only has the support of about 22% of the population, and it appears his days in office are numbered.  The result could be a constitutional crisis and lead to further political instability in Ecuador, potentially leaving it as yet another major Latin American commodity producer taken over by the left.

China-United States:  Yesterday, U.S. prosecutors charged dozens of Chinese security officers and their associates in absentia for running thousands of fake social-media personas to discredit U.S. policies.  They also arrested and charged two ethnic Chinese for setting up a secret Chinese police station in New York City to harass Chinese dissidents.  Along with last week’s revelation that a former U.S. Navy sailor helped disseminate classified documents posted online by an Air National Guardsman, yesterday’s charges highlight how rogue-state officials and their domestic sympathizers are active in U.S. cyberspace and on U.S. territory.  Reports today indicate the FBI is investigating the Navy sailor involved in the further dissemination of the leaked intel documents.

  • Naturally, that realization is likely to further worsen U.S. relations with China and Russia.
  • It could also potentially spark moves to root out any domestic “fifth column” of China and Russia sympathizers.

U.S. Fiscal Policy:  Even though House Speaker McCarthy hasn’t gotten the Republicans he leads to agree on a budget proposal for the upcoming federal fiscal year, he said in a speech yesterday that the party would soon pass legislation linking a rise in the federal debt limit to cuts in spending.  According to McCarthy, the majority of Republicans would only agree to a rise in the debt limit if it were linked to a limit on federal spending, a claw back of COVID-19 aid, and a requirement that people work to receive federal benefits.

  • President Biden has signaled that he is willing to negotiate on federal spending levels, but he rejects linking those talks to the debt limit.
  • McCarthy’s speech is a reminder that federal fiscal policy and the risk of a default remain a risk for the financial markets, even if the most likely scenario is a last-minute compromise.

U.S. Environmental Policy:  The Treasury Department yesterday released an updated list of electric vehicle models that qualify for tax credits under last year’s Inflation Reduction Act.  Because of tightened rules on pricing and the country of origin for key components, the list now includes just 16 models from U.S. brands.  The pared down list illustrates the impact of the law’s preference for North American-made vehicles and technology, which has strained relations between the U.S. and some of its allies.

U.S. Banking Regulation:  New research drawing on public filings indicates that most U.S. banks haven’t been hedging their exposure to rising interest rates.  For example, the research shows that only about 6% of bank assets have recently been hedged with interest-rate swaps.  The findings suggest that the rise in interest rates that helped bring down two key banks last month could have also left other institutions at risk.  We continue to watch carefully for signs that other banks could be in trouble or that financial stresses will crimp bank lending and help push the economy into recession.

U.S. Labor Market:  Privately held consulting giants McKinsey & Co. and Bain & Co. are reportedly delaying the start dates for new MBA hires to as late as April 2024, in some cases paying them thousands of dollars to work for a charity for a few months before starting their consulting jobs.

  • The actions by McKinsey and Bain reflect concerns about an impending recession and slowdown in business. They also serve as a reminder that as recession nears, demand will likely soften even for expensive workers in business services.
  • Separately, UPS (UPS, $193.29) and the Teamsters union begin negotiations this week for a new five-year contract covering some 330,000 employees before the current contract expires on July 31. Because the number of covered employees is so large, the negotiations and resulting contract could have significant implications for overall U.S. wage rates and labor market conditions.

View PDF

Bi-Weekly Geopolitical Report – U.S. Intelligence Sharing as a Tool of International Relations (April 17, 2023)

Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA | PDF

Why should investors care about international relations?  Why should they pay attention as great powers jostle for influence and dominance across the globe?  One simple answer is that the global economy tends to grow better when there is one dominant country or “hegemon” that provides security, order, effective instruments for trade and investment, and perhaps even a common culture or set of values.  Since World War II, investors have benefited from relatively fast and stable economic growth as the United States provided those public goods in its role as the world’s “Benevolent Hegemon.”  Investors in the U.S. have enjoyed especially strong, risk-adjusted returns.

But as we’ve written before, the military, economic, and social costs of hegemony have now given the U.S. pause.  Whether the U.S. ultimately abandons its role as hegemon, and how fast it might do so, will have major implications for investors.  In this report, we look at one way U.S. officials today are trying to maintain their influence on other countries without the big economic costs they’ve accepted in the past.  As always, we will also examine the investment ramifications of that strategy.

Read the full report

Don’t miss the accompanying Geopolitical Podcast, available on our website and most podcast platforms: Apple | Spotify | Google

Daily Comment (April 17, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with an apparent assassination attempt against Japanese Prime Minister Kishida.  Although Kishida escaped unharmed, the security failure raises concerns for leaders attending the Group of Seven summit in Japan next month.  We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including signs that China’s first-quarter economic growth will come in healthy when it’s released tomorrow and new evidence suggesting the U.S. is about to experience a rebound in manufacturing activity.

Japan:  Prime Minister Kishida was apparently the target of an attempted explosives attack as he prepared to deliver a stump speech for a local by-election near the southwestern city of Osaka on Saturday.  The assailant’s pipe bomb landed just feet from Kishida, but security personnel whisked him away before it exploded, and the prime minister was not injured.

  • Coming just nine months after Former Prime Minister Abe was assassinated by an assailant with a homemade gun, the incident on Saturday points to continuing gaps in the security for Japanese leaders.
  • Moreover, the incident raises questions about the security environment for the global leaders who will attend a G7 summit in Hiroshima next month.

China:  Numerous signs indicate that tomorrow’s report on first-quarter gross domestic product will be in line with the government’s goal of 5% growth this year.  New data today showed that March new home prices were up 0.5% month-over-month, accelerating from a rise of 0.3% in February and marking their strongest increase in almost two years.  The People’s Bank of China also kept its one-year medium-term lending facility interest rate unchanged at 2.75% today rather than cutting it, and last week the government announced better-than-expected export growth.  Continued economic recovery from China’s pandemic lockdowns will likely be positive for global stocks and commodity prices, at least in the near term.

Turkey:  National oil champ Turkish Petroleum will begin shipments this week from its new Sakarya gas field, just three years after discovering the deposit.  According to President Erdoğan, supplies from the new gas field will help slash energy costs for Turkish consumers and businesses.  The timing of the announcement was probably driven by President Erdoğan, who is at risk of losing his bid for a new term in office in the May 14 elections.

  • Erdoğan’s electoral strategy is to tout his achievements in completing key economic projects and making Turkey a stronger player in global politics.
  • Last week, Erdoğan also presided at a ribbon-cutting for the Turkish navy’s new flagship, the TCG Anadolu.  The landing ship, which can carry helicopters and armed drones, is Turkey’s largest ever naval ship.

Poland-Hungary-Ukraine:  Faced with a glut of imports from Ukraine due to the European Union’s policies to help the country deal with the Russian invasion, the Polish and Hungarian governments have announced a temporary ban on Ukrainian grain despite EU warnings that they could be violating the bloc’s trade policy.  The grain shipments were supposed to be re-exported to the Middle East and Africa but have been bottled up in Poland and Hungary due to a lack of truck and train capacity.

Russia-Ukraine War:  Reports indicate a Russian power station in the southern border region of Belgorod was knocked off line by an apparent Ukrainian drone strike.  Ukraine has staged numerous attacks on military sites within Russia, but today’s strike seems to mark an expansion of its attacks.  By shutting off power to Russian citizens, it broadens the impact of the attacks, potentially undermining Russian citizens’ confidence in the war effort and perhaps sparking stronger retaliation by the Russian military.

United Kingdom:  As the West continues to worry about China’s stranglehold on the rare minerals needed for future energy technologies, British geologists have identified eight sites in the U.K. that have the right geology to potentially yield 18 key metals and minerals, including cobalt and lithium.  The mapping marks the first time the U.K. has systematically identified geological potential for the resources needed to produce electric car batteries, semiconductors, and wind turbines.  The sites will still need to be explored, and any commercially viable deposits would probably take more than a decade to develop.

Sudan:  Over the weekend, military forces led by two rival generals began attacking each other in the capital Khartoum and elsewhere in the country, dashing hopes that the country could continue its transition to democracy after the country’s armed forces toppled its dictator in a 2019 coup.  Continued political instability opens the country to further interference from Russia and other countries that would want to take advantage of its strategic location in northeastern Africa.

U.S. Intelligence Leak:  New reporting indicates the classified U.S. intelligence documents posted by Air National Guardsman Jack Teixeira in his chat room were further disseminated by a pro-Russian blogger who had been in the U.S. Navy until late last year.  The revelation adds to concerns that the U.S. military could be infiltrated with Russia sympathizers who are willing to undermine the U.S. and potentially put U.S. military and government personnel at risk.  Such concerns could encourage even stronger U.S. government action against authoritarian states such as China, Russia, and Iran.

U.S. Industrial Policy:  New research by the Financial Times suggests the U.S. is about to enjoy a manufacturing boom sparked by the $400 billion or so in subsidies provided in last year’s Inflation Reduction Act and CHIPS Act.  The research identifies more than 75 large-scale factory commitments that will take advantage of the laws, which will create about 82,000 jobs.

  • The research is consistent with our view that deglobalization, increased defense spending, and Washington’s new embrace of industrial policy will prompt significant re-industrialization in the U.S., creating new investment opportunities while also imposing such costs as higher interest rates and the risk of malinvestment.
  • Even though Republicans largely opposed the two industrial policy measures and continue to criticize them, the analysis indicates more than 75% of the investments identified so far will be in Republican-held congressional districts, where they will create some 58,000 jobs. If true, that could eventually boost Republican support for the laws and ensure they have political support going forward.

U.S. Bank Regulation:  According to officials attending the International Monetary Fund’s annual meeting last week, the banking crises last month in the U.S. and Europe could prompt the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision to try enforcing its strictest regulations on small and mid-sized U.S. banks that are currently exempt.  The possible change would expand the Basel Committee’s reach beyond those that are just “internationally active” to those that are “internationally relevant.”  Such a move could impose greater compliance costs on smaller banks and reduce their profitability and lending activity.

View PDF