Daily Comment (July 8, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Despite rising stock markets overseas, sentiment in the U.S. markets today seems finely balanced between optimism about post-virus economic reopenings and accommodative policies on the one hand and the reality of resurgent infections and renewed lockdowns in some locales on the other hand.  We review all the key news below.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 11,856,991 worldwide, with 544,871 deaths and 6,473,170 recoveries.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 2,996,333, with 131,481 deaths and 936,476 recoveries.  Here is the interactive chart from the Financial Times that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population.

Virology

Economic Impact

European Union:  ECB President Lagarde said her ongoing review of the central bank’s operations will examine how they can be made “greener.” This includes potentially shifting its massive asset purchases to sell off obligations issued by carbon-intensive companies and buying more obligations issued by less carbon-intensive firms.  Separately, she also tried to tamp down expectations that the EU’s proposed €750-billion coronavirus recovery, including common debt issuance, would be approved at a summit to be held on July 18.  According to Lagarde, approval of the plan will probably come closer to the end of July.

EU-Germany:  The German central bank will reportedly accept the positive findings of a finance ministry and parliamentary review of the ECB’s massive bond-buying program. This suggests the program won’t be tripped up by the German constitutional court’s ruling in May, stating that government officials must review the economic and financial costs of the bond purchases.

United States-China:  The U.S. is imposing visa restrictions on Chinese officials involved in Tibet policy.  This is the latest rise in tension with Beijing, as the Trump administration increasingly uses immigration measures as a tool to target China.

Mexico:  The Jalisco New Generation Cartel, which dominates the trade in fentanyl and methamphetamines, has become Mexico’s most powerful criminal organization, eclipsing the more famous Sinaloa Cartel. Perhaps most worrying, the Jalisco Cartel has made it a hallmark to attack Mexican security forces and public servants directly, making it the biggest danger to the country’s, at times, fragile stability and further complicating the country’s investment environment.

View the complete PDF

Daily Comment (July 7, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Risk assets are under pressure this morning in part because of multiple reports pointing to the reimposition of coronavirus lockdowns in some locales and the risk of halting, prolonged economic recovery.  On top of that, geopolitical tensions between the Western democracies and China and Russia remain high.  We outline all the key news below.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 11,648,268 worldwide, with 538,828 deaths and 6,328,930 recoveries.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 2,938,750, with 130,310 deaths and 924,128 recoveries.  Here is the interactive chart from the Financial Times that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population.

Virology

Economic Impact

Foreign Policy Response

China-India-Bhutan:  Chinese and Indian troops started to withdraw from disputed areas along the two countries’ Himalayan border, following talks between senior diplomats and military commanders to calm tensions.  The moves should help end the fistfights between the two sides, which caused at least 20 deaths among Indian troops last month.  However, Indian media reports say China has now begun designating part of the border with Bhutan as disputed.  The new pressure may be a way to keep pressure on New Delhi, which is a key Bhutanese ally.  In any case, Chinese territorial aggressiveness appears alive and well, which will keep up geopolitical tensions in the region.

China-Germany:  Chancellor Merkel is facing criticism in Germany for failing to take a tough line on China over the new national security law it has imposed on Hong Kong, with politicians from both opposition and government parties accusing her of being too soft on Beijing.

China-United States:  The U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the Business Roundtable and other business groups issued a public letter urging the U.S. and China to fully implement their January “Phase I” trade deal.  The letter reflects growing concern that Chinese purchases of U.S. goods are running far short of the pace required under the deal.  China has made decent progress with its ramp-up of U.S. agricultural goods, but that probably just reflects President Xi’s belief that President Trump would be so satisfied with increased farm exports that he would overlook China’s failure to implement other parts of the deal.  That could be a miscalculation, as China’s failure to meet its obligations could generate enough anger among U.S. conservatives that Trump would walk away from the deal.  A formal breakdown of the deal would signal even worse U.S.-China tensions and more trade conflict, which would likely be very negative for global risk assets.

United Kingdom-Russia:  Britain has imposed sanctions on more than two dozen Russian individuals in connection with the 2009 death of lawyer Sergei Magnitsky, signaling it may become more active in imposing U.S.-style economic sanctions against authoritarian regimes for their destabilizing acts.  The Kremlin said it would hit the U.K. with “reciprocal measures” in response.

Russia:  An adviser to the chief of Russia’s Roskosmos state space agency, Ivan Safronov Jr., has been detained on a charge of high treason for passing classified military information to an unspecified NATO country.

France:  As part of his cabinet reshuffle, President Macron has promoted a young lieutenant, Gérald Darmanin, to replace Interior Minister Christopher Castaner, who was criticized for his handling of the anti-government gilets jaunes protests last year.  More recently, the police also lost faith in Castaner for not doing enough to protect them from criticism by Black Lives Matters protesters.  In other aspects of the reshuffle, Finance Minister Le Maire kept his job, as did the foreign, defense and health ministers.  However, with the post-coronavirus economic recovery central to Macron’s re-election hopes, the president named new labor and environment chiefs.

View the complete PDF

Daily Comment (July 6, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Good morning, and happy Monday!  U.S. equity futures and global equity markets are moving higher this morning led by China after comments in the state media suggested it’s good to buy stocks.  We update the pandemic news.  China has several news items of note.  Overseas, we have a new PM in France and elections in Croatia.  Here are the details:

COVID-19: The number of reported cases is 11,470,637 with 534,784 deaths and 6,193,538 recoveries.  In the U.S., there are 2,888,729 confirmed cases with 129,947 deaths and 906,763 recoveries.  For those who like to keep score at home, the FT has created a nifty interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.   The latest R0 data suggest the majority of states are seeing a rise in the pace of infections.  Additionally, this link gives a single source for the testing progress of treatments and vaccines.

Virology:

  • Temperature checks are the most common way that companies screen customers or employees. However, smell checks, where the person is asked to determine a scent may be more effective.  The most common symptom of COVID-19 is a loss of the sense of smell.
  • Although studies are in the early stages, vitamin D may prove to offer at least some protection against COVID-19.
  • Hospital systems are approaching capacity in some southern and southwestern states.
  • One of the more frustrating elements in monitoring this pandemic has been a surfeit of research papers published, many of dubious value. The media tends to report on the most sensational headlines but almost never touches on the retractions.  China has been publishing a great deal of research; a recent analysis suggests that researchers there are reusing data, which allows for the fast publication of reports that probably don’t add much to the pool of knowledge.
  • Apple and cherry farms usually hire seasonal workers to pick their crops. Reports indicate these workers have been hit by the pandemic, putting the harvest at risk.

China news:

Policy news:

  • One of the issues we are watching carefully is state and local government spending. Unlike Federal government spending, which can be countercyclical, state and local governments are pro-cyclical.  When economic activity slows, state and local governments usually see a decline in revenue with leads to falling spending.  If the Federal government or the Fed refuse to take action to counter this issue, the impact of fiscal and monetary stimulus will be blunted due to a drop in state and local government spending.
  • Sen Hawley (R-MO) proposed a bill to force the U.S. to exit the WTO. Reports indicate that parliamentary maneuvering will prevent the bill from coming to a vote before the elections, sparing incumbents a potentially problematic vote.

Foreign news:

View the complete PDF

Daily Comment (July 2, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Good morning, and happy Thursday!  This is the last trading day of the week before the Independence Day holiday, so there will be no Daily Comment tomorrow; enjoy the holiday!  Global equity markets are higher this morning on improving global economic data.  Due to the holiday, the BLS has put out the employment report.  We cover it in detail below but in short, it was much stronger than forecast.  We recap the Fed minutes and other policy news.  We also look at the pandemic news.  Concerning China, we take a look at the initial response to the new security law in Hong Kong.  In foreign news, Putin “won” his referendum (the outcome was as certain as the Chiefs playing the Raiders).  Here are the details:

Policy news:

  • The Fed released the minutes from the last meeting. Although there were no policy actions taken, there was interest to see what the members were thinking.  There appeared to be a great deal of discussion about forward guidance; this was evident in the dots plot, which showed there would be no change in rates for at least two years.  The members did consider yield curve control; it seems to be in the context of forward guidance, although it was also noted that if the markets were convinced that the Fed would cap rates, it may not need to actually buy a lot of bonds.  Overall, the message was accommodative policy would be in place for a long time.
    • In separate comments, Louis FRB President Bullard warned that the pandemic could still trigger financial problems and thus supported continued broad actions to prop up capital markets.
  • In a surprise move, Congress extended the Paycheck Protection Program to August 8. The program still has unused funds, but the deadline of the original bill was set to expire.  President Trump still needs to sign the extension.
  • So far, the Fed’s Main Street lending program has not attracted much borrowing. Critics suggest the terms are such that distressed borrowers can’t qualify and qualified borrowers are looking elsewhere.  However, its existence will act as a backstop if the financial markets seize up again, and we would not be surprised to see lending terms ease.

COVID-19The number of reported cases is 10,716,063 with 516,726 deaths and 5,499,628 recoveries.  In the U.S., there are 2,686,587 confirmed cases with 128,062 deaths and 729,994 recoveries.  For those who like to keep score at home, the FT has created a nifty interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.  The Axios map has been updated; cases are rising across the country.

Virology: 

  • A recent study out of China suggests that being infected by COVID-19 does not bring long lasting immunity. Antibodies, according to the study, offer immunity for only around eight weeks.  If this study is confirmed (and we note it hasn’t been peer reviewed) it would suggest that immunity passports after contracting the disease would not be a good idea and vaccines may only offer limited immunity.  It may be that COVID-19 vaccines would need to be offered on an annual basis, like influenza.  At the same time, it suggests that a more fruitful approach may be antiviral therapies.
  • At the same time, the BBC reports that a Swedish study showed widespread evidence of T-cells associated with COVID-19. Although this evidence may indicate that a much larger number of people have been exposed to the virus, it isn’t clear if they have gained any immunity from the exposure.
  • COVID-19 may have been with us longer than we thought; some tested in New York had antibodies in February.
  • As we get to know more about the transmission of the disease, the primary vector is extended close contact with an infected person. It is less likely to get it from surfaces and incidental contact.  Large, enclosed gatherings are the primary way that people are catching the disease.
  • As we see an uptick in cases, states and cities are starting closures and restrictions on various businesses.
  • Initially, COVID-19 looked about as problematic as influenza. Although it was novel and humans had little natural immunity, it seemed possible that simply allowing the virus to infect the population and build herd immunity might be a viable plan.  To some extent, this was Sweden’s initial program.  However, as we have watched the disease progress, it appears that the infection is widespread through the body and some of the impact is lasting.  We are starting to see autopsy reports.  These take a while to process but there a now enough to where some patterns can be observed.  First, micro-clotting is being widely seen (of course, in fatalities).  Small clots are being observed in numerous organs, including the brain.  Second, although brains are not showing signs of inflammation (good news, as it suggests the blood/brain barrier is working) the virus does reduce blood oxygen and if it lasts long enough, it can irreparably damage brain cells and is leading to reports of dementia type symptoms in some patients.  This finding may mean patients may need oxygen therapy even if they remain at home.
  • Researchers are monitoring cases of the virus where the victims are facing long recoveries, with some exhibiting signs of permanent impairment. Although articles didn’t discuss this issue, the chance that an infection could lead to permanent impairment is a particular risk to athletes.  Sports teams will need to weigh the potential loss of a star to the disease, or the risk to a prospect.  It is possible that this summer’s limited MLB season could be populated with AAA players.  It will be interesting to see how college sports handles this problem; at least professional players are paid directly whereas college players who become infected could see their careers end before they get the chance to “cash in.”  As we have noted before, college athletics are heavily dependent on football; if the season is lost, it may undermine a myriad of college sports.
  • As we and others have noted, the recent wave of infections is skewing to the younger population. Although they are more likely to survive, albeit with the above section caveats, there are worries that they could become vectors for vulnerable populations.
  • An experimental vaccine that uses a novel gene-based technology has shown some initial promise.
  • After the U.S. announced it was purchasing a large amount of remdesivir, the EU is in talks to secure supplies for Europe.
  • And, finally, on fears of COVID-19, North Korea took aggressive steps to seal its borders. This action has led to a sharp decline in defections.

China news:

Economic news:

  • There is a cottage industry in economics about what the shape of the recovery will be. Our take is that the recession will end soon (it may be already) but the recovery will be slow.  One new shape that has been suggested is a square root; a sharp bounce followed by flat growth.
  • For the past few years, we have noted that the U.S. coastal real estate markets have benefited greatly from foreign buyers. We could see another wave due to the exodus from Hong Kong.  However, in recent months, it does appear that the buying from overseas is slowing.
  • One industry that has been booming on pandemic fears, and supported by recent presidential polling, is firearms.

Technology news:

Foreign news:

View the complete PDF

Daily Comment (July 1, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

A slew of purchasing managers’ indexes from around the world today show manufacturing activity is either growing again, or declining at a much milder pace than at the initial peak of the coronavirus crisis (see tables below).  However, renewed infection outbreaks and lockdowns are taking the wind out of investors’ sails, as are renewed tensions with China after its imposition of a new national security law on Hong Kong.  We present all the key news below.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 10,501,482 worldwide, with 511,909 deaths and 5,378,800 recoveries.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 2,636,538, with 127,425 deaths and 720,631 recoveries.  Here is the interactive chart from the Financial Times that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population.

Virology

Economic Impact

 

U.S. Policy Response

China-Hong Kong:  The Hong Kong municipal government officially published the text of the new national security law imposed on it by Beijing yesterday, putting the legislation into effect just one hour before today’s 23rd anniversary of Britain’s handover of Hong Kong to China.  The full text of the law, which can be found here, is largely consistent with the hints and summaries provided by Chinese officials over the last few weeks.  In other words, the legislation seems as bad as feared, which will further tamp down anti-China political opposition in Hong Kong and exacerbate tensions with the U.S. and other Western democracies.  Police in Hong Kong today made their first arrests under the law when a group of protestors tried to hold a demonstration marking the 1997 handover of Hong Kong to China.  Under the law,

  • Secessionist, subversive, and terrorist activities against China, or Hong Kong are criminalized beginning today, as are acts of collusion with foreign forces that endanger national security. The collusion offenses include espionage and efforts to impose sanctions against China, or Hong Kong, as well as inciting hatred against the central or local government.  Punishments include jail terms up to life in prison.
  • Any person who commits offenses defined by the legislation are subject to the law’s provisions, even if they are outside Hong Kong and aren’t permanent residents of the territory. It wasn’t clear how this provision would be implemented.
  • China’s central government is empowered to supervise the policing of subversive activities in Hong Kong and, in some cases, intervene directly. Its provisions would supersede Hong Kong legislation should there be inconsistencies between them.
  • A special council formed by Hong Kong officials and led by the city’s chief executive has responsibility for enforcing the law. Their work will be confidential, with decisions not subject to judicial reviews.
  • Within the municipal police force, a special unit will be set up to handle national security cases.  Beyond the police’s usual powers in criminal investigations, the law allows the special police unit to put suspects under secret surveillance with authorization from the city’s chief executive.
  • Hong Kong’s government is also required to strengthen its scrutiny and management of schools, civic organizations, media and the Internet, and use these platforms to educate local residents on matters related to national security.
  • A dedicated central-government office in Hong Kong will oversee national-security affairs, and its personnel are empowered to gather and analyze intelligence, as well as advise and supervise local authorities on security matters. Its personnel won’t be subjected to Hong Kong law when they are carrying out their duties.

China-Hong Kong-United States:  Just after the publication of the new Hong Kong security law, a bipartisan group of U.S. senators and representatives introduced legislation that would offer refugee status to Hong Kong residents at risk of persecution under it.  The legislation would require the State Department to give special status to Hong Kong residents and certain family members who suffered persecution, or have a well-founded fear of it, due to their expression of political opinions, or peaceful participation in political activities. The paperwork could be completed in Hong Kong or in a third country, and refugees would then be able to apply for permanent residency and citizenship. The opportunity, which wouldn’t be restricted by the current U.S. cap on refugees, would be valid for five years from the date of the bill’s passage.

Russia:  The country will finish voting today on a series of constitutional changes that would allow President Putin to run for two more terms in office and stay in power until 2036.  To sweeten the pot, the amendments also include a range of social and nationalist goodies such as guaranteeing social benefits and a ban on “belittling the significance” of Russia’s victory over Nazi Germany in World War II (though voters can only vote for or against the entire package).  And in case that’s not enough to drive participation, posters and mass text messages are promising Muscovites “a million prizes” through raffles in exchange for voting, officials are pressuring public employees to vote and large state companies are offering their own prizes for doing so via QR codes that could be used to track people at polling stations.  A positive outcome for Putin seems little in doubt.

Germany:  Defense Minister Annegret Kramp-Karrenbauer is dissolving a unit of the country’s special forces, known as the Kommando Spezialkräfte (KSK) after some of its members were found to have radical rightwing sympathies.  The KSK will also be restructured and stripped of control over its training.

United States-Mexico-Canada:  The new U.S.-Mexico-Canada (USMCA) trade agreement, which updated the previous NAFTA deal, officially went into effect today.

View the complete PDF

Daily Comment (June 30, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

U.S. risk assets are little changed today as encouraging economic data out of China is being largely offset by reports of renewed coronavirus outbreaks and lockdowns in many key U.S. states and some foreign localities.  At the same time, geopolitics are rising to the forefront again, with China passing its new national security law for Hong Kong and Australia boosting its cyber-defenses against Chinese aggression.  We present all the key news below.

COVID-19:  Official data show confirmed cases have risen to 10,417,063 worldwide, with 509,474 deaths and 5,255,829 recoveries.  In the United States, confirmed cases rose to 2,682,897, with 129,544 deaths and 705,203 recoveries.  Here is the interactive chart from the Financial Times that allows you to compare cases and deaths among countries, scaled by population.

Virology

  • Surging coronavirus cases in California, Arizona, Texas and Florida are reportedly straining hospital systems and maxing out the capacity of their intensive care units.  In Phoenix, where ICU units at several hospitals are already full, some are reportedly refusing to admit patients arriving by ambulance to the emergency room.  When a community’s health system is overwhelmed, it tends to prompt government officials to take action they otherwise wouldn’t take, and it can have a significant negative impact on people’s confidence.  The development could prompt renewed economic restrictions and undermine political support for current incumbents in key localities, so it’s an important risk for the equity markets.
  • Just as Florida and Texas did last week, Arizona has responded to the surge in caseloads and stress on the hospital system by putting its economic reopening into reverse.  Governor Ducey said yesterday that the state would immediately close all bars, gyms and cinemas for at least one month.  Separately, New Jersey halted plans to allow indoor restaurant operations and New York’s governor said he is considering a similar move, while Tennessee’s government said its state of emergency would be extended.  Curiously, even as states continue to stretch their traditional health and welfare responsibilities into stringent economic lockdowns, few of the new announcements touched on the imperfect but much simpler and less costly measure of requiring people to wear facemasks in public.
  • Meanwhile, in Britain, the city of Leicester and surrounding areas have been placed under renewed lockdown in response to a resurgence in COVID-19 cases.  Health Secretary Matt Hancock said non-essential shops had been told to close on Tuesday and schools asked to shut their doors to the majority of their pupils from Thursday.  Classes will remain open for vulnerable children and children of critical workers.
  • In India, the government said schools would stay shut for another month and restrictions would be extended until the end of July on nonessential services and movement of persons in containment zones—coronavirus hot spots where lockdowns are still in effect. A nighttime curfew will also be kept in place across the country.
  • The FDA today will outline its conditions for approving a COVID-19 vaccine, including a requirement that any vaccine be at least 50% more effective than a placebo in preventing the disease.  According to the Wall Street Journal, the agency will also say that a vaccine won’t be approved simply if it leads to antibodies in the bloodstream of patients, on grounds that it is not known what level of antibodies will confer protection.  The guidance will also reportedly say that no vaccine would be approved unless a vaccine company had “clearly demonstrated” proof of a vaccine’s safety and effectiveness through a clinical study.
  • WHO Director General Ghebreyesus warned that the virus pandemic is far from over and the worst could yet come.  He also said the WHO would send a second team to China to investigate the source of the pathogen.

U.S. Policy Response

  • Federal Reserve Chair Powell and Treasury Secretary Mnuchin will testify before the House Financial Services Committee today on the coronavirus crisis and the policies implemented to fight it, as required by economic support legislation passed in March.  According to his prepared remarks, Powell will say that even though the economy appears to have bounced back faster than previously expected, there is still significant uncertainty as to whether the virus will be kept in check and how the economy will grow from here.  If Powell sticks to that theme, it will probably be interpreted as confirmation that monetary policy will remain extraordinarily accommodative, which would be supportive of the markets.

Foreign Policy Response

  • In an effort to build momentum for the European Commission’s proposed €750 billion post-coronavirus recovery fund, which would be financed with common EU debt, German Chancellor Merkel assured the “frugal four” nations opposed to the idea that all EU countries must also be willing to reform their economies and make them more “future-proof.”  Merkel expressed confidence that EU leaders would reach agreement on the fund and on the bloc’s new budget at a summit due to be held in July, although she admitted there is still a “long way to go.”  If Merkel’s gambit helps push the recovery fund forward, it will likely be positive for European assets and negative for the dollar, at least in part because the common EU debt would help create conditions for the euro to eventually become a true reserve currency to rival the greenback.

China-Hong Kong:  In an extraordinary meeting, China’s rubber-stamp legislature gave final approval to a new national security law for Hong Kong and President Xi immediately signed it, though full details are still to be released.  Demonstrating how swiftly the new law is affecting Hong Kong politics, anti-China activist Joshua Wong disbanded his Demosisto opposition party and urged pro-democracy leaders to use “more flexible” methods to resist Chinese influence on Hong Kong.

China-India:  New Delhi announced it would ban dozens of Chinese mobile apps from being downloaded or used in India, citing this month’s China-India border clashes in the Himalayas and the possibility that the apps could be used to monitor and profile Indian citizens.  According to a senior Indian official, “This is India’s first salvo to China after the border clashes, showing that India has a diverse range of retaliatory options.”  The move deprives some of China’s biggest and most important technology firms from accessing India’s large, fast-growing market.  It may therefore encourage similar moves by the U.S. or other countries that are concerned about China’s growing assertiveness.

China-Australia:  The Australian government is recruiting 500 additional cyber spies and making its largest-ever investment in digital security after a breakdown in diplomatic relations with China and mutual allegations of espionage activity.  The investment of almost $1 billion over a decade follows a warning from Prime Minister Morrison that the nation’s government, companies and educational institutions have been under sustained attack from a “sophisticated state actor.”

Russia-Libya:  The Russian government is sending additional fighters, weapons and cash to Libyan opposition leader Khalifa Haftar, who is on the defensive after a failed effort to topple the country’s UN-backed government.  In an effort to maintain influence in the country in case Haftar loses further support, the Russians are reportedly also building relationships with alternative opposition leaders, including Aguila Saleh.

United States:  A nonprofit higher education research organization said overall enrollment at U.S. colleges and universities this spring was down 1.7% from a year earlier, marking the seventh straight year of annual declines.  The drop was most severe for four-year, for-profit institutions and smaller, nonprofit schools.  Many large public and private nonprofit schools saw increased enrollment.

View the complete PDF

Weekly Geopolitical Report – The Geopolitics of the Eurobond (June 29, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady | PDF

(N.B.  Due to the Independence Day holiday, the next report will be published on July 13.)

A global hegemon provides two broad categories of public goods.  The first is security.  A successful hegemon enforces some degree of global security as it has the ability to project power globally.  This power projection ostensibly prevents regional wars from becoming world wars.  Another way of thinking about hegemony is that if a world war occurs, it is evidence of hegemonic failure.  In addition to war suppression, the hegemon’s global reach gives it the capability to secure sea lanes, which facilitates global trade.

The second public good is financial.  The hegemon provides the reserve currency which enables global trade and investment.  The reserve currency nation must have two characteristics to be a successful provider of the reserve currency.  First, it must be willing to run persistent current account deficits.  It is through trade that the rest of the world acquires the reserve currency. Persistent current account deficits put great strain on the labor markets of the hegemon and require a strong commitment from the reserve currency nation to absorb these imports.  Second, it must have deep financial markets and an instrument that is considered safe and widely available so nations that accumulate the reserve currency can use this instrument to hold this saving until it is needed for trade or direct investment.

If the U.S. is going to be replaced as a hegemon, the successor will need to fill these two roles.  Currently, there is no nation that is capable or willing to fully provide these public goods.  However, it is not impossible to consider a situation where a partial replacement occurs.  Such outcomes have occurred before.  By the late 1800s, Britain realized that it could not defend any of its colonies in the Western Hemisphere from a determined American attack.  The U.S. economy was too well developed and its navy and army too large; the costs of defending Canada, for example, would have been excessive.  So, quietly, the British ceded regional hegemony, at least in terms of security, to the U.S.  That allowed Westminster to focus on the other growing threat, Germany.  In the current environment, the U.S. could cede a sphere of influence to China.  It is arguable that the U.S. would like to see a regional hegemon arise in the Middle East to allow America to reduce its security burden there as well.

Something similar could occur on the reserve currency front as well.  Some economists, notably Barry Eichengreen, have argued that there is the potential for multiple reserve currencies.  Although we have had doubts about this possibility, recent developments have led us to consider the possibility that the euro could become a serious competitor for the dollar as a reserve asset.  That doesn’t mean the euro would replace the dollar as the reserve currency, but it would mean the euro could be a parallel reserve currency and offer competition to the dollar.

The most recent development that could create potential competition for the dollar’s reserve status is the proposed new financial instrument designed to fund Europe’s recovery from the pandemic.  The proposal evolved from a plan developed by Germany and France to create a €500 billion recovery fund.  European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen expanded the proposal, increasing it to €750 billion.  But the key element of the proposal is a specific bond backed by the full faith and credit of the European Union.  The bond service would be tied to several EU-wide revenue sources, including a proposed digital tax, a carbon border tax and fees on transportation.

The proposed plan still requires approval by all members of the EU.  The “frugal four”—Austria, Denmark, the Netherlands and Sweden—could still scuttle the proposal.  But, Germany’s support is a reversal of its longstanding opposition to EU debt mutualization and will probably be enough to sway the opposition toward accepting the program.

The prospect of debt mutualization creates competition for the dollar’s reserve status.  The EU doesn’t fulfill the other requirements for hegemony; its military strength has atrophied, and it has not shown a willingness to run persistent current account deficits.  Nevertheless, a mutualized debt instrument does make the euro a much more attractive currency for reserve purposes.

In this report, we will examine why an alternative reserve currency might be attractive for several countries.  An analysis of why Germany has changed its position on debt mutualization will follow.  As always, we will conclude with market ramifications.

Read the full report

Daily Comment (June 29, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

Good morning, and happy Monday!  U.S. equity futures are currently pointing to a modest rise in a holiday-shortened week.  We update the COVID-19 news.  In foreign news, we cover the Poland elections and a new government in Ireland.  The end of stimulus measures is looming in the U.S.  We update weather news.  Here are the details:

COVID-19:   The number of reported cases is 10,154,984 with 502,048 deaths and 5,147,436 recoveries.  In the U.S., there are 2,549,069 confirmed cases with 125,803 deaths and 685,164 recoveries.  For those who like to keep score at home, the FT has created a nifty interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.  State infection rates are showing a definite rise.

Virology: 

  • We have been monitoring reports that the virus may be mutating. A paper out of China suggests that COVID-19 has indeed mutated from its form in China to a more virulent form in Europe.  A mutation, named D614G, increases the number of spikes on the virus, enhancing its ability to infect.  The mutation has made the virus more contagious by increasing its shedding.   This development may explain why the virus initially seemed to be about as problematic as influenza and has become something worse.  There are also reports that the virus has developed in such a way that it sends out “fingers” that increase the pace of infection.
  • Last week, in the face of rising infections, Texas and Florida took the aggressive actions to close bars, ban the sale of alcohol consumption and limit restaurant seating.   The population infected in the South does appear different than what we saw in the Northeast.  The current infections are hitting younger Americans and thus we are seeing fewer fatalities per infection.
  • Doctors are finding that even asymptomatic patients with COVID-19 are showing signs of lung damage. How serious the damage is remains uncertain.
  • Health officials are considering a new testing strategy, pool testing. In a pool test, a single test is administered to a group of people.  If all test negative, it is assumed the entire pool is infection free.   This method allows for a much larger testing base with the same level of resources, and, with careful sorting, can even increase the power of the testing.  It has two downsides.  First, a false negative means a much larger problem because it means the entire pool is considered safe, but it may not be.  Second, the process of pooling itself can dilute the sample, increasing the odds of a false negative.
  • There is evidence that COVID-19 is causing psychiatric and neurological problems in patients. The symptoms include strokes, encephalitis, and encephalopathy.  Some patients exhibited evidence of dementia and psychosis.
  • There remains hope that a vaccine will be developed by late 2020. We remain skeptical that it will occur in this short time frame.  However, a vaccine isn’t the only path to reducing the risk of the virus.  Antiviral treatments could also reduce the virulence of the disease; AIDS has been controlled by this path.  Three[1] new anti-viral drugs are being tested; all three are currently used in treating cancer, so if they work on COVID-19, they could be deployed rapidly.

Policy news:

China news:

  • China has been aggressively building out its 5G network. Although the U.S. has been working to reduce Chinese tech firms’ ability to sell 5G products abroad, China also needs to import products for its domestic build out.  Apparently, Japanese firms have been aiding this effort.  We will be watching to see if Washington takes steps to end this practice.
  • The PBOC is promising to take stronger measures to support the Chinese economy.

Technology news:

Foreign news:

  • Andrzej Duda won a plurality in this weekend’s election in Poland but not a majority. A second round of elections will be held on July 12th, where he will face Warsaw Mayor Rafał Trzaskowski, who won second place.
  • Ireland has a new PM, Macheal Martin; he will govern a three-party coalition of Fianna Fail, Leo Varadkar’s Fine Gael and the Green Party. Sinn Fein, the political arm of the IRA, will be the official opposition.  The current PM, Varadkar, will be deputy PM and will take over the PM jog in 30 months.   This is a “grand coalition” of sorts; for the first time since the founding of the modern Irish republic, Fianna Fail and Fane Gael will form a coalition.  This is mostly because neither could agree to form a government with Sinn Fein.
  • Russia is increasing its arms sales to Turkey and India. The former is a member of NATO and a long-time U.S. ally; the arms relationship with Russia has been an unwelcome development.  India, on the other hand, is a long-term client of Russia’s arms industry but is being courted by the U.S. in a bid to contain China.  The arms sales will likely not cause problems for New Delhi, but we would expect U.S. arms makers to try and encourage India to begin using U.S. platforms.  This will be especially the case if relations become closer.
  • Despite U.S. opposition, it appears the EU will be moving ahead to implement digital taxes. The U.S. opposes this move because it is seen as a threat to the American tech firms.
  • The EU has also slapped tariffs on an Egyptian fiberglass firm that was built in conjunction with the Chinese “one belt, one road” project.  This action will be seen as a snub to Beijing.
  • Lebanon is in the midst of a debt and currency crisis. The currency has lost 75% of its value in the unofficial market and its external debt is over 186% of GDP and the country is in default.  Demonstrations took place late last week to protest declining living conditions.  Although the level of anger is palpable, it is not clear at all how the situation will be resolved.
  • The State Department says Iran has become a haven for al Qaeda. Although we doubt much will come from this news, it could be used as a pretext for retaliation, either kinetic or financial, by the U.S.
  • Late last year, Congress passed the Caesar Act, makes sanctions mandatory for anyone who facilitates the Assad regime’s acquisition of goods and services among other actions that support the current regime in Syria.  The U.S. has begun implementing that act, putting additional sanctions on Syria and could add more to Iran as well.  Lebanon will also face a sanction threat from the law. The other important characteristic of the Caesar Act is that it applies sanction pressure directly on Syrian Alawites, the base of Assad’s support.
  • We are monitoring reports of elevated levels of radioactive particles in Northern Europe.  The current levels are not a health risk but the inability to pinpoint the source is a worry.  There are concerns that the elevated levels may signal a problem due to a Russian nuclear power facility, Russia claims that no problems exist.

View the complete PDF

[1] https://xospata.com/, https://ascopubs.org/doi/abs/10.1200/JCO.2019.37.15_suppl.5537, https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/senhwa-biosciences-silmitasertib-named-as-potential-covid-19-therapy-301032362.html

Daily Comment (June 26, 2020)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT]

The 13th episode of the Confluence of Ideas podcast is available; it is our first in a series of episodes on the November elections.  Additionally, there is something new!  As usual, we have a new Asset Allocation Weekly in today’s report (which we also post as standalone report), but we are adding two new features to this report: an associated podcast and an automated chartbook!  Check them out!

Good morning and happy Friday!  Equity futures are mostly marking time this morning.  Personal income and spending are out today; we detail the numbers below.  In the economics section, we look at the drop in global trade and the problem of college sports.  There was news on banking policy; we go over the details below, but, in short, “the Fed giveth and the Fed taketh away.”  China had something akin to a bank run.  We update the pandemic, including the “Duff’s map.”  We also take a look at tech.  Here are the details:

Economic news:

Policy news:

China news:

  • Chinese households, like their counterparts in Japan, Europe and the U.S., have been in search of yield for their savings. In China, trust companies have emerged to satisfy this demand.  The industry holds CNY 21.0 trillion ($3 trillion); it is estimated that around CNY 625 billion of these assets are distressed.  However, financial institutions that are sound can face liquidity problems if depositors demand liquidity simultaneously.  Small scale protests have broken out in Chengdu, Sichuan, after Sichuan Trust told investors that it would “struggle to make principal and interest payments” on about CNY 13 billion of assets.  China’s debt growth has been of concern for some time.  It has been noted that Chinese policy support from the pandemic has been modest compared to what we saw after the Financial Crisis, leading to concerns about China’s debt capacity.  This situation bears watching; if Chinese investors begin to fear the stability of the financial system, we could see purchases of bitcoin, gold and capital flight.

COVID-19:  The number of reported cases is 9,632,969 with 489,854 deaths and 4,859,744 recoveries.  In the U.S., there are 2,422,312 confirmed cases with 124,415 deaths and 663,562 recoveries.  For those who like to keep score at home, the FT has created a nifty interactive chart that allows one to compare cases across nations using similar scaling metrics.  Additionally, one way of monitoring reopening is by the number of beer taps operated relative to capacity, or as we like to call it, the “Duff’s map.”

Virology:

Technology news:

Foreign news:

View the complete PDF