Daily Comment (September 14, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning! Today’s Comment is split into three sections: 1) Why rising energy prices will complicate the Fed’s efforts to project future policy rates; 2) Why European policymakers may be finished with their hiking cycle; and 3) Why the green transition is leading governments to push for more domestic manufacturing.

Where Do They Stand? The disappointing consumer price index (CPI) report may lead to further divisions within the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC).

  • Rising energy prices pushed headline CPI above expectations in August, leading investors to adjust their interest rate expectations. Consumer prices rose 3.7% from the previous year, above economists’ expectations of 3.5% and July’s reading of 3.3%. The rise was driven by a 5.6% surge in petrol prices from the previous month, which accounted for more than half of the month-over-month increase. Energy prices have picked up following efforts by Saudi Arabia and Russia to prop up oil prices through production cuts. The sudden reversal of inflationary pressures has led to investors’ pricing in a near 50% chance of another hike by the end of the year.
  • Despite the recent surge in headline inflation, there are some encouraging signs that underlying inflation pressures may be easing. The year-over-year change in core CPI, which excludes food and energy, fell from 4.7% to 4.3% in August. Meanwhile, the frequently cited core services inflation, which excludes goods and shelter, also eased in August, declining from 3.3% in July to 3.1%. Additionally, supercore inflation, which excludes food, shelter, and energy, rose by 2.2% in the same period but was modestly above its 20-year historical average of 1.9%. Therefore, there is still a case for the Fed to stand pat, at least for now.

  • The latest CPI report is unlikely to have a significant impact on the FOMC’s decision of whether to keep interest rates unchanged during its next meeting on September 19-20. Although policymakers have not commented on how they would vote in the meeting, members have expressed concern regarding the level of tightness in the labor market. The committee is 25 bps shy of meeting its fed funds target outline in the latest dot plots. As a result, we will be paying close attention to the latest FOMC projection materials and Fed speeches for evidence of the committee’s thinking on future rate hikes.

Policy Pushback: Economic woes are prompting policymakers to reconsider rate hikes amid slowing output and lawmaker complaints.

  • The European Central Bank (ECB) raised its benchmark policy rates by 25 bps on Thursday. The increase comes amidst signs that inflation is starting to return to normal but still remains well above the central bank’s 2% mandate. Despite the decision to tighten monetary policy, markets believe that the central bank is likely finished hiking rates. During the press conference, ECB president Christine Lagarde suggested that rates are currently in sufficiently restrictive territory but stopped short of ruling out an additional hike. As a result, the euro (EUR) fell against the USD and Japanese yen (JPY).
  • Unlike the United States, the eurozone economy is more fragile, partly due to its greater reliance on exports, which are being hurt by China’s economic slowdown. European Central Bank officials downgraded their growth expectations for the next three years and hinted at the possibility of recession. At the same time, high interest rates have hurt manufacturing activity throughout the bloc, with industrial production falling 2.2% from the prior year in August. These troubles are not likely to go away anytime soon as the ECB projects that rates will likely stay above 3% in 2024, making it harder for them to justify rate cuts.

Return of the Industrial State? Governments are becoming more assertive in protecting domestic industries as the world begins to fracture into blocs.

(Source: Wikimedia Commons)

  • Governments in advanced economies are likely to play a more active role in the economy than investors are used to, reflecting a long-term trend of supporting domestic firms to compete with foreign competitors. This is already evident in the Inflation Reduction Act, which uses tax subsidies to build domestic manufacturing in the U.S., and in similar incentives offered by the EU. While this shift may help businesses subsidize their research efforts, it could also lead to higher inflation and borrowing costs due to inefficiencies associated with firms being unable to use outside suppliers.

View PDF

Weekly Energy Update (September 14, 2023)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA | PDF

Oil prices have continued their rise, with WTI trending towards $90 per barrel.

(Source: Barchart.com)

Commercial crude oil inventories rose 4.0 mb, compared to forecasts of a 2.0 mb draw.  The SPR rose 0.3 mb which puts the net build at 4.2 mb (the discrepancy is due to rounding).

In the details, U.S. crude oil production rose 0.1 mbpd to 12.9 mbpd.  Exports declined 1.8 mbpd, while imports rose 0.8 mbpd.  Refining activity rose 0.6% to 93.7% of capacity.

(Sources: DOE, CIM)

The above chart shows the seasonal pattern for crude oil inventories.  Last week’s rise is mostly consistent with expected seasonal increases in crude oil stockpiles.  However, the sharp drop in exports is a bit of a puzzle and if reversed next week, inventories could remain tight.

Fair value, using commercial inventories and the EUR for independent variables, yields a price of $73.30.  Commercial inventory levels are a bearish factor for oil prices, but with the unprecedented withdrawal of SPR oil, we think that the total-stocks number is more relevant.

Since the SPR is being used, to some extent, as a buffer stock, we have constructed oil inventory charts incorporating both the SPR and commercial inventories.

Total stockpiles peaked in 2017 and are now at levels last seen in late 1985.  Using total stocks since 2015, fair value is $94.95.

Market News:

  • The executive director of the IEA issued an editorial in the Financial Times where he forecast peak oil and natural gas demand would occur by the end of the decade. The increase in EVs and renewables is expected to supplant fossil fuels.  Obviously, we won’t know for sure if he is correct for a few years, but this position does affect behavior.  Oil and gas firms have already shifted their focus from growth to providing return to shareholders and owners.  After all, how does one justify expanding production that may simply be stranded?  On the other hand, if he is wrong, and demand continues to grow, the behavior of firms increases the likelihood of much higher oil prices.
  • Russian refineries are planning seasonal maintenance that will allow for more oil exports but will also curtail product exports. It will be interesting to see if Russia maintains its promise to restrict oil supplies in light of this seasonal situation.
  • Although the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s (KSA) production restrictions have supported oil prices recently, it will almost certainly weaken the economy. That’s in part due to increasing Iranian exports and rising Guyana production that will reduce the KSA’s market share.  We don’t expect a change in Saudi production this year, but we wouldn’t be surprised to see an attempt to regain market share next year.
  • U.S. shale producers are trying to impress investors with their improved efficiency. In the past, it was all about production, but now there is a focus on profitability.  One measure of efficiency is the length of drilling laterals; in other words, getting more oil from each wellhead.
  • As the odds of an Australian LNG strike loom, Chevron (CVX, $165.59) is likely to deploy a legal strategy to avert a work stoppage. Workers have already went on strike to signal their resolve.  There is an element of Australian law that suggests that if two sides in a labor dispute are hopelessly deadlocked, one side can petition for arbitration and work continues.  It is apparently untested, and we would be surprised if the courts give Chevron an out.

Geopolitical News:

Alternative Energy/Policy News:

  View PDF

Daily Comment (September 13, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with the latest news on souring relations between the West and China.  We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including the latest on the Russia-Ukraine war and U.S. inflation and banking dynamics.

United States-China:  The House Select Committee on the Chinese Communist Party has been holding hearings and meetings on Wall Street this week to put further pressure on U.S. financial and business elites who have been reluctant to sever ties with China.  In a statement that we think investors should heed, the Republican chairman of the committee, Mike Gallagher of Wisconsin, and the Democratic vice-chairman, Raja Krishnamoorthi of Illinois, both said they favor new laws to restrict U.S. investment in publicly traded stocks and bonds of certain Chinese firms.

  • The new legislation mentioned by Gallagher and Krishnamoorthi would go beyond the current U.S. restrictions on bilateral trade, investment, and technology flows, illustrating the risks to investors as U.S.-China geopolitical tensions worsen.
  • As a reminder that China is also clamping down on bilateral business, the Chinese government today said it has “noticed reports” of “security incidents” related to iPhones made by U.S. technology giant Apple (AAPL, $176.30). The government emphasized that it is still committed to protecting the rights of foreign businesses and supporting free markets.  Nevertheless, since the statement followed so closely on Beijing’s recent directive which curbed the use of iPhones by certain government workers, it is being taken as a warning that China is prepared to undermine key U.S. economic interests to retaliate for the U.S. pushback.

European Union-China:  As advanced, low-cost electric vehicles from China start to flood Europe’s auto market, European Commission President von der Leyen today announced that she is launching an investigation into the subsidies paid to Chinese producers.  Complaining that European-made autos are often blocked from other markets, von der Leyen signaled Brussels will take a tough approach on subsidized Chinese EVs.

  • The move is a reminder that von der Leyen and other leaders in Europe have swung behind the U.S. effort to push back against China’s growing geopolitical and economic aggressiveness.
  • In response to von der Leyen’s speech, shares in high-flying Chinese EV companies have fallen sharply today, with Warren Buffett-invested BYD (BYDDY, $65.62) losing 2.8% of its value and rival Xpeng (XPEV, $18.65) losing about 2.5%.

United Kingdom-China:  Just days after British police said they had arrested two people, including a parliament researcher, on charges of spying for China, press reports say the authorities are preparing to arrest several more people in the coming months on charges that they have been secretly working to undermine Britain’s democracy under the direction of the Chinese government.  The news points to a further rupture in China-U.K. relations, which could potentially include new, U.S.-style restrictions on bilateral trade, investment, and technology flows.

Russia-North Korea-Ukraine:  Russian President Putin and North Korean Supreme Leader Kim met today at a Russian space-launch facility in Vladivostok, with both pledging to deepen their cooperation on security and economic issues.  The two leaders are widely expected to strike a deal under which North Korea will sell weaponry to Russia to help it continue its invasion of Ukraine.

Sweden:  The center-right government this week proposed a 2024 budget that would hike military spending by approximately 28%.  The proposed budget would put Sweden on track to meet the North Atlantic Treaty Organization’s standard of spending at least 2% of gross domestic product on defense, even though the country is still waiting to be accepted into the alliance.

U.S. Military:  U.S. Air Force Secretary Kendall has announced that the service will miss its annual recruiting goal by about 10% when the fiscal year ends on September 30, marking the first such shortfall since 1999.  The deficit shows how most of the military is struggling to keep up troop levels because of factors such as the strong civilian job market, lingering disruptions from the coronavirus pandemic, and difficulties in finding enough young people who can meet today’s physical and intellectual standards.

U.S. On-Line Prices:  While investors today will focus on the headline Consumer Price Index (see U.S. Economic Releases below), a separate private index shows on-line prices are falling in year-over-year terms.  The Adobe Digital Price Index for August was down a full 3.2% from the same month one year earlier, including annual price declines of 7.3% for appliances, 7.0% for sporting goods, and 11.6% for electronics.

U.S. Banking Industry:  Incoming data shows net new bank lending has slowed to a crawl, with outstanding loans growing at an annualized, seasonally adjusted rate of just 3.6% so far in the third quarter, compared with average growth of about 7.0% over the long term.  Of course, part of the slowdown reflects weaker loan demand now that the Federal Reserve has hiked interest rates so aggressively since last year.  In addition, however, the slow growth reflects cautious lending as banks worry about rising deposit costs and asset values.  Importantly, slow lending could also help to finally push the economy into the recession that we’ve been expecting all year.

View PDF

Daily Comment (September 12, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Today’s Comment opens with a discussion of new irritants in the China-India relationship and what they mean for investors.  We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including indications that the Bank of Japan could end its negative interest-rate policy by year’s end and signs of progress in the negotiations for new labor contracts in the U.S. auto industry.

India-China:  India yesterday imposed anti-dumping tariffs on some Chinese steel imports, responding to a flood of foreign steel and complaints from local producers in recent months.  From April through July, government data shows steel imports into India were up 23% from the same period one year earlier, with imports from China alone up 63%.  The anti-dumping duties are scheduled to last for five years.

Chinese Economy:  Two of the largest cities in Shandong province, China’s second-most populous region, said they have lifted their restrictions on home purchases.  That adds to the list of major local governments in China that have taken steps to boost their housing markets after being encouraged to do so by the central government.  Nevertheless, the piecemeal regulatory moves are widely viewed as insufficient to spark a significant improvement in home purchases or general economic growth.

Chinese Military:  Satellite imagery and social media posts show a large, nearly completed new drydock and basin at a major shipyard known for producing China’s top amphibious assault vessels.  The new facilities suggest Beijing has given the order to move forward with the construction of its massive, new Type 076 “landing helicopter docks.”  The new LHDs will be able to launch both helicopters and drones, aided by state-of-the-art electromagnetic catapults like those on China’s newest aircraft carrier and the U.S.’s new Gerald Ford-class carriers.

  • Even though China already has the world’s largest navy, the new LHD program shows that Beijing intends to expand it further and increase its capabilities in preparation for a potential takeover of Taiwan and/or war with the U.S. On a related note, the Chinese navy today is launching its biggest-ever exercise with an aircraft carrier in the waters around Taiwan, the Philippines, and Guam.
  • We continue to believe that China’s unceasing military buildup and modernization program will spark ever-greater concerns among Western officials, drowning out those business elites who argue for maintaining trade and investment ties with China. The result will be further risk for those who invest in companies based in China or who are dependent on the Chinese market.

Japan:  In a recent press interview, Bank of Japan Governor Ueda said his policymakers could be in a position to end their negative interest-rate policy by the end of the year, so long as there is continued growth in the country’s consumer prices and wage rates.  Coupled with the BOJ’s recent decision to allow longer-term bond yields to fluctuate more widely, the statement provides further confirmation that the policymakers are edging toward tighter monetary policy after years of extraordinarily loose policy.

  • In response, the yield on longer-term Japanese government bonds has climbed smartly in recent days. The yield on the benchmark 10-year JGB yesterday closed at 0.705%, up from 0.589% one month ago and 0.251% one year ago.
  • The value of the Japanese currency has also sharply appreciated. The JPY yesterday closed at 146.51 per dollar ($0.0068), for an appreciation of almost 1.0% from its level just one week ago.

United Kingdom:  In the three months ended in July, average wages excluding bonuses were up a record 7.8% year-over-year, while average total pay was up 8.5%.  The figures show British pay has now grown faster than the 6.8% rise in the consumer price index over the last year, which should boost consumer purchasing power and tempt the Bank of England to hike interest rates further.  On the other hand, the monetary policymakers will be concerned about a separate report today showing that in the three months to June, the value of residential mortgage in arrears was up a full 28.8% year-over-year, as rising interest rates put pressure on homeowners with floating-rate mortgages.

Libya:  Mediterranean Cyclone Daniel has devastated areas of coastal Libya, causing massive flooding and at least 5,000 deaths.  Libya is not a major economy, but the destruction could drive more Libyans toward migrating to Europe, potentially causing a new, politically divisive migration crisis in that important economy.

U.S. Bond Market:  New data from LSEG shows corporate bonds issued so far in 2023 will come due in an average of 10.0 years, marking the shortest average maturity in more than a decade.  The average maturity for investment-grade bonds has fallen to about 10.5 years, while the average for junk bonds has fallen to 6.0 years.  The shorter maturities suggest firms are betting that the Federal Reserve will soon be cutting interest rates.

U.S. Defense Industry:  As we’ve tracked rising U.S.-China tensions and resulting growth in U.S. defense budgets, we’ve noted that the relatively small, post-Cold War defense industrial base is bumping up against capacity constraints that are slowing the effort to rebuild allied defenses.  However, recent articles in Defense News illustrate how the Defense Department is helping address those problems.

  • To accelerate the output of submarines, for example, the Navy since 2018 has spent some $2.3 billion on initiatives such as:
    • Promoting “strategic outsourcing,” which removes bottlenecks by shifting heavy subcomponent manufacturing out of the shipyards, and with those modules produced elsewhere, the shipyards can focus on final assembly, outfitting, and testing;
    • Providing funds to help expand and modernize the two existing shipyards that produce ballistic missile submarines and attack submarines; and
    • Expanding the supplier base by providing capital investment funds to smaller private firms so they can begin producing submarine-certified components.
  • As these examples illustrate, the effort to expand the defense industrial base will help feed the re-industrialization of the U.S. economy that we’ve been writing about. As we’ve argued, re-industrialization will likely boost investment prospects in the industrial sector.

U.S. Auto Industry:  Automaker Stellantis (STLA, $18.69) said it has made progress in its negotiations for a new labor contract with the United Auto Workers, just days before the Thursday expiration of the current contract and the potential start of a disruptive strike.  The referenced progress probably relates, at least in part, to the company’s industry-leading offer of a 14.5% pay raise and the UAW’s modest cut in its demands to a pay hike of about 35%.  Still, UAW chief Shawn Fain complained that Stellantis and the other major automakers have waited until the last moment to make their economic offers, indicating he will keep up pressure on the firms in the hope of extracting large pay increases and other benefits.

Global Oil Market:  Fatih Birol, chief of the International Energy Agency, argues in an opinion article today that the world is coming to the end of the fossil fuel era, as the agency for the first time forecasts that global demand for petroleum oil, natural gas, and coal will peak before 2030.  According to Birol, the new, earlier forecast for peak consumption of fossil fuels can be attributed to the greater-than-expected investments in renewable energy projects over the last year.

View PDF

Daily Comment (September 11, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Our Comment today opens with news about Chinese domestic politics and the country’s currency, the renminbi.  We next review a wide range of other international and U.S. developments with the potential to affect the financial markets today, including news of a cut in the European Union’s economic growth forecast and increased concerns about a potential federal government shutdown in the U.S.

Chinese Domestic Politics:  According to insider reports, influential Communist Party officials unexpectedly warned President Xi at their annual Beidaihe leadership retreat that if China’s political, economic, and social turmoil continues without any effective countermeasures being taken, the party could lose public support, posing a threat to its rule.  The reports say Xi was stunned by the reprimand and bitterly complained about it to his confidential advisors afterward.

  • The reports could help explain why Xi failed to attend the Group of 20 (G20) summit in India over the weekend, why he missed a key speech at the recent BRICS summit, and why he appears to be backing away from a visit to the U.S. later this month.
  • Rather than expressing his disdain for U.S.-founded international organizations, as pundits have suggested, Xi might be pulling back from such meetings to avoid being pressed on Chinese security and economic policies. In other words, Xi may have pulled back from these venues not for deliberate strategic reasons, but because of domestic political challenges.
  • The reports serve as a reminder that Xi must still contend with domestic political pushback against his policies, even if he has done a good job solidifying his power. Going forward, that may force him to temper some of his policies and provide more stimulus to the economy despite his aim to rein in debt and control the private sector.
  • All the same, other reporting suggests he is doubling down on at least some of his initiatives. In several recent speeches, for example, he has urged government officials to prepare for “worst case scenarios” and “extreme circumstances,” which some outsiders have interpreted to mean he is preparing for war with the U.S.

Chinese Economy:  The People’s Bank of China today issued a warning against speculating against the renminbi (CNY), saying PBOC officials “are capable of and feel confident in . . . keeping the renminbi exchange rate at a reasonably stable level.”  In response, the currency has rallied as much as 1.0% to 7.2698 per dollar ($0.1376).  Nevertheless, the renminbi is still trading close to a 16-year low as investors fret over China’s ongoing economic slowdown and worsening tensions with the West.

India:  As foreign investors sour on the Chinese economy, India is reportedly ramping up its infrastructure investment to increase its attractiveness as a place to do business.  For example, the country now has approximately 90,000 miles of national freeways, almost double the mileage one decade earlier.  The expansion and upgrading of India’s infrastructure will probably encourage even more foreign direct investment and portfolio investment.

Japan:  Another Asian country that appears to be benefiting from China’s malaise is Japan.  The Wall Street Journal today carries a useful examination of what’s been driving the Japanese stock market higher after many years in the doldrums.  Besides investors’ shift in focus away from China, the article cites positive developments such as improved corporate governance in the country, recent investments by Warren Buffett, and low valuations.

European Union:  The European Commission today cut its forecast for EU economic growth this year, saying it now expects gross domestic product to grow 0.8% in 2023, rather than the 1.0% it expected in May.  The Commission also said GDP will grow just 1.4% in 2024, down from 1.7% previously.

United Kingdom-China:  In a bilateral meeting between British Prime Minister Sunak and Chinese Premier Li Qiang at the weekend’s G20 summit, Sunak said he personally expressed his “very strong concerns” to Li about China’s interference in the U.K.’s parliamentary democracy.  Sunak’s announcement followed news that British authorities in March arrested two men on charges related to spying for China.  One of those arrested was a long-time researcher in the U.K. parliament who had close contacts with Conservative Party politicians.

United States-Vietnam:  At their weekend summit, President Biden and Vietnamese leader Nguyễn Phú Trọng signed an agreement elevating their countries’ relationship to that of a “comprehensive strategic partnership.”  The agreement lays the groundwork for increased defense cooperation between the countries and establishes a joint semiconductor supply program to boost Vietnamese computer chip manufacturing in support of U.S. businesses.

  • Previously, Vietnam had signed such strategic partnership agreements with only four other countries: China, Russia, India, and South Korea.
  • The deal shows that China’s geopolitical aggressiveness in the South China Sea is pushing Vietnam into Washington’s embrace, just as it has done to the Philippines, and as it is likely to do to other countries in the Indo-Pacific region.
  • Based on our objective methodology for assigning countries to the world’s evolving geopolitical and economic blocs, we currently assess Vietnam to be in the “Neutral” bloc. For example, note that even as Vietnam tiptoes into a closer relationship with the U.S., it is also continuing to seek weapon imports from Russia to build its defense capability against China.  However, if Washington and Hanoi continue to cooperate more closely, Vietnam could eventually shift to the “Leaning U.S.” camp, or even to the “U.S.-led bloc.”

United States-Venezuela:  Rumors that secret talks between Washington and Caracas will lead to détente and reduced economic restrictions have given a boost to Venezuelan bonds recently.  Although the debt still trades at a tiny fraction of its face value, the hope of renewed cross-border investment has pushed the value of the benchmark 2027 bond up above 10 cents on the dollar.

U.S. Household Wealth:  Data from the Federal Reserve shows the net worth of U.S. households and nonprofits rose to a record $154.3 trillion in the second quarter, driven about equally by the rebound in stock prices and rising real estate values.  The rise in net worth comes despite moderating economic growth and concerns about an impending recession.

U.S. Labor Market:  The United Auto Workers union continues to negotiate for a new labor contract with the top three U.S. automakers—Ford (F, $12.30), General Motors (GM, $32.95), and Stellantis NV (STLA, $18.23)—with the current contract expiring Thursday night at midnight.  In simplistic terms, the auto manufacturers want to channel much of their recent profits into new electric vehicles, but the union, with new leverage because of labor shortages, wants them to share their proceeds with employees to make up for significant concessions they granted over the last decade.

U.S. Policymaking:  The House of Representatives is back in session this week after its summer recess, and all eyes are on the increasing frictions between Speaker McCarthy and the right wing of his Republican Party.  The increasing acrimony has raised concerns about a destabilizing leadership battle and the possibility of a partial shutdown of the federal government.  Such a shutdown could happen if the right-wing of McCarthy’s party prevents passage of the appropriations bills needed to fund the government once the current fiscal year ends on September 30.  Coming just as more pandemic stimulus programs are set to end (including the moratorium on student loan payments and subsidies for childcare centers), a government shutdown could help to finally push the economy into the long-expected recession.

View PDF

Asset Allocation Bi-Weekly – Fiscal Tightening Looms (September 11, 2023)

by the Asset Allocation Committee | PDF

To understand the state of the U.S. economy and gauge near-term financial prospects, investors over the last couple of years have focused on issues like the Federal Reserve’s monetary policy, consumer price inflation, labor market indicators, and retail sales.  They seemed to pay much less attention to fiscal policy, except perhaps amid this spring’s Congressional standoff over the federal debt limit.  Our recent work suggests fiscal policy could become a much more important focus in the coming months.  In part, that’s because of the potential for a stalemate in Congress over the budget for the new fiscal year starting October 1.  More generally, it’s also because of the fast-growing budget deficit and looming changes in the government’s income and outlays.

To start out, let’s look at the broad contours of today’s federal budget situation.  In the 12 months ended in July, federal receipts totaled $4.480 trillion, but outlays rose to $6.743 trillion.  The deficit stood at $2.263 trillion.  That shortfall was nowhere near the enormous deficits at the height of the coronavirus pandemic, but it was still much worse than in the prior 12 months.  As shown in the chart below, the expansion in the deficit over the last year reflected both declining receipts and rising outlays.

To understand what’s going on here, let’s first dive deeper into federal revenues.  During the year ended in July 2023, they were down $352.4 billion from the year ended in July 2022, for a decline of 7.3%.  Our analysis shows the decline can be explained entirely by a $408.3-billion drop in individual income taxes, most likely because of lower capital gains taxes after the stock market’s long slide last year, lower wage income as more Baby Boomers and other workers dropped out of the labor force, and an upward adjustment to federal tax brackets because of the price inflation in 2022.  The drop in individual income taxes was partially offset by a modest rise in other receipts, such as Social Security taxes, Medicare taxes, corporate income taxes, and customs duties.

The bigger change came on the spending side of the ledger.  In the year ended July, federal outlays were a whopping $951.8 billion more than in the preceding year, for a rise of 16.4%.  A couple of major outlays fell.  For example, Income Security and Healthcare spending declined modestly.  On the other hand, several big spending types grew sharply.  Because of population aging, a boom in new retirees, and a big cost-of-living increase in Social Security benefits, outlays for Social Security and Medicare grew by a collective $279.6 billion.  In addition, interest outlays were up $182.9 billion from the prior 12 months as outstanding debt grew and interest rates rose.  Most dramatic of all, education outlays ballooned by $453.2 billion compared with the previous 12 months, mostly reflecting the pandemic-era moratorium on student loan repayments and interest.  That moratorium was declared back in March 2020, but final costs of $449.3 billion were recognized only in September 2022, making it look like there was a sudden, temporary spike in education expenditures during that one month (see chart below).

The spike in recognized education expenditures may drop out of the 12-month rolling average beginning with the Treasury report for September 2023, which could then show a drop in spending.  More broadly, as the student loan pause and other big pandemic relief programs come to an end in the coming months, the drop in overall fiscal stimulus could have a noticeable negative impact on demand.  Not only will college graduates lose their student loan subsidies and have to start paying principal and interest again, but daycare centers will lose their operating subsidies, prompting some to close and forcing many, mostly women, out of the workforce.  Of course, the administration’s big, new programs to subsidize infrastructure rebuilding and factory construction will soon begin to pump more money into the economy, but that probably won’t offset all the expiring pandemic outlays.

Without substantial growth in fiscal stimulus in the coming year, a major pillar that has prevented the economy from entering recession will be removed.  Although the tight labor markets from the loss of Baby Boomers and the consequent higher incomes remain as does rising interest income, the drop in fiscal stimulus raises the odds of a downturn in the coming quarters.  Thus, investors need to remain vigilant about a recession, even though the current consensus is calling for continued growth.

View PDF

Daily Comment (September 8, 2023)

by Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA, and Thomas Wash

[Posted: 9:30 AM EDT] | PDF

Good morning! Today’s Comment will be broken down into three sections: 1) Why more central banks are signaling an end to their tightening cycle; 2) How the no-shows by the U.S. and China reflect the waning relevance of multilateral organizations; and 3) Our thoughts on the leader widely expected to succeed AMLO as the president of Mexico.

Peaking Trend: The Bank of Canada has become the first G-7 central bank to signal that it may be nearing the end of its hiking cycle.

  • Bank of Canada Governor Tiff Macklem said that policymakers are nearing success in their battle against inflation. The dovish comments come a day after Canadian policymakers agreed to hold rates steady at 5%. Although inflation remains well above the central bank’s 2% target at 3.3%, the bank’s governor’s change in tone suggests that the policymakers are shifting their stance. This comes amid signs that the labor market is easing, with the unemployment rate increasing for four consecutive months from 5.0% to 5.5%. The bank has said that it is willing to take further action if needed to bring inflation under control.
  • His remarks come as other G-7 central banks are set to meet to discuss their latest policy decisions. The European Central Bank (ECB) has signaled that it is prepared to raise its benchmark interest rate one last time this year, possibly in September, while the Bank of England (BOE) has said that its policy rate is “near the top of the cycle.” Meanwhile, the Federal Reserve is divided on whether more needs to be done to combat inflation, with some officials advocating for one more hike and others hinting that rates are high enough.

  • The world is witnessing a change in monetary policy, with central banks potentially opting for holding rates steady or even cutting them. The Central Bank of Brazil has become the first notable central bank to reverse course on interest rates, cutting them in August for the first time since 2020. This move is likely to be followed by other central banks in the coming months, as global growth shows signs of slowing down. Nevertheless, inflation still remains significantly higher than the targets set by central banks. As a result, the process of easing policy may be more gradual than what investors are accustomed to, as central banks strive to strike a delicate balance between managing the risks of inflation and recession.

Choosing Sides:  The G20 and ASEAN summits wrap up this week with key absences, as prominent world leaders chose not to attend.

  • Chinese President Xi Jinping’s absence from the ASEAN and G20 summits is a notable snub, suggesting that he is becoming increasingly disinclined to engage with countries that do not share China’s worldview. His absence from the G20 is particularly significant, as he has not missed a meeting of the group in over 10 years. This suggests that Xi is cooling on the G20, or at least on the current format of the group. Xi’s replacement at the ASEAN summit, Premier Li Qiang, used the platform to warn countries against taking sides in what he described as a “new Cold War.” China’s recent actions are a clear sign that it is concerned about the growing international pressure and is seeking to isolate itself from groups that do not support its policies.
  • Meanwhile, U.S. President Joe Biden’s absence from the ASEAN summit unnerved some countries and is likely a reflection of his view that the group has not been effective in achieving its goals. The ASEAN declaration states that the group strives to ensure “durable peace, stability, and shared prosperity” in Southeast Asia. However, Myanmar’s military coup and its continued participation in the ASEAN summit are in direct contradiction to this aim. Instead of traveling to Jakarta for the ASEAN summit, Biden will travel to Hanoi, Vietnam, to sign a “comprehensive strategic partnership.” The President’s decision to travel to Vietnam instead of attending the ASEAN summit suggests that he is more interested in building closer relationships with individual countries than with large groups of nations.

  • We believe the world will be split into two camps: the BRICS countries and the G7 countries. The chart above shows that the BRICS countries have been growing at a faster rate than their G7 counterparts since the onset of the pandemic.
  • The decision by the two leaders to skip summits could be seen as a sign of the declining relevance of multilateral organizations. These organizations have often been used to get countries together to resolve their differences. However, recently, they have been seen as being biased towards either the United States or China. The lack of a neutral forum for countries to have dialogue and to prevent the further deterioration of relations raises the likelihood of conflict in the future. At this time, we do not believe that tensions have reached a level that warrants serious concern, but we are monitoring tensions between the U.S. and China closely.

AMLO’s Successor: The Mexican president has chosen his replacement for after his tenure ends in 2024.

  • The biggest question about a Sheinbaum presidency is whether she will be able to establish herself as her own political figure, independent of Andrés Manuel López Obrador. With approval ratings above 60%, it is widely believed that AMLO will try to maintain his influence on the party behind the scenes. The main difference between Sheinbaum and her predecessor is that she supports a transition to nationally subsidized renewable energy, while AMLO favors propping up Mexico’s oil industry. That said, they both agree on the need to protect Mexico’s lithium resources from privatization.

View PDF

Weekly Energy Update (September 8, 2023)

by Bill O’Grady, Thomas Wash, and Patrick Fearon-Hernandez, CFA | PDF

Oil prices have clearly broken out of their trading range, with Brent crude oil moving above $90 per barrel.  Prices are being supported by the Russian and Saudi extension of production restraint.

(Source: Barchart.com)

Commercial crude oil inventories fell 6.3 mb, much lower than the 1.8 mb draw forecast.  The SPR rose 0.8 mb which puts the net draw at 5.5 mb.

In the details, U.S. crude oil production was steady at 12.8 mbpd.  Exports rose 0.4 mbpd, while imports rose 0.2 mbpd.  Refining activity fell 0.2% to 93.1% of capacity.

(Sources: DOE, CIM)

The above chart shows the seasonal pattern for crude oil inventories.  Last week, the continued decline in inventories put stocks well below seasonal norms.  We are nearing the seasonal trough, and if stockpiles continue to decline, it would be a bullish factor for oil prices.

Fair value, using commercial inventories and the EUR for independent variables, yields a price of $74.53.  Commercial inventory levels are a bearish factor for oil prices, but with the unprecedented withdrawal of SPR oil, we think that the total-stocks number is more relevant.

Since the SPR is being used, to some extent, as a buffer stock, we have constructed oil inventory charts incorporating both the SPR and commercial inventories.

Total stockpiles peaked in 2017 and are now at levels last seen in late 1985.  Using total stocks since 2015, fair value is $95.32.

Market News:

Geopolitical News:

Alternative Energy/Policy News:

  View PDF